The Tuesday Top 5

The Tuesday Top 5

Welcome all to the Tuesday Top 5 – grand final edition. This week we look at this weekend’s final match and how the teams got there, we talk Wallabies and go visiting Europe and New Zealand.

The final!

Yes, the inaugural Super Rugby AU champs will be crowned this Saturday night. Unlike other reports I have seen, I refuse to say that whoever wins this will take home their first Super Rugby Championship since (insert appropriate year here), because this comp is not Super Rugby as we have known it. Winning this does not equate to winning Super Rugby with all 12/15/18 teams, this is a new comp and it will have a first-time winner.

Speaking of winning, the team that wins gets to take home … wait for it … the trophy that has in the past been awarded to the team that tops the Aussie conference in Super Rugby. Now I guess that in theory, this is simply the Aussie conference, minus any games against OS teams, but I really thought they would have something different.

I’m not going to do a preview or prediction, there will be enough of that coming up as the week goes on. What I am going to do is do a little comparison, keep in mind any stats from the Reds win over the rebels were taken out so there was a fair comparison in terms of the number of matches played.

Brumbies   Reds
30 (1st) Tries 28 (2nd)
3314 (2nd) Metres 3721 (1st)
932 (3rd) Carries 944 (1st)
70 (2nd) Clean Breaks 83 (1st)
165 (2nd) Defenders Beaten 200 (1st)
1049 (3rd) Tackles 1202 (1st)
116 (5th) Missed Tackles 173 (2nd)
50 (3rd) Turnovers Won 64 (1st)
93 (3rd) Penalties Conceded 90 (4th)
135 (1st) Turnovers Conceded 118 (2nd)


Brumbies   Reds
Tom Wright 5 (=1st) Tries Filipo Daugunu 5 (=1st)
Tom Banks 546 (3rd) Metres Filipo Daugunu 594 (1st)
None in top 10 Carries Filipo Daugunu 94
Tom Wright 14 (1st) Clean Breaks Filipo Daugunu 12 (2nd)
Irae Simone 18 (6th) Defenders Beaten Filipo Daugunu 29 (1st)
Allan Alaalatoa 88 (7th) Tackles Liam Wright 100 (3rd)
For the next categories I could only find the top 5 players.
None in top 5 Missed Tackles Hunter Paisami 22 (1st)
None in top 5 Turnovers Won Fraser McReight 17 (1st)
None in top 5 Turnovers Conceded James O’Connor 15 (1st)

So what do we get out of this? On paper the teams are pretty close, with the Reds probably having the edge. If the Brumbies are to stand a chance they need to shut Daugunu out of the game, not give him room to move.


Wallabies – who gets you pick?

As we are all well aware by now, the Wallabies squad has been announced. There were a couple of surprises, both ins and outs, but they have all been talked to death so I won’t go into that here.

Instead, I am going to give you my 23, if I had to pick right now, based on what I have seen so far in Super Rugby AU. I’m not talking potential, not what I have seen in the past, but what I have seen over the past few weeks. I tried to go for a mix of experience and newbies, making sure that when the rookies are on the field there are also the experienced heads around them.

  1. James Slipper
  2. Folau Fianga’a
  3. Taniela Tupou
  4. Matt Philip
  5. Rob Simmons (experience in the lineout, calling and made a lot of steals this year)
  6. Liam Wright
  7. Fraser McReight
  8. Pete Samu
  9. Jake Gordon
  10. Will Harrison (accuracy off the tee and combination with Gordon)
  11. Filipo Daugunu
  12. Irae Simone
  13. Jordan Petaia (though I would like to see him play more first, string a few 80 minute matches together)
  14. Marika Koroibete
  15. Jack Maddocks
  16. Brandon Paenga-Amosa
  17. Scott Sio
  18. Allan Alaalatoa
  19. Lukhan Salakaia-Loto
  20. Rob Valetini
  21. Nic White
  22. James O’Connor
  23. Tom Wright

Banks, Paisami, Hodge, Lolesio, Wilson, Swinton, Hannigan, Horton, Johnson-Holmes and Fa’amausili are the other players I would rotate in.

Wallabies fans celebrate a try. Photo: Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

Wallabies fans celebrate a try. Photo: Cameron Spencer/Getty Images

About that Bledisloe …

Ok, I am sick of this COVID-19 thing wrecking it for everybody. Crowd restrictions, travel restrictions, not being able to walk and drink at a pub … but now there is more of a fuss going on with the Bledisloe Cup. So the way it seems to be going is that 2 of the Bledisloe matches will be played in NZ before the Rugby Championship is held over here. New Zealand want the 1st game on October 10, while Australia want it on October 17. Doesn’t sound like it would make much difference, does it?  But it’s actually pretty messy. If the 1st match is held on the 17th, it means that the RC will be pushed back and the All Blacks won’t be out of quarantine before Christmas. Apparently some players have indicated they may skip the Rugby Championship if that were to be the case.

BUT if the 1st match is held on October 10, due to the New Zealand Government’s rules, the Wallabies would have to fly out of Australia on Sunday as in in 4 sleeps time. When they arrive in NZ they would be confined to hotel rooms for 4 days, then over the next 10 days group sizes would increase. They would not be able to train together as a team until a week before the first test, while the All Blacks are happily training the entire time.

I don’t know what the answer is, but neither option sound ideal. Like I said, bloody COVID, wrecking it for everyone.

MOTM Beauden Barrett

MOTM Beauden Barrett

Up in the North

On the weekend Leinster took out their 3rd Pro 14 title in a row, defeating Ulster 27-5. They have an insanely impressive record – They went undefeated this season (which began in 2019), including all of their European Champions Cup matches. They have used a massive 53 players this season, showing that they have some pretty decent depth in there too.

The last game they lost was against Saracens, 16 months ago. And it just so happens that they will face Saracens in the Champions Cup quarter final this coming weekend. Saracens will be missing Owen Wilson, who was suspended for 5 weeks after the hit we showed you last week. (It’s lucky he does volunteer work for charity, that got his suspension cut in half!). With all the drama surrounding Saracens, salary caps, relegation etc, it will be interesting to see how the match plays out.

On a side note, I looked up the coach of Leinster to see if there had been consistency there over the past few years, which helped their success. The coach, Leo Cullen is most definitely not a recent appointment. He has a very long history with the club, dating back to 1998 when he was a player. He played for Leinster for until 2005, then again from 2007 until 2014. From there he spent a year as Forwards coach at Leinster before getting the head coaching gig. Now that is definitely an example of an ex player who has shown he can coach.

leinster heineken cup crowd flags


Here are some highlights from different comps around the tracks.

Mitre 10 Cup

Pro 14 Final

Top Tries from the Top 14


Brumbies first, then for the love of the game. "It infuriates me to be wrong when I know I'm right." —Moliere

More in Rugby