• Home
  • Forum
  • Shop
  • Super Rugby
    • ACT Brumbies
    • Melbourne Rebels
    • NSW Waratahs
    • Queensland Reds
    • Western Force
  • Wallabies
    • All Blacks
    • Argentina
    • Barbarians
    • British & Irish Lions
    • England
    • Fiji
    • France
    • Ireland
    • Italy
    • Japan
    • Samoa
    • Scotland
    • Wales
  • Women’s
  • World Cup
    • 2023 Rugby World Cup Fantasy League
  • Sevens
  • Schoolboy
  • Podcast

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

What's Hot

Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA

December 1, 2023

Can we all play together?

November 30, 2023

Moneyball.

November 29, 2023
Facebook Instagram YouTube X (Twitter)
Green & Gold Rugby
0 Shopping Cart
Facebook Instagram YouTube X (Twitter)
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Shop
  • Super Rugby
    1. ACT Brumbies
    2. Melbourne Rebels
    3. NSW Waratahs
    4. Queensland Reds
    5. Western Force
    6. View All

    Friday’s Rugby News – 23/6/23

    June 22, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 12/6/23

    June 11, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News – 9/6/23

    June 9, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/5/23

    May 14, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 8/5/23

    May 7, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/5/23

    May 14, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 8/5/23

    May 7, 2023

    The Reds narrowly defeat the Wild Knights

    November 5, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Thursdays Rugby News 1/6/23

    June 1, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 5/6/23

    June 4, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 29/5/23

    May 28, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/5/23

    May 14, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 8/5/23

    May 7, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday’s Rugby News – A New Dawn

    November 23, 2023

    The Chewsday Chew – anything on LinkedIn?

    November 21, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #16: Roll Up, Roll Up.

    November 20, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #15: Who Dares Wins, unless you’re Rugby Australia.

    November 13, 2023
  • Wallabies
    1. All Blacks
    2. Argentina
    3. Barbarians
    4. British & Irish Lions
    5. England
    6. Fiji
    7. France
    8. Ireland
    9. Italy
    10. Japan
    11. Samoa
    12. Scotland
    13. Wales
    14. View All

    In from the side – one Kiwi’s view of the final and some musings (opinion) on where the game’s at.

    November 2, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #14: There can only be one.

    October 30, 2023

    Final Live Review: New Zealand v South Africa -Saturday 28 October

    October 28, 2023

    The Chewsday Chew – Brotherhood

    October 24, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: Love thy Neighbour?

    October 19, 2023

    Happy and Crescent’s Thursday Rugby News – Broken Faith

    October 19, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #13: RWC Quarter Finals and Australian Coaching Shenanigans!

    October 16, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: ‘Banzai’

    October 12, 2023

    Thursday’s Rugby News 25/5/23

    May 25, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 15/11/21

    November 15, 2021

    Monday’s Rugby News – 20/09/21

    September 20, 2021

    Five observations from the Barbarian match

    November 4, 2014

    Thursdays Rugby News 1/6/23

    June 1, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 13/3/23

    March 12, 2023

    Monday’s Rugby News – 20/09/21

    September 20, 2021

    Thursdays Rugby News

    August 19, 2021

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #13: And then there were Two!

    October 23, 2023

    Game Review: England v South Africa – Semi-Final 2 – Saturday 21 October

    October 22, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: Love thy Neighbour?

    October 19, 2023

    Happy and Crescent’s Thursday Rugby News – Broken Faith

    October 19, 2023

    Happy and Crescent’s Thursday Rugby News – Broken Faith

    October 19, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: ‘Banzai’

    October 12, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Anti Wallaby XV (XXIII)

    October 5, 2023

    Game Review: Fiji v Georgia – Pool C – Saturday 30th September

    October 1, 2023

    Happy and Crescent’s Thursday Rugby News – Broken Faith

    October 19, 2023

    Game Pre/Review: France v South Africa – Quarter-Final 4 – Sunday 15 October

    October 15, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: ‘Banzai’

    October 12, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    Happy Thursday Rugby News – The RWC Myth

    October 26, 2023

    Happy and Crescent’s Thursday Rugby News – Broken Faith

    October 19, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #13: RWC Quarter Finals and Australian Coaching Shenanigans!

    October 16, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: ‘Banzai’

    October 12, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – The Best of the Rest

    October 12, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    Review: France v Italy – Pool A – 6 October 2023

    October 7, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #10: Did we just see the Final?

    September 25, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #15: Who Dares Wins, unless you’re Rugby Australia.

    November 13, 2023

    The Reds narrowly defeat the Wild Knights

    November 5, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – The Best of the Rest

    October 12, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    Game Pre/Review: Japan v Samoa – Pool D – Thursday 28 September

    September 28, 2023

    Game Review: Argentina v Samoa – Pool D – Friday 22 September

    September 22, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #9: David v Goliath

    September 18, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Changing the Narrative

    November 9, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – The Best of the Rest

    October 12, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    Ireland v Scotland: Live Chat

    October 8, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday’s Rugby News – A New Dawn

    November 23, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #13: RWC Quarter Finals and Australian Coaching Shenanigans!

    October 16, 2023

    Friday’s Rugby News: ‘Banzai’

    October 12, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #12: And so the Pool Games come to a close!

    October 9, 2023

    The Chewsday Chew – anything on LinkedIn?

    November 21, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #16: Roll Up, Roll Up.

    November 20, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #15: Who Dares Wins, unless you’re Rugby Australia.

    November 13, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Schadenfreude

    November 2, 2023
  • Women’s

    A personal view

    November 27, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday’s Rugby News – A New Dawn

    November 23, 2023

    WXV 2023 Weekend 3 results

    October 30, 2023

    WXV 2023 Weekend 2 results

    October 22, 2023

    WXV Weekend One Results

    October 17, 2023
  • World Cup
    1. 2023 Rugby World Cup Fantasy League
    2. View All

    Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA

    December 1, 2023

    Can we all play together?

    November 30, 2023

    Moneyball.

    November 29, 2023

    The Chewsday Chew – here’s to the ‘grassrooters’.

    November 28, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #16: Roll Up, Roll Up.

    November 20, 2023

    Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #15: Who Dares Wins, unless you’re Rugby Australia.

    November 13, 2023

    2023 RWC Team Ratings

    November 8, 2023

    The Chewsday Chew – RWC23 Team of the Tourney

    November 7, 2023
  • Sevens

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – Changing the Narrative

    November 9, 2023

    Australia’s Iona College brave but beaten in Rugby Heritage Cup Final

    September 7, 2023

    Brisbane’s Iona College through to the world semi-finals of Rugby Heritage Cup

    September 6, 2023

    Happy Thursdays Rugby News 27/7/23

    July 27, 2023

    Thursday’s Rugby News 20/3/23

    April 20, 2023
  • Schoolboy

    Nudgee College win 44th QLD GPS Rugby Premiership

    September 14, 2023

    Thursday’s Rugby News 24/3/22

    March 23, 2022

    Rugbycology report -Super Rugby AU Round 6

    August 10, 2020

    It all starts with ambition: A schools rugby analysis piece

    August 4, 2019

    Australian Schools Championships – the tradition continues

    July 4, 2019
  • Podcast

    The Dropped Kick-Off 103 – McLennan falls in Coup de Tah

    November 20, 2023

    The Dropped Kick-Off 102 – Upsetting Municipal Councils (+ RWC 2023 GF) w Yowie

    October 24, 2023

    The Dropped Kick-Off 101 – A Little Bit Of Chaos w Happyman

    October 12, 2023

    Happy’s Thursday Rugby News – The Best of the Rest

    October 12, 2023

    The Dropped Kick-Off 100 – Here Comes The Fozz w KARL (World Cup Bites II)

    October 6, 2023
Green & Gold Rugby
Home»National Rugby Championship»NRC law changes – are they working?
National Rugby Championship

NRC law changes – are they working?

Lee GrantBy Lee GrantSeptember 16, 201414 Comments0 Views
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp VKontakte Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

How are the NRC law variations and other changes working?

After four rounds, nearly halfway through the pool stages, it’s time to have a look.

It’s also worthwhile to consider what the prospect is for these changes being adopted by World Rugby at a higher level.

Nothing will be changed before the Rugby World Cup next year anyway, which means that the NRC can trial them for two seasons before they can be tested in a professional environment, most likely in 2016 Super Rugby.

Scoring changes

In the NRC penalty goals and drop goals are valued at two points (instead of three); conversions are three points (two).

Changing the scoring system in some way was the number one request from the public when an NRC panel asked for ideas. It sounded like a no-brainer so that more tries would be scored and fewer penalties attempted.

How’s it working?  If more tries  was the aim, it worked a treat: penalty shots have been like silent halfbacks: rare.  In Round 3, for example, there were only four penalty goals attempted—one per match.  In Round 4 none were attempted.

Mind you, the score was 2-2 at one stage in a game at Coogee Oval, when the ball and ground was so wet the teams had trouble scoring tries.

At first there was too much hot-potato off-loading trying to get the ball wide to score tries, rather than trucking it up to earn the right to do so first. There was some white-line fever from 40 metres out also—but all this moderated over four rounds.

After four rounds, 141 tries were scored in the 16 games—an average of nearly nine per match.  Competition leaders Melbourne Rising were averaging eight per game by themselves.

.
Leichhardt scoreboard – 3 points for conversions

Will this go further?   No.

If most Aussies had their way it would, because it encouraged high tempo rugby and stopped the time wasting from kicking penalty goals. In the future it would help to increase Super Rugby crowds also.

But a few naysayers thought, even after enjoying NRC games, that there was no need to change a scoring system that was already nicely balanced.

Their arguments in our forums against the scoring changes included:

• The fabric of the game was affected.

• If high-tempo rugby and more tries were wanted they could be attained with the scoring system as it was if players and teams were good enough; and if they weren’t, they should be trained to become so.

• Although there hadn’t been too much cynical play defending at the goal line in the NRC, there would be in professional rugby, right? Pro teams would give up two points to save eight, because referees were always too shy giving out yellow cards, weren’t they?

• The powers-that-be in the northern hemisphere, where rugby is played in bad conditions two months of the year, and sometimes three, wouldn’t be interested in approving changes that encouraged racehorse rugby, would they? There were too many draught horses in their player stables for starters. The French would hate it: they loved their grinding rugby.

• So, why develop players in a false environment?

Bonus points for tries

Instead of getting a try bonus point after scoring four tries, teams have to score three more tries than their opponents do to get one.

This means that only one team can get a bonus point for tries in a game; so it rewards defence more than the standard system does.

In 2010 the Chiefs beat the Lions 72-65 in the Super 14 with the sides scoring nine tries each—and the Lions got two bonus points. Both teams should have been docked a point for crap defence.

How’s it working?  OK – because nobody is talking about it. Maybe that’s one to look at near the end of the competition.

Will this go further?  There’s a good chance that it will, but the Poms may not like it simply because the French have had the system for years. There’s history there.

.
The TMO could have been asked about this one

TMO protocol

The TMO protocol was changed back to how it was.

Amen. I was the first to applaud the new system in 2013 to rule on, for example, forward passes when a try was scored, because I had seen it work in the Top 14. People said that it would slow the game down but I replied that no, it wouldn’t, because you scarcely knew the protocol was in operation in France because it was used sparingly.

How wrong was I?

What happened? Once the TMO protocol was changed referees around the world over-used it and there was an outbreak of conservatism as referees tried to out-TMO the others. Even the French referees escalated their use of the TMO in the Top 14 because the rest of the world was doing so.

Wayne Barnes and a few others started making their own TMO decisions based on what they saw on the big screen to speed things up, which made everybody happy except the people selling beer at the ground.

How’s it working?  Great in the TV games—as expected. At least the change in 2013 demonstrated how dud it was in practice; never to return.

Will this go further? Certainly—the clubs in the Aviva Premiership hate the present system and that is always a good sign that a change will be accepted.

Moreover I noticed that in Round 1 of the Aviva Premiership that the referees weren’t using the TMO in regard to how the ball was coming out of the hands in try-scoring movements, which was dumb from day one; so they will be conditioned to change the protocol back to how it was.

.
Contested NRC lineout – but was it straight?

Not straight throws

Skew throws to the lineout that aren’t contested near where the ball is thrown to, are ignored in the NRC provided they are credible throws: not to the outside shoulder, or worse.

Once the proposed variations were put before the public this was voted number one.

How’s it working?  Great. I suspect that defending teams are opposing more now so that the throwing teams don’t get a leg up.

Will this go further?  It has a good shot after the northerners try it out first.

There were a few underarm throws in the NRC straight to the belly of first man in the front of the lineout; which gave the front defender no time to contest. This won’t go down well north of the equator nor in the RSA.

Some folks will say that lineout throwing is a skill that shouldn’t be corrupted: look what’s happened in the NRC—they turned an openside flanker (Lala Lam) into a hooker, for crying out loud. And by the way: that is another chance for the sneaky Aussies to dodge a scrum, the cunning bastards.

1 2
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp Email
Previous ArticleDwyer’s View: Campo mark II?
Next Article Tuesday’s Rugby News
Lee Grant
  • Website

Voted most valuable member of the G&GR Forum since records began - Ed.

Related Posts

Can we all play together?

November 30, 2023

Moneyball.

November 29, 2023

The Chewsday Chew – here’s to the ‘grassrooters’.

November 28, 2023

A personal view

November 27, 2023
GAGR Podcast
Our Picks

A personal view

November 27, 2023

Friday’s Rugby News: Ground Zero?

November 23, 2023

Moneyball.

November 29, 2023

The Chewsday Chew – here’s to the ‘grassrooters’.

November 28, 2023
Follow Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
Don't Miss
Australia

Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA

By NuttaDecember 1, 202336

Hello all. In my inbox this morning: “…the tackle height will be lowered to below…

Can we all play together?

November 30, 2023

Moneyball.

November 29, 2023

The Chewsday Chew – here’s to the ‘grassrooters’.

November 28, 2023

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest news from Green & Gold Rugby.

About Us
About Us

greenandgoldrugby.com is your one stop shop for all things Rugby Union - news, podcasts, opinions, fixtures, events & everything in between.

greenandgoldrugby.com - created by fans of rugby, for fans of rugby.

About
Submit a Story
Authors
Contact
Privacy

Our Picks

A personal view

November 27, 2023

Friday’s Rugby News: Ground Zero?

November 23, 2023

Moneyball.

November 29, 2023
New Comments
  • Walt White on Mad Monday with Brisneyland Local #15: Who Dares Wins, unless you’re Rugby Australia.
  • donktec on Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA
  • donktec on The Chewsday Chew – here’s to the ‘grassrooters’.
  • Charlie Mackay on Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA
  • Reds and wallabies fan on Nutta on the loose: tackling and an open letter from RA
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Super Rugby
  • Wallabies
  • Podcast
  • Privacy Policy (2023)
© 2023 Ponderosa Publishing Pty Ltd | ABN 76 668 430 386.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.