South Africa 26 – British & Irish Lions 21
This is a game that had it all: an unbelievable crowd, a charged atmosphere, drama and excitement, heroes and villains, scrum battles that ebbed and flowed, inches (or centimetres in the new age) and a team that won a huge amount of possession and played the majority of game in the opposition half, but lost the match.
Funny old game. It was split into two parts. For the first two thirds of the match it was the Boks all the way. They dominated the set piece and mauls, won all their own ball and took the chances offered to them when they were down the Lions end. They smashed the Brits in the early scrums, turning over four and in the process I’d say ended the career of Phil Vickery . The possession they won they put to good use, but often they went to the air which resulted in giving a fair bit of ball away, hence the lop-sided statistic. The good news for them was that it won them the match.
The game actually looked to be all over early in the second half with the Boks leading by 26-7. Then coach de Villiers must have had a brainstorm: “Why don’t we take off all our good players and save them for next week?” Off went Brussow (who was having a blinder securing their ball at the breakdown), Botha, Jacobs, du Preez, Smit, The Beast (more of him later) etc etc. That’s when it all turned crapper. The disruption of all these changes left the Bokkies a bit disorganised and allowed the Lions back into the game.
Consequently, the Brits dominated the last 25 odd minutes and clawed back to 26-21 by some expansive play and deserved tries. It ended up a close run thing for the Boks , which is not how it should have been. To be fair, the Springboks were running out of juice having to make more than double the number of tackles the Lions did and not having the same level of match fitness.
The crowd: you remember the Gabba in 2001….sea of red, loads of singing and support, like we were back in the old dart? That was ABSA Stadium in Durban yesterday, except there were probably another 10,000 Brits there having a jolly old time. Talk about atmosphere, you just don’t get that playing the Eyties in Melbourne. The Brit crowd was very vocal prior to the match but was a bit restrained during the first half and only really came to life as the Lions finally got their act together later in the game. You could even hear ‘Swing Low Sweet Chariot’…..
Heroes and villains: The Beast – nudge, nudge, wink, wink, say no more. He was a snorting colossus and has ARRIVED. He absolutely smashed Vickery in the process of establishing himself in the world loosehead order as the new Myth. Watch out Le Fuse and assorted Benny’s. There were a couple of villains. For the poms, paddy’s and boyos (it was a jock free zone) it was Vickery.
In the process of being popped and monstored by the Beast, Vickery gave away a load of scrum and other penalties which, in the new age, are all long arm and some resulted in points. He met his Waterloo in the 45th minute when Geech pulled him off and sent on one of the ‘hair bears’ Adam Jones. The Welshman immediately stabilised the scrum and played himself into next week’s side. In fact, later in the match when the Bokkie changes had been made, their scrum went backwards. It’s all about mechanics you know!
The game started in the best possible way for the Springboks. After an attacking scrum in the corner and a couple of phases, John Smit rumbled over next to the posts. It all looked a bit ominous but there was an immediate response from the Lions with Ugo Monye crossing in the corner. Unfortunately, Jean de Villiers wrapped his arm underneath the ball and prevented the try. It took the Frog TMO a while to convince Bryce Lawrence that (1) he could speak English, and (2) this is actually what happened, and (3) he got it wrong anyway – it should have been a 22 drop out, not a 5 metre scrum to the Lions. Fortunately, Bryce was in the zone and eventually worked it out. Looking forward to the Japanese TMO next time.
A couple of Bok penalties took the score to 13-0 (Pienaar and Steyn – the latter for the longer kicks) and then a good half break by Roberts with a great off load to BO’D. Croft was on on his shoulder and this resulted in a very good try, converted by Jones. 13-7 and game-on. The halftime score was 19-7 after another couple of penalties, with Vickery really starting to piss the ref off. ‘I’m going to the pocket’ next time I think was the refrain, or something like that. Lee Byrne, who had defended manfully at the rear, was replaced by Kearney due to injury.
The Bokkies completely dominated the opening stanza in the second half. They stole Lions lineout ball like a ‘tea leaf’ in The Bill and, in another highlight, mauled 30m upfield to set up a great attacking position. A subsequent maul from a lineout resulted in a Brussow try. That’s when the Bok substitutes started coming on and the game turned. In the 71st minute Monye had the try line open but Morne Steyn knocked the ball out in a George Gregan ‘that tackle’ moment.
The Lions then responded with a Philips ‘no try’ after he was tackled just inches from the line. After some good expansive play and pressure Croft went over for his second try. There was a plethora of penalties awarded to the Lions as they attacked in wave after wave. The Brits were not taking kicks but looking for the try option. Philips scored after sniffing a gap at a ruck close to the try line. Jones converted and26-21 was the final scoreline.
I thought the Lions were a reasonable shot for this game. In my view, this was their best opportunity for the series. They were in the match at the end but the Springboks should have comfortably won after such a great lead. For the Boks, who said John Smit was going to be the weak link? He had a powerful game and with du Plessis and The Beast were unstoppable. In fact, the tight five and Brussow won the game for them. The lineout and scrum were superb (the latter until the changes were made). In the backs, Pienaar controlled it well and the Steyn fullback experiment worked, albeit shakily at times.
For the Lions, Gethin Jenkins and O’Connell worked hard but their loosies (Wallace and Heaslip in particular) were anonymous. Mike Roberts was the standout back with Monye always looking for work. Kearney also looked exciting when he came on. However, the Lions man of the match would have to be Tom Croft – his support play was outstanding.
What can the Lions do next week? Adam Jones, Martyn Williams and maybe a No 8 option. Stephen Jones took the ball to the line a lot but was always covered – he looked a bit pedestrian actually. Maybe RO’G ? My advice is to recruit Kobus Wiese at tighthead. Did you see him interviewing the Beast after the match? He made him look like Luke Burgess. Man mountain – Max Headroom!
<span class="dsq-postid" data-dsqidentifier="3765 https://www.greenandgoldrugby.com/?p=3765">15 Comments
I Agree that Vickery is over the hill Lance. However, the Beast was using scrummaging illegally, he kept boring in on the old teletubby. It was pretty frustrating to watch and there wasn’t a lad around me who thought otherwise.
The springboks are obviously the more physically dominant team, but the lions really should have capitalised on the flashes of brilliance they’re backs showed in the first half. I counted three tries that were disallowed.
The lions have got my backing only because I don’t want them to be a complete joke by the time the come to Australia next time round. And i hate saffas.
What do you think about BOD taking the captaincy back next week? O’Connell seemed to get on the wrong side pretty quickly, admittedly what he was saying was true, but it was hopeless once he go the ref offside.
That’s a very valid point you make Ed, because I thought that when they replayed the footage in slow motion it did look like the Beast was boring in on occasions. I guess if you can get away with it – of course the ref’s always on the loosehead side when it’s the Lions feed. Notwithstanding that, it was a Sheridan/Baxter moment from 2005! The interesting thing about it was that it stopped completely when the Hair Bear came on?
O’Connell obviously was getting frustrated but, hey, you’ve got to roll with the punches at this level. He’ll be better for the experience. Taking the captaincy off him would definitely send the wrong message and I can’t see it happening. He’s a natural leader, deserves his spot in the test side and rallied the troops later in the game. They wanted a Johnno clone and he’s the next best thing.
Yep hair bear knew his stuff better, there was a time when you couldn’t have drilled Vickery out to save your life.
The most obvious changes are Stephen Jones out ROG in, that is absolutely necessary if they are to win, Jones missed two sitters and was at sea, Martyn Williams in to try and put some pressure on Pienaar and Adam Jones in for certain, as well I think as the reserve hooker who helped a lot in tightening up.
I would even think about Sheridan back, who cares about technique they were outmuscled all around the park.
Overall, I suspect they are in for a torrid time next week even with all those changes. They might turn it around but the gulf for the first 50 minutes was too big I think.
My wife commented before the match when they did the introductions that the Lions looked and sounded like such nice men, they didn’t look ready for the big Boks who sounded mean – as always, she was right!
Just watched the game again… sober this time.
Roberts was immense and O’Driscoll is one of the best guys in the world to feed of Roberts damaging runs.
I too was amazed that the ref wasn’t picking up on the beast boring in, but like Lance mentioned above, why would he stop doing it if he’s not getting pinged? Can’t believe O’Connell or the front row weren’t making a bigger deal of it to the ref. Each time they just trotted back 10 metres.
Enjoyed the game though. Much closer than I thought it would have been. Monye will be living those bombed tries over and over again in his head for the rest of his life.
Changes should be Vickery out (Beast boring in or not he still got buckled and demolished), Wallace out, Jones out (big game for O’Gara on Tuesday) and O’Connell out. I don’t think O’Connell would have played in the first test had he not been captain.
Looking forward to the second test!
Rees needs to replace Mears as well and, when he did so on Saturday, together with Jones for Vickery, that is when the scrum improved.
AWJ and O’Connell are too similar. The Lions need a big, mean, hard lock in there to combat Botha. I would pick Hines or Shaw to start with O’Connell next week.
Did anyone else notice that Heaslip was quiet? Its a pity Ryan Jones isnt fit and ready because, apart from Powell, they dont have another genuine 8 over there.
Is Monye normally a right winger? You would think so the way he tucked the ball under his right arm for both try scoring chances. Although he’s out of form, Shane Williams would have scored those tries.
i was discussing the beast and boring in with a few of my mates. One of them suggested it could have just been a case of vickery crumpling on impact from the beast and as such he wound up sideways. I’m not so sure myself but would like to hear what others think.
As for the rest of the team, monye dropped for luke. While monye was unlucky with the first “try”, to paraphrase oscar wilde to let it happen twice is careless. Williams is too much of a liability in defence and is playing poorly.
While people have said heaslip was quiet, and he certainly didnt have many barnstorming runs, he was probably too busy tackling and rucking. I would also point out the spies didn’t do much in attack, hardly a coincidence.
If martyin williams starts to play well again then i would love to see him start, but i think that HCup semi is still haunting him.
Jones has to go, if hook can start then start him, if not the ROG. Jones did not play well enough to deserve a second start
ah well, ireland and leinster have had a great year so maybe it was too much to ask the lions to win as well!!
I can’t believe the ref wasn’t picking up the beast boring in. It only really stopped after the ref started calling the Beast for other things, like not binding. P’OC should have been screaming this out at the top of his lungs.
Unlike everyone else I wouldn’t change much, I don’t think. I agree that Rees has to come in for Mears just because of the lineouts. I would definately think hard about Williams in for Wallace. Wallace was supposed to be stronger and he just got thrown backwards. Why not put the quicker 7 in there and let the backs run around even more. Taking the Boks on upfront is a truly useless idea.
I would leave Jones in though. He is still a better defender than O’Gara will ever be and O’Gara hasn’t gotten a very good backline moving at all yet this tour. Jones still runs things better and I’d let him fix it next week instead of chucking him out.
Mostly what I’d change is the game-plan. New Plan: Throw the ball to Roberts, O’Driscoll and Bowe as much as you can. Only reason to use the forwards is to get those three out of rucks and into the backline again. Still picking the Lions to win at least one, maybe two now that they are pissed off and believe they can win.
What part of ‘kick the f***en points‘ and ‘win the f***en game‘ are you planning to change, in order to accomodate Jones? If you don’t trust O’Gara (who managed a grand slam 6N no?) then try Hook.
You Guys mention that O’Connel should have been having more of a go at the ref. Though I’m pretty sure he was reprimanded for being too ‘insulent’ when speaking to the ref about the scrum. I remember on the saffa commentators saying he was in danger of losing credibility. You’re right Lance, he should he keep the captaincy, he’s got this manic aggression that should lift the players around. But any ref (the nobs that they are) would take exception to the aggressive way O’Connell questioned that idiotic ref?
Agree with Rees and Jones coming in. Also get rid of Stephen Jones, the man looks like a robot when he runs.
Both wings didn’t impress me much, thought the replacement fullback looked good. I think it was Luke Fitzgerald. So if Lee Byrne is fit, start Williams and Fitzgerald on the wings.
Combine that with BOD and Jamie Roberts and you have yourself a premier backline. If only they had a decent pack. Who would of thought it?
Btw, How funny was the Video Ref on that Monye no try? I think they had to replace him because he could barely speak. Nerves or maybe just bad english, poor guy.
you’re looking for rob kearney there mate!
Yes it was Kearney, I would leave him at FB. I too would be tempted to shaft both wingers, they didn’t add much at all. Lucky the Boks don’t have much in that department either, at least not on the pitch.
I didn’t think the Lions backs had too many issues, apart from not taking their opportunities. I certainly wouldn’t be making wholesale changes. Jamie ‘Mike’ Roberts and BO’D are a dynamic duo in midfield, Philips had a great game at half and Lee Byrne has been the form fullback of the tour. If he’s fit I think he should stay there, if not then Kearney.
Kearney also plays wing as well as fullback, so that’s where I’d use him if Byrne is fit. Bowe didn’t have the best of games but I’d give him another chance, considering his tour form. So it’d be Monye who’d be the fall guy – a few too many crucial errors.
The only other change in the backs I’d consider is at five eighth. RO’G is the tour captain against the Emerging Bokkies tonight (included with Fitzgerald, Martyn Williams, Hines, and Shaw on the bench – if that is any indicator). Hook is fit again, he’s also a dirty dirty. Should be an opportunity for either of them to play their way in.
Interestingly, both replacement props Hayes and Payne are starting tonight – looks like Sheridan is stuffed (dodgy back apparently).
Odd about Sheridan, I guess they watched his tapes against le Fuse (so where did they put Vickery’s?).
I think replacing Jones is a must, and form is good but both wingers looked like the proverbial tits on a bull for my money. But I agree that the centres and Philips were fantastic.
Karmichael Hunt has an Irish grandmother. Don’t be suprised to see him as a Lion very soon.
Well Godwin, sorry….Mungo – that’s Scottish isn’t it? If Ed O’Donoghue can be selected for Ireland A, anything is possible, although I think there might be a four year waiting list!