1. Ben Alexander (Brumbies) – Superb performance with his workrate and willingness to truck the ball-up, just what was needed on a night where the conditions were appalling.
2. Squeeky Moore (Brumbies) – Lead the Brumbies front row which dominated the Stormers pack. Had a pretty solid night with his line-out work and did plenty of dog work in tight.
3. Guy Shepardson (Brumbies) – Hard to leave him out given he played the full game and was in the thick of the action with his two front-row team mates.
4. Noodles Kimlin (Brumbies) – Stamped his authority on the match with some outstanding defence on both AJ Venter and Schalk, not an easy thing to do I’d imagine. He has played well over the last couple of weeks under difficult circumstances.
5. Madness McMeniman (Reds) – Looks far more comfortable when playing lock and it appears as though this is his preferred position rather than no.6 where he struggles for mobility. Back to his marauding best against the Highlanders after a few quiet weeks, his try was one for the end of season highlights.
6. Ben Mowen (Tahs) – Ok, he blew a try when he should have passed in the first half, but, perhaps he had visions of repeating his try in the same corner of a few weeks earlier. The only Tahs forward who seems capable of linking with the backline and providing an attacking option
7. David Pocock (Force) – Didn’t have quite the impact in attack as he had in games previous but provided the Force with a non-stop supply of good breakdown ball and made more tackles than any other Australian forward for the round.
8. Cliffy Palu (Tahs) – It is such a shame that the Tahs are unable to turn the dominance his continues to have over his opponents into better results. Easily put Pierre Spies in the shade and was one of the few go forward players for the Tahs
9. Patrick Phibbs (Brumbies) – I’ve never been a fan of Phibbs but he came on and made things happen. Charge-downs, close in snipes, disrupting opposition ball and was rewarded with a try. He is a scrapper in the Brett Sheehan mould and the conditions suited his style
10. Gits (Force) – Although Quade Cooper went alright this week, Gits was once again on a different level to anyone else.
11. Peter Hynes (Reds) – A goer, had an impact from the kick-off and made the Reds look like a different team. It will be an interesting selection meeting to decide if he or Diggers gets the right wing spot for the Wallabies assuming Lote has the left wing spot in the bag.
12. Berrick Barnes ( Reds) – While still far from his best, he showed some neat little touches and great attacking running to beat the other no.12’s this week. Would have liked to see Tyrone Smith on a dry track, but that was not to be. Barnes is such a great defender despite giving away a fair bit of size.
13. Diggers (Reds) – Every week leads the attacking metres gained. This stat is even more impressive considering a fair few of those metres are gained off inside balls running into traffic. Not sure if he will be the Wallaby outside centre this year but it looks only a matter of time before he make the position his.
14. Nick Cummins (Force) – Crammed more into the 50 odd minutes he was on the field that the other Australian wingers put together. Finishes tries well and can make things happen for himself; as shown by some outstanding line-breaks. Cummins is proof the Force can develop talent rather than just knocking it off from the other states.
15. Mark Gerrard (Brumbies) – Won the game against the Stormers with his right boot, Gerrado seems to be ageing like fine wine. Despite his outstanding performances this season, his name rarely comes up when potential Wallabies sides are talked about…why is that?
<span class="dsq-postid" data-dsqidentifier="2393 https://www.greenandgoldrugby.com/?p=2393">25 Comments
nice one juan.
Much better than our worst coach ever, john connelly who wrote an article about the australian individual talent emerging from the super 14 as wallaby starters here. Connelly mentions many but forgets about Ioane and Gerrard… I think they both have had great seasons to date.
Its amazing that Gerrard never gets a mention in terms of wallaby selection on any other media bar this website… Me thinks its because he was tipped as starting fullback by many last year and was left out all together and it left many people thinking that means he’s never gonna be picked.
I think Deans has improved his play by leaving him out and making him more hungry. But if he’s left out again we’ll lose him to Japan and the brumbies wont win the super 14 next season even with Giteau.
I read that article and it became quite apparent that Connelly doesn’t actually watch much rugby…
I think he does watch rugby, he just doesn’t understand what it means
He did inherit a team that beat the springbox (the eventual winners of the WC) 49-0 in their first game and got them to lose to england in the WCQF.
He understands how to score less points than other teams. Honestly I think a dog could coach better and El Dommo could write a better article than he.
you should see the new SMH article about how the force have a chance… they’re getting them mixed up with the brums on the table… pretty serious mistake…
spiro zavos must watch but not keep score.
I noticed that too about Spiro. I was thinking, what about the Brumbies? It doesn’t even mention them.
The article is here:
http://www.rugbyheaven.com.au/news/news/waratahs-are-playing-without-intellect/2009/04/13/1239474817210.html
Pedro’s last blog post..Australia Prevail 2-0, One Foot In South Africa
Isn’t it amazing how Spiro always overhears someone saying exactly what he’s thinking?
Amazing.
Gagger’s last blog post..Bakkies Botha gets 3 Weeks
Thanks Bobas…i probably could, alas, Knuckles needs the cash…so i wont take the job away from him.
Just stuck some info about tries scored so far this year in the forum.
Guess who Australia’s leading point scorer is…..
http://bit.ly/1xRD6c
benn robinson?
Gerrard and Gits leading the points, Digby and Lachy leading the tries…maybe this site has Australian Rugby’s only reality-based community!
I dream of the day I get to watch all four aussie teams in action and can write on of these..
…unfortunately it won’t be until the next double-aussie derby weekend :(
That could really be a Wallabies team for RWC 2011, looking at it, better to my eye than the recent combinations mooted on this site. Obviously there are a lot of positions someone else could grab, notably Horwill, Elsom, Smith, Smith, Tuquiri, Turner and Mitchell, but everyone on that list would be good odds (as good as can be this far out) of being at least on the bench.
Nice one JC. You can’t deny Phibbs, although I thought Burgess showed good form again. Especially for the Tahs customary first 15 minute blitz
I wouldn’t have put any Tahs in the team this week, they were all crap. It was the only game i saw this week too…
Haven’t seen the Reds in a couple of weeks. Any signs that McM can scrummage?
Sorry mate, it’s under ELV’s, scrummaging doesn’t matter any more.
Pedro’s last blog post..Australia Prevail 2-0, One Foot In South Africa
Thats an intersting coment considering a half arm in the attacking 20 oftens leads to a scrum being formed.
Set piece is more impportnat than evern now, as with 5 metre rules at scrum, 9 offside lines, the option of a scrum off a half arm etc, and the hasty whistleblowing refs on the 3rd pack of a scrum to free kick or penalise a team for disrupting its beauty, have led to coaches ustilising the set piece and their power in it, as a big advantage…
also lets not forget…when you are small and you dot know how to pack, and you keep packing scrums…no fking way are you gonna be able to play this so called RUNNING RUGBY the elvs want…
Sorry pedro i just thought that was a very intersting comment…
scrums are extremely important…possible moreso now than before…
I was only being silly El Dommo.
I was just repeating the northern hemisphere argument.
Pedro’s last blog post..Australia Prevail 2-0, One Foot In South Africa
Check.
The french would be great at ELVs…their front rowers are floating around 105-110 kilos, significantly lighter than soutern hemisphere or other Northern Hem Unions, and they still fk people up. Says a lot about technique.
if anything…most of the elvs should be adopted, and the Half arm thing, cant rememebr whats its called, and i was only just discussing it the other day
however numbers in lineout, and Pulling down maul…big no nos for me…keep them equal numbers, no pulling down…thats the shit
Reds scrum (with MMM at 4) held up pretty well against the Clan, with a few nice wheels and good stability on their own feed.
That was the full-strength Clan scrum too, with Mackintosh at 3.
Re Gerrard it was interesting that in an article this week Deans said that in June last year there weren’t a lot of decisions to be made in regards to selection, which suggests that for the most part he just picked the incumbents and ran with that. You’d have to think that having watched the whole season this year, he would have to be leaning heavily towards Gerrard for the 15 shirt. Shepherd’s the only other player who’s really stepped up to claim the fullback spot.
Shepherd’s the only other player who’s really stepped up to claim the fullback spot?
You gotta be kidding? he hasn’t played much in fullback this year? he’s been injured or been on the wing?
Do you write for the SMH Ishmael?
True, he hasn’t had much time there this year. I guess I was thinking mostly of his form last season. Or something. He’s still the second best behind Gerrard though.
domo arigato mr gerrardo
Re Gerrard
Planet Rugby included Gerrard in their S14 Team of the Week with the following comment:
15 Mark Gerrard (Brumbies): Without a doubt, the leading full-back contender for the 2009 Wallabies squad – Gerrard isn’t knocking on Robbie Deans’ door, he’s bashing it down following yet another flawless performance for the Brumbies against the Stormers. Swirly winds and constant rain made it hard for either side to gain an advantage through field position, each side instead focused on defence with Gerrard’s four penalties in the match proving the difference.
Hard to disagree – unless he completely stuffs up the remaining matches, if he gets overlooked again you’d really have to question Deans’ thinking