I keep hearing this argument. Isn't it more that the QLD gates have gone up because you've gone from dead fucking last but one, to a good gap above dead last?....By that I mean it's less about the Quade Train, and more about not being a jibbering mess, so that a lot of supporters who couldn't take any more have come back.
If this had happened under Genia and Barnes, they'd be back all the same.
That rather makes the point; in fact, Barnes in 2009 for the Reds didn't 'make it happen', not even close. And, yes, if a Barnes paired with a Genia in 2010 had achieved: the same consistent ball-in-hand dazzle, incredible short and long passing skills (with high accuracy under pressure), excellent orchestration of the Reds' backs game after game, exceptional vision in tough games, and wonderful stepping through multiple defenders, then, yes, Barnes could have been a catalyst for the Reds' fans return in 2010.
But that wasn't Barnes in 2010. That isn't anybody else with those skills in the Reds in 2010. That was QC (Quade Cooper). He's unique in Australian top rugby today, with these skills at 10. Yes, Genia was the perfect enabler and partner for these talents. In combination, they were the core catalysts for most of the Reds' wins. That's why you and BD and LG rightly have all referred to the huge Wallaby-reviving potential and p.o.d. of this nexus of 9 and 10.
There's no doubt that Quade himself was a major part of the Reds' income/game revival in 2010. His skills created a core of dynamism and successful running rugby that thrilled. This - plus the exciting wins v the best S14 teams - brought the fans back. He's a big part of the Reds 2010 income gain, I have no doubt, it would have happened to a far less a degree without him.
PS: The above comments under-credit the decisive parts the Reds' forwards played the Reds' revival this year, exceptionally well coached as they were by Link and Evans. But the above notes re QC (Quade Cooper) are still just as true.
PSS: Btw, QC (Quade Cooper) scored 171 points for the 2010 Reds season, beating the previous best of 155 (John Eales in 1996)