The Sydney selections are completely scandalous.
I am not sure I would say scandalous, but I would say symptomatic of a flawed process…
For example, the Norths 10, 12, 13 are excellent players and easily deserved selection in the Sydney team. They have cohesion from Mosman and Norths and were selected in the Sydney Red backline. As a unit, they were miles ahead of any other midfield at the carnival and when they were on the field together, the Sydney Red backs carved up.
What would have made more sense was for them not to all be selected in the same Sydney team, or for the selectors to step in at the carnival to reshuffle the teams to see some other combinations.
The inverse of this situation happened with Sydney Blue. The Penrith 12 was not at the carnival and one of the reserves filled his spot. Was clearly out of his depth (and suspect likely hadn’t played at 12) and resulted in Sydney Blue backs having no chance of further selection.
If the purpose of the carnival is to pick a team for progression to higher honours, it would make more sense to have a pool of 3 teams selected. Have them coached by the selectors as a pool, not as 3 seperate teams. The selectors then get to see skills, fitness, attitude, etc at training. Then pick and choose players and teams over the weekend so that selectors can be looking at players, not just combinations. Selectors should be on the field interjecting during breaks in the game instructing players how they want to see the game played.
Selectors could also match up teams during the game to get the selection match ups they wanted to see. eg. There was 1 game I saw where a number of the reserve forwards were playing the other teams first choice forwards. That team hardly got any ball and when they did it was under extreme defense pressure, so limited the players ability to show anything other than a scrambled kick for touch.
P.S I have no problem with the 10,12,13 being in the Sydney team as they are excellent, just that the current process meant it was inevitable that this was going to be the combination.