Tazzmania
Bob Loudon (25)
Carlo has been playing club rugby for UWA, so while no where near the required level at least he has been keeping match fit
Wallabies v Springboks, Sat 10th August 2.30pm AEST @ Suncorp,
- Thread starter KOB1987
- Start date
- Status
The_Brown_Hornet
John Eales (66)
I'm stoked to see Carlo get the gig, but like others I do worry about about him being able to play bulk minutes on debut against the meat eaters. I guess we'll never know unless he gets given a crack at it, right? I do like the fact that Schmidt appears to have gone for a genuine openside too.
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
It's not very inspiring at the moment is it.
I agree the career of these two might be collateral damage on the road to finding a long term player. Having said that if you were to write a manual on how to best stuff up a promising young 10s career, wouldn't you pretty much show them how Lolesio has been handled?
Homer
Bill Watson (15)
Tizzano has a huge engine but sometimes tries to do too much. He is better than he was but has to play with a level head, certainly wont back down from anything and he is almost exactly the same size as Kwagga Smith.
The lineout will be a concern though with only two jumpers against four for them if you count Kolisi. Then a thousand rolling mauls.
The lineout will be a concern though with only two jumpers against four for them if you count Kolisi. Then a thousand rolling mauls.
I'm not sure I'd describe it as collateral damage. I just don't think either are good enough to be long term starting Wallabies (as is the case with the majority of players who ever pull on the jersey). Realistically we need players to surpass them if we're any chance of consistently being better than the 8th to 10th ranking we've been hovering around for a while.
I don't really agree with that last part. I'm not convinced that he'd be a substantially better player now if he hadn't played a bunch of tests nor do I think he'd be a substantially better player if he'd been selected at every opportunity since his debut.
Yoda
Cyril Towers (30)
I think they both would be better players if they went overseas and played far more games to develop their skills.
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
The collateral damage is having to play these guys (cause we have to select someone) even though they aren't ready.
I think he might be a substantially better player if he hadn't been picked and dropped 8 times through his test career before the age of 24, and he had an experienced 10 along with him for the ride as mentor.
Or at least he may not be on the verge of being discarded for the next option
Managing better, might have meant playing fewer tests.
I don't think it's a coincidence that he has better outcomes playing under Larkham
Last edited:
Wilson
Phil Kearns (64)
A very different take on the halves in the SMH:
www.smh.com.au
How do you beat the world champion Springboks? Start by getting them to fly to Australia
The under-construction Wallabies will be huge outsiders against the world’s best team. But a sold-out Suncorp Stadium and the Boks’ record in Australia offers a glimmer of hope.
Collateral damage for fans or the players? In general I think they're better off career-wise having been selected in the first place even if for whatever reason it wasn't for a long time. They make more money immediately, they'll always be Wallabies and I think it generally increases their earnings potential internationally.
Even if some of them weren't overly ready for test rugby, I don't think they were selected prematurely. They've all been the form option or close to it when selected. It's not like we've selected young project players ahead of currently clearly better options on the basis that we hope they will one day become an even better option on the back of that experience.
I'd say the Larkham thing is more that Super Rugby is his level and at test level his good stuff doesn't stand out as much and his bad stuff is exposed more.
I think this is just where we're at. Guys who are justifiably being selected to play for the Wallabies because they're the best we have right now aren't good enough to be long term stars. I also think that for a lot of these guys who have been in professional systems since a young age and haven't got a lot to gain through improved physicality/muscle that's achieved as they age a bit, they're far closer to their ceilings than they once would have been at a similar age.
I think Tizzano is going to get smashed at the breakdown. That won't stop him from having a crack. Good luck to him though. Yes Donaldson probably a place holder though I hope I am wrong there, as how be it I just don't see any other quality 10's coming through since Carter left. Backing the Wallabies as always just can't see them getting up. Long term problem is not really the coaches except for Eddie it is the cattle we have. Good luck to them all though.
Derpus
Nathan Sharpe (72)
There are a few decent prospects like McLaughlin-Philips.
House is on Fire
Frank Nicholson (4)
I know he's only played a couple professional matches, but as far as I'm concerned any 10 is a placeholder until Jack Bowen breaks through. I think he's a special player.
But until (if) that happens, my pick remains Noah.
But until (if) that happens, my pick remains Noah.
Tomikin
David Codey (61)
Maybe they could convert Max Jorgensen to a 10, his got some of the skills the others don't, being pace and is a better tackler. I think his paths pretty blocked at 15 or wing and his not a massive player. Although to be honest not watched enough of him to really know if he'd be up for it.
KOB1987
John Eales (66)
This has been discussed elsewhere - can certainly see it happening at the Tahs. He played a bit there at schoolboy level but hasn't had an opportunity to get any experience there since as he has been thrust straight into the top level as a back 3 player since the day he left school. Can realistically envisage a Larkham-esque transition in due course. Add game awareness and management to to skills not possessed by the others.
I think he'll be the Wallabies starting 15 within a year or so. I don't think his path is blocked there at all.
His goal kicking has to improve a lot. He misses way too many easy ones and is falling into the same area as Carter Gordon where he's losing the job so isn't getting the matchday experience to improve it (he's not the goal kicker for Easts in the Shute Shield currently. The winger, Cooper Whiteside who is a great goal kicker took the job).
- Status