stillmissit
Peter Johnson (47)
Kob who are these teams? I think your expectations are understandable but a bit out there. I think if we go from 10th to 9/8th I would call that progress from where we are ATM.
Wallabies 2024
- Thread starter rugbyAU
- Start date
stillmissit
Peter Johnson (47)
I said it to Derpus and I'll say it to all of you. Have some faith that things can and will change - the only question is can Schmidt make things better? I am of the view that he can.
2-0 vs Wales, 1-1 vs Argentina.
stillmissit
Peter Johnson (47)
Shouldn't that read 1-2?
How many times have we played Argentina this year?
Hogan
Herbert Moran (7)
A coach is only as good as his players. We are currently ranked 10th in the world for a reason. We simply don’t have the depth of talent that we had back in the 80’s and 90’s. Many reasons for this including the shrinking of the player pool of CHS rugby and poaching raids by NRL clubs on schoolboy talent.
The current players are the best we have. Bringing in one or two players from overseas will make little difference. All we can hope for from Schmidt and the team is that they make small improvements and gradually move up the world rankings. But the days of the Wallabies being ranked in the top 3 of the world are long gone. Sad but true.
The current players are the best we have. Bringing in one or two players from overseas will make little difference. All we can hope for from Schmidt and the team is that they make small improvements and gradually move up the world rankings. But the days of the Wallabies being ranked in the top 3 of the world are long gone. Sad but true.
emuarse
Chilla Wilson (44)
Sword of Justice
Arch Winning (36)
@Hogan I agree strongly with most of that. There are players in our squad who would not be in the world’s best 50 players in their position. They are the best we have as you say.
Regarding overseas, I actually agree also that 1 or 2 players ain’t doing much. However opening up selection without restriction will improve depth and competition. It could also be used as a way to fight off the NRL. Get paid to play in the south of France and also a chance at the prestige of representing your country is the best of both worlds.
Regarding overseas, I actually agree also that 1 or 2 players ain’t doing much. However opening up selection without restriction will improve depth and competition. It could also be used as a way to fight off the NRL. Get paid to play in the south of France and also a chance at the prestige of representing your country is the best of both worlds.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
This is inevitable in my mind. Look how we are tracking with players going overseas in their prime now, look at the salaries offered in the NRL... Levelling the playing field is opening up selection.
I don't think there would be a mass exodus unless international Clubs had zero restriction on foreign players.
Derpus
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Its been inevitable for a decade.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
Your'e right, but the sooner we rip the band aid off and let the dust settle after the initial panic of thinking all the players will leave the better.
The Tahs are still going to pay Angus Bell, Reds will pay McDermott and McReight but it's really shit to not be able to pick a guy like Kemeny in the squad atm who was in great form all year when fit. Or when we are on our ass for Props at one point not call Scott Sio or how about give Lucas a run when we seem to be looking for a playmaker to grab the jersey.
The Tahs are still going to pay Angus Bell, Reds will pay McDermott and McReight but it's really shit to not be able to pick a guy like Kemeny in the squad atm who was in great form all year when fit. Or when we are on our ass for Props at one point not call Scott Sio or how about give Lucas a run when we seem to be looking for a playmaker to grab the jersey.
If they open up selection without restrictions I think Super Rugby would die. A knock on effect could be that our pool might diminish as if you have Pacific Island heritage and you align that country you could earn more money, I'm pretty sure there is a EU and PI free trade agreement. We could get to the point where French clubs set up academies here to qualify players as JIFF qualified.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
I think this is something a lot of people deep down (me included) have already conceded is happening with or without selection restriction. We will have something in place but it will never be what it was and sticking to it clearly isn't having great flow on for the Wallabies anyway.
A lot to happen but it would need WR (World Rugby) to implement rules around qualifying players.
I think the best thing we could do is walk away from NZ and have a local comp. It would gain more interest than Super Rugby and RA would have total control over it. Then it wouldn't matter as much if players went OS as it would only be a few and the Australian teams wouldn't be smashed by the NZ teams.
Tomthumb
Chilla Wilson (44)
Don't agree with this. If the only way a coach can be successful is to have great players, how do we know someone is actually a good coach?
The best coaches make teams better than the sum of their parts. Guys like Ian Foster & Pieter De Villiers have proven even bang average coaches can have success with great players
Derpus
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Super Rugby has been dying with protectionist policies in place just fine.
Yoda
Cyril Towers (30)
Agree. I’d also let players go overseas for the cash and experience. They would play more games depending on where they go and hopefully improve their skills. The Aussie Comp could have a few wild card high profile players to keep interest for the punters and then the Wallabies are picked from anywhere. Best financial and practical decision to boost rugby.
Guys we've covered this in at least three dozen threads and more than 5k pages.
The problems have all been solved therein. Super Rugby, the Giteau Law, league defections, the lot. All fixed. It was a fun ride, we solved the problems and we're all better for the experience.
So really we don't need to go back to square one again here.
The problems have all been solved therein. Super Rugby, the Giteau Law, league defections, the lot. All fixed. It was a fun ride, we solved the problems and we're all better for the experience.
So really we don't need to go back to square one again here.
Yoda
Cyril Towers (30)
A great coach can definitely improve his weakest links and mould his squad to be a better side. However, winning sides generally have better cattle. That is a fact.
stillmissit
Peter Johnson (47)
We played 2 games in Argentina 1st and 8th Sept?? Won one and demolished in 2nd odd post by you.