James Pettifer
Jim Clark (26)
That is why you have the experience of Tony McGahan as defense coach ...
Hahahahahahahahaha
Reds 2018
- Thread starter The torpedo
- Start date
- Status
That is why you have the experience of Tony McGahan as defense coach ...
Hahahahahahahahaha
emuarse
Chilla Wilson (44)
DB
"Hopefully Hamish gets some decent (any) minutes this week.."
We don't know the full story.
Maybe BT wants Lance to get up to full match fitness level, or that Stewart is carrying a minor niggle.
I think that Stewart will get some play time, for the same first reason (needs to keep match fit/aware)
"Hopefully Hamish gets some decent (any) minutes this week.."
We don't know the full story.
Maybe BT wants Lance to get up to full match fitness level, or that Stewart is carrying a minor niggle.
I think that Stewart will get some play time, for the same first reason (needs to keep match fit/aware)
dillyboy
Colin Windon (37)
Fair enough - I just look for something more than reliable (whilst a great quality) in a fly half. I want someone who can create something....
I guess I should be happy Lance managed to stay on the field for 80 minutes.....
Simon.
Bob Loudon (25)
Ok thanks - the way it was reported in the media (I think it was Tucker) suggested that for Higgers they elected to take the early plea but for Tui they elected to go to the full hearing. Sounds like for a post-match citing like Tui got it's a compulsory judiciary.
Cue Lance getting a yellow card this week.
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
)
Lance made 2 massive line breaks last week (yep in one game)
Think that was more than Quade made last year ( or close to it).
Plus defence, fearlessness.
It actually looks like we have an engaged 10 this year and one for the future (Stewart)
learning the ropes. Hopefully he gets 10 - 20 minutes
Lance made 2 massive line breaks last week (yep in one game)
Think that was more than Quade made last year ( or close to it).
Plus defence, fearlessness.
It actually looks like we have an engaged 10 this year and one for the future (Stewart)
learning the ropes. Hopefully he gets 10 - 20 minutes
Rebels3
Jim Lenehan (48)
I get why Thorn has leant towards a player like Lance over Quade, but i don't think it's the right way to go. It just seems such a negative way in which to approach games. The fly half generally is supposed to be the heart beat of the teams attacking prowess, not the heart beat of the defense. Although you need a bit of both to be successful. I believe at 10 it should be attack > defense than defense > attack
I don't think they're picking Lance because he is a better defender. I think it is because he suits a game plan that doesn't revolve around a 10 who takes a lot of risks and takes a lot of the game on their shoulders.
The reality with Cooper has always been that if he's your 10 your entire game has to be very much structured around the way he plays. If he isn't in the team then doing the same thing with the replacement doesn't work.
That was unbelievably worthwhile when he was at the top of his game and won a lot of rugby games due to his brilliance. Lots of people think those days are few and far between now.
The reality with Cooper has always been that if he's your 10 your entire game has to be very much structured around the way he plays. If he isn't in the team then doing the same thing with the replacement doesn't work.
That was unbelievably worthwhile when he was at the top of his game and won a lot of rugby games due to his brilliance. Lots of people think those days are few and far between now.
Zero_Cool
Arch Winning (36)
On this I think the Quade - Hunt switch in attack/defence was actually really very effective. Quade is a very serviceable fullback and Hunt would make a serviceable 10 so you don't lose anything in either attack or defence while they are between and gain a whole lot in each.
I do follow the logic behind the move towards Stewart/Lance but if Lance is still our primary flyhalf by seasons end this whole season will have largely been wasted.
Cooper for Stewart -- understandable
Cooper for Lance -- dumb
Lance will only miss half the season due to injury.
dru
David Wilson (68)
I don’t think it worked that way. Right or wrong Brad acted on QC (Quade Cooper). Then we needed to bolster experience and FH. Bringing in Jono was logical, sensible and the right thing to do.
It’s the QC (Quade Cooper) bit I have an issue with. We’ll do OK with Jono and Stewart.
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
Quade was given his marching orders well before Lance was on the books right?
Thinks it's more that Thorn won't risk playing QC (Quade Cooper), and Jono was the only super rugby standard (at the moment) 10 available. So that's who he's playing
Edit - same time as dru
Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk
Thinks it's more that Thorn won't risk playing QC (Quade Cooper), and Jono was the only super rugby standard (at the moment) 10 available. So that's who he's playing
Edit - same time as dru
Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
upthereds#!
Peter Johnson (47)
Sure we didn't really get a chance to unlock out wide (partially through DP and Kerevi glaring communication issues) but I have no idea how people said Lance had a rubbish game. I thought he was a bit of a one man army. Making huge breaks and such a dependable and vicious tackler. When Lucas is coming off the bench (or starting as Tuttle screams journeyman ie - Prior, with nil outstanding characteristics), hopefully they can spread themselves out and lead the defence. Toua has given us great speed but I think the crux of our problem is giving leeway to Kerevi who continues to be a crash baller, or decoy at best. Just keep that guy doing what he does best and stop involving him in intricate back plays where he is actually required to make judgements. Either give him the ball to crash or cut him out as a decoy - but for the love of god don't give him any tactical or leadership responsibilities.
dru
David Wilson (68)
Two. And someone is paying for it.
Scrubber2050
Mark Ella (57)
dru you definitely right about 1 season but I think he will have to play overseas (somewhere) in the second year otherwise his relevance may seriously hurt his income (if he waits until the third year).
Costly exercise however but I say Lance did more last game than I would have expected Quade to do - line breaks and front on tackles.
Whichever way you look at it the decision has been made and I reckon Thorn would rather die than change his mind.
dru
David Wilson (68)
Mate, you (and Brad) and I are just never going agree on QC (Quade Cooper). So no Jono did nothing like QC (Quade Cooper). But he did do Jono. Need Jono and Duncan to start building. And work Stewart through.
- Status