- Status
G
GC
Guest
Rebels try butchered by Benthem. reds have had no pill.
G
GC
Guest
Quade goes Mortlock. That won't end well.
G
GC
Guest
Great try from Higgers. Wobs no. 6 Right there.
F
feed_me
Guest
Well... good to get the win, but not the most convincing performance from the reds
Well, after a brief pause, we're back!!
Good win in the end from the Reds, but the Rebels put in a pretty good effort in many facets. A few poor defensive lapses gifted some easy points to the Reds, and the horrible goal-kicking didn't help.
Having no dog in the fight, I will make one comment about Bryce Lawrence - really let the breakdown degenerate into farce towards the end. I honestly question his position on the RWC panel. That is all.
Genia - huge game, especially being pretty unwell; Cooper had some real magic, but I wanted Mortlock to thump him in the first half just a little bit!
He is so dangerous. Samo was a liability more than a positive. Higgers varied between sublime play (mainly in the loose still) and some pretty silly stuff where he ran the risk of getting carded towards the end. Needs to be tighter still, but lots of talent.
For the Rebels, Delve strong, Pyle good in places, Robinson solid, and Phipps continues to impress, but some glaring problems with Huxley fairly poor, and some bad defensive alignment issues.
Good win in the end from the Reds, but the Rebels put in a pretty good effort in many facets. A few poor defensive lapses gifted some easy points to the Reds, and the horrible goal-kicking didn't help.
Having no dog in the fight, I will make one comment about Bryce Lawrence - really let the breakdown degenerate into farce towards the end. I honestly question his position on the RWC panel. That is all.
Genia - huge game, especially being pretty unwell; Cooper had some real magic, but I wanted Mortlock to thump him in the first half just a little bit!
He is so dangerous. Samo was a liability more than a positive. Higgers varied between sublime play (mainly in the loose still) and some pretty silly stuff where he ran the risk of getting carded towards the end. Needs to be tighter still, but lots of talent.For the Rebels, Delve strong, Pyle good in places, Robinson solid, and Phipps continues to impress, but some glaring problems with Huxley fairly poor, and some bad defensive alignment issues.
Sandpit Fan
Nev Cottrell (35)
Think the website was down for most of the game.
Sandpit Fan
Nev Cottrell (35)
True that. He started well, giving about 5 milliseconds before penalising for not rolling away, should have continued. Didn't seem to matter where people came into the ruck from in the last 20, from both sides.
Yeah, not that it mattered in the overall context, but to let AWH come in from the side to kill it after a warning about penalties was just awful reffing.
But it was all sorts - players lying in the way, playing the ball on the ground, not releasing tackled players...you name it, and it was from both sides, but it just made it a blight.
I thought some refs might have carded Higgers for taking out the Rebels player at the quick lineout - pretty cynical stuff, and an aspect of his game he has to lose, given his other obvious strengths.
Plus I think he needed to crack down on some of the niggle which got plain silly at times.
Ignoto
Peter Sullivan (51)
Scrappy game as most people have alluded to. However I would like to know how the Rebels were awarded the Dorf and second half try.
DK seemed to have his entire arm and hand around the ball and the camera seemed to show conclusive evidence that the ball was held up?
More importantly, that second half try to me seemed like a knock on, however, Lawrence decided to award the try whilst falling on his arse and simply telling the TA to bugger off?
I thought the Reds scrum looked pretty solid, the only time there was trouble was when Woodcock wasn't binding and simply putting an arm on the ground.
Line outs are still a worry, calls werent right!
DK seemed to have his entire arm and hand around the ball and the camera seemed to show conclusive evidence that the ball was held up?
More importantly, that second half try to me seemed like a knock on, however, Lawrence decided to award the try whilst falling on his arse and simply telling the TA to bugger off?
I thought the Reds scrum looked pretty solid, the only time there was trouble was when Woodcock wasn't binding and simply putting an arm on the ground.
Line outs are still a worry, calls werent right!
With Hilgendorf's try, I think he went with the ball being "helped" down by the later players - deserved a try for the ability to hold the ball while his leg was being destroyed!
The last one looked pretty dicey though.
Scrums waxed and waned with both teams having a few good ones, and neither side gaining a real edge I thought.
Tangawizi
Peter Fenwicke (45)
I don't think you'd call it grinding - patchy is more what it was. Patches of brilliance interspersed with a fair bit of shit. The Harris sinbinning was always going to make things a bit more difficult for them but I was personally a bit disappointed they didn't manage to keep going away with it after securing the bonus point try. Thought with the exception of the forced change re Morahan, Link was very conservative with his use of the bench tonight.
Hopefully the Morahan injury isn't too bad and he is back next week. If not what do the Reds do? Start Shipperley or push Chambers back on to the wing where he started out? Smokin' Joe and Rene Ranga aren't exactly slouches so whoever gets the gig will have to be on their game.
Hang on, now I see that Houston was punted from the bench to make way for Prior as Genia was feeling less than 100%. That explains why there was no Leroy to be found around 60 mins in then. So Link's use of bench not as conservative as I first thought and also partly why Reds didn't go on with the job.
Genia went very well for a sick bloke.
Hopefully the Morahan injury isn't too bad and he is back next week. If not what do the Reds do? Start Shipperley or push Chambers back on to the wing where he started out? Smokin' Joe and Rene Ranga aren't exactly slouches so whoever gets the gig will have to be on their game.
Hang on, now I see that Houston was punted from the bench to make way for Prior as Genia was feeling less than 100%. That explains why there was no Leroy to be found around 60 mins in then. So Link's use of bench not as conservative as I first thought and also partly why Reds didn't go on with the job.
Genia went very well for a sick bloke.
Sandpit Fan
Nev Cottrell (35)
Best 2 sentence summary of the game I think we will see. If we play like that next week it will be the end of fortress Suncorp. Although the Blues have looked a bit the same in the last 2 games, todays against the canes wasn't great but they got the points.
Victorian Reds Fan
Bob Loudon (25)
Got to meet the players and go on the ground afterwards. A win is a win. I thought Huxley, apart from his goal kicking, was very good. Genia was brilliant, while Cooper was not at his best.
- Status