Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
All Wallaby top-ups are excluded from the Super Rugby salary cap.
Iain Payten reported last year re Donaldson.....
The Tahs weren't willing to pay that much for Donaldson, and presumably, the Force were.
Western Force 2025
- Thread starter RugbyReg
- Start date
Iain Payten reported last year re Donaldson.....
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
Most players that aren't getting a top-up would be on less than the $200k RA limit.
But LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) is a really good example. He was reportedly getting paid $600k, but wasn't getting a top-up (deals like this might explain why the Rebels ended up where they did)
But LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) is a really good example. He was reportedly getting paid $600k, but wasn't getting a top-up (deals like this might explain why the Rebels ended up where they did)
Yoda
Cyril Towers (30)
That seems to make sense BH. If the Force then have the weakest squad moving forward though, it will only strengthen Rugby Australia’s case to whittle the teams down to 3. I am assuming they finish down the bottom, because with injuries their depth isn’t great. Wouldn’t having the Force strongest of all sides help boost rugby in WA? Isn’t that the aim? Since Queensland and NSW provide most of top level rugby players, they will no doubt continue to do so and hence their sides will generally be pretty good. If you look at the NRL and the Storm. How long do you think they would have kept them going if they were perennial losers? I’m only throwing up questions because I don’t know the answers.
Yoda
Cyril Towers (30)
They probably couldn’t afford to? I’m sure if Will Harrison was offered something reasonable he would’ve have left for Japan? That’s right. They have paid Sua'ali'i ridiculous money. He needs to score 3 tries every game and have 100% kicking accuracy off the tee to repay his worth!
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
Yeah the reporting was the Tahs already had Edmed, Jack Bowen and Will Harrison under contract, so couldn't justify paying Donaldson as well.
Yoda
Cyril Towers (30)
He ended up better off too playing 10 every week and not subbed off…
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
Salary cap worked exactly as intended on that one
Wilson
Phil Kearns (64)
If the intent of the salary cap is to spread talent it has been incredibly poorly put together. The main goal looks to be keeping a lid on salary growth and hopefully keeps clubs operating in their means, but even then it's had pretty mixed results.
rugbyAU
Bob Davidson (42)
Force lands exciting Australia U20s international Palu
westernforce.rugby
dru
David Wilson (68)
It is distorted by the RA top up - especially where they skew from even distribution. It distorts talent distribution and it distorts the marketplace as to who get's to spend more on players.
A note to add to this was I believe given Harrison's injury history, the Tahs had him on the minimum contract, and probably didn't offer him much more with the 3 person battle for the starting jersey. I would say this is the main reason he left for Japan - way more money and less competition to play each week.
Yoda
Cyril Towers (30)
Agree … imo 10’s need to play for 80 minutes unless injured. This chopping and changing and half a game each hardly helped the Tahs young 10’s. All had different styles and Coleman’s gameplay didn’t suit any of them. On it goes this year with Edmed, Bowen and possibly Creighton… pick and stick.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
Not Tah chat I know but I think DM will pick someone and build to a plan if the Brumbies are a Blueprint. I hope it's Bowen with Creighton as the Jack Deb option when required.
Back to the Force. Have they still got or re-signed O'Donnell? I rate him highly and genuine 12, 13s don't come around all that often at his size with ball skills.
Tazzmania
Bob Loudon (25)
Wallaby Stewart re-signs with Force after career-best season
The Western Force are delighted to today announce the re-signing of Wallabies utility back Hamish Stewart following his career-best 2024 season.
The 26-year-old has re-committed to the Force following an outstanding 2024 Super Rugby Pacific campaign which led to his maiden Wallabies call-up for the recent Tests against Wales and Georgia, along with last week's call-up for the upcoming Tests against the Springboks where he could make his debut.
READ MORE
The Western Force are delighted to today announce the re-signing of Wallabies utility back Hamish Stewart following his career-best 2024 season.
The 26-year-old has re-committed to the Force following an outstanding 2024 Super Rugby Pacific campaign which led to his maiden Wallabies call-up for the recent Tests against Wales and Georgia, along with last week's call-up for the upcoming Tests against the Springboks where he could make his debut.
READ MORE
Yoda
Cyril Towers (30)
He needs to debut for 12 in the Wallabies. Great player and a fantastic season.
PhilClinton
Mark Loane (55)
Biggest impediment on Hamish playing consistently for the Wallabies I think is our lack of creativity at flyhalf. Hamish would excel with a prime Quade at 10, he provides some defensive starch and does all the skills right.
I worry that having him line up next to the likes of Donaldson, Lolesio etc and we dont have a lot of points in us from a backs perspective.
I worry that having him line up next to the likes of Donaldson, Lolesio etc and we dont have a lot of points in us from a backs perspective.
Yoda
Cyril Towers (30)
I would disagree Phil. I thought the Force backline had some great games with White, Donaldson and Stewart quite instrumental in that.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
Just think unfortunately he doesn’t have the flashiness looked for at Test level or at least the belief they have a highlight moment to break a game open.
I think he would perform at the level almost to the same degree he does at Super Rugby I just don’t think he has enough areas he outscores someone else if comparing even though he’s likely to be more consistent and trusted
I think he would perform at the level almost to the same degree he does at Super Rugby I just don’t think he has enough areas he outscores someone else if comparing even though he’s likely to be more consistent and trusted
