Lightblue
Arch Winning (36)
Eddie Jones wouldn’t agree.
Waratahs 2023
- Thread starter RugbyReg
- Start date
7137
Alex Ross (28)
More talk of the beefed up pack. Both Swinton and Harris are nudging 117kg and Gamble is up to 109kg.
If true, that’s a big backrow!
www.smh.com.au
If true, that’s a big backrow!
Super (size) Rugby: Bulked-up Waratahs emerge from gym to power up new season
Bullying at the hands of New Zealand teams prompted NSW to camp in the weight room over summer. Some players have added nine kilograms to their frames.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
Interesting. I think they always pump them up 5%
Harris and Swinton it will benefit but I do have concerns if Gamble is 109kg that his movement stays the same.
Harris and Swinton it will benefit but I do have concerns if Gamble is 109kg that his movement stays the same.
A quote from the rugby.com.au article makes me incredibly nervous.
“Our school of thought is we’ll play ourselves into fitness rather than planning around it being all ready for round one.”
“Our school of thought is we’ll play ourselves into fitness rather than planning around it being all ready for round one.”
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
Sounds like a wonderful recipe for injury.
interesting concept. Might be fine for the Brumbies first up where bulk will be a big factor.
Drua round 2 might be a bit different but definitely manageable but the Drua will be an unknown quantity again this year.
They won't be run off their feet by the Rebels either in Rnd 3 but you'd hope their fitness was ready for when Rnd 4 rolls around and they face the Canes, then the Chiefs, then the Crusaders
Drua round 2 might be a bit different but definitely manageable but the Drua will be an unknown quantity again this year.
They won't be run off their feet by the Rebels either in Rnd 3 but you'd hope their fitness was ready for when Rnd 4 rolls around and they face the Canes, then the Chiefs, then the Crusaders
7137
Alex Ross (28)
Pocock peaked at 115kg apparently.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
True, good point.
Pocock is a genetic freak though in terms of physique and ability to perform with a physique like that.
Pocock is a genetic freak though in terms of physique and ability to perform with a physique like that.
Lightblue
Arch Winning (36)
Also from Paytons article in the SMH…A quote from the rugby.com.au article makes me incredibly nervous.
“Our school of thought is we’ll play ourselves into fitness rather than planning around it being all ready for round one.”
“It is a gamble because gains in one area can come at the cost of the other, although added size is a safer bet in the modern game because of the amount of stoppage time.”
As a spectator, that is the biggest blight on the game. The amount of stoppages is killing it. They need to get rid of injury stoppages, unless it’s scrum time or a broken leg, water breaks, repeated scrum resets… the game should be faster. Third umpire rulings should be viewed in real time and only alert the referee of the infringement if it is necessary like football does. Rave,rave rave!
I agree and it is worse at the elite level than anywhere else.
The problem is that it's largely a player issue that needs to be fixed. I don't see how else you can fix it. A referee can't judge if someone is injured. You can't make a decision that a player isn't injured enough to require play not to be restarted. Players are the only ones that can stop going down for some sort of injury to delay the restart of play.
I agree that World Rugby really need to speed up the TMO process. Clear guidelines around the onfield decision trumping the TMO unless there is clear evidence to overturn it. Clear evidence should be clear. If you can't see it in a couple of replays then you go with the onfield decision. You don't end up with a better situation after watching 15 replays of the same thing.
In terms of foul play I definitely advocate for something that is at least a yellow card being done straight away. The TMO then has 10 minutes to go through a thousand replays to work out whether it should be yellow or red. At some stoppage in play the yellow can be confirmed or upgraded to red and you've avoided looking at replays for 3 minutes of where exactly the contact originated etc.
I also think we should just stop the clock for shots at goal after x number of seconds and for any scrum resets. I feel like the actual stoppages are less of an issue than the knowledge of how much game time you are losing with nothing happening.
re YC vs RC - I would YC them all if it ain't obviously a red on the first replay, so stick them all report and be harsh on the Wednesday review
For the unsure whether the penalty should have been a yellow (the other end of the spectrum), let TMO review it in the back ground and stick it on report if it was missed
but keep the game moving
As to the Tahs S&C making them do some work, it is about time, all the aus teams look underdone physically
A gentle reminder as to how the boks look physically
For the unsure whether the penalty should have been a yellow (the other end of the spectrum), let TMO review it in the back ground and stick it on report if it was missed
but keep the game moving
As to the Tahs S&C making them do some work, it is about time, all the aus teams look underdone physically
A gentle reminder as to how the boks look physically
If we could show that "after a pump" we would, but body fat % is impressive
Will Harris 117kg? it is possible, he is a big boned unit who could carry it,
But putting on 9kgs that quickly? I could do it, by eating like a pig and just fattening up, but putting on 9kgs of muscle over six months?
Well that is highly unlikely without illegal help
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
9kg in 6 months probably equates to about 3kg of muscle and the rest in fat from eating to gain the muscle. If he came out with 9kg of muscle in that period of time would definitely trigger some ASADA eyeballs. He's not a newbie where his body would just pile it on from the initial stimulus.
I hope he legitimately runs out at 112ish and can still run like we've seen.
Whatever plan the Tahs are apparently on can we get it to Nick Frost ASAP?
I hope he legitimately runs out at 112ish and can still run like we've seen.
Whatever plan the Tahs are apparently on can we get it to Nick Frost ASAP?
I don't think you can gloss over what should be a red card in the match. Why shouldn't the team on the receiving end of the foul play not benefit from the required repercussions?
A yellow card offence doesn't result in a suspension so you'd just be ignoring potential yellow card foul play acts.
Dctarget
Tim Horan (67)
That photo makes me think Aphiwe Dyantyi was rather unlucky to be the one pushed under the bus
7137
Alex Ross (28)
You can provide contrary evidence?
Derpus
Nathan Sharpe (72)
qwerty51
Stirling Mortlock (74)
Eye test is usually ok.
It's funny, even the comparison photo they use on the article he doesn't look bigger.
Here is he too. Barely looks over 110kg imo.