The neutral doctor at the ground does the initial assessment and this is the one that found Horne was concussed and ruled him out for the match. At that point he enters the GRTP programme.
He then needs to be symptom free for 24 hours before he can move onto the second stage of light aerobic exercise.
So, Stage 5 starts on Thursday and he will be assessed at that time
Phipps was slow and cumbersome.
I understand that Cheika wants Fardy (left)and Hooper (right)roaming the tram tacks on each side of the field to exploit their ball carrying abilities.
The problem on the weekend came on the second and third phases of attack in centre-field. Our "middle-pod" would get tied up in a ruck and the next phase we'd barely have a forward to manage the next ruck.
Phipps looked spent after 30 minutes. He was doing a lot of walking.Seriously?
That's what I meant about too many forwards thinking about the next phase. As I said, most of the English turnovers were after slow phase ball midfield from a forward hitup. Our midfield pod gets caught in the ruck and their defensive line is set! Throwing it wide to their numbers isn't an option on slow ball, you saw it on the weekend that we just end up losing 10 or more metres.Nope, you don't understand. It's to enable us to play a wider game. They're there for the next breakdown. The goal is for them not to get the ball, since that defeats the purpose of the tactic.
As for your unsporting comments about Horne, give yourself an uppercut please.
Our defensive specialist and Vice Captain, with plenty of time to think, decided to tackle a player with his head in front of their knee's. He gets concussed and ruled out of the rest of the game. Now we're down a winger on a 6/2 bench split.
I have a particular type of disdain for "professionals" that choose to tackle like this because
a) it's coached out of you from u9's &
b) I've seen an amateur tackle like this in club footy end up with a fractured c6 vertebrae
a) exists because of consequences like b)
Horne's the only one that needs an uppercut
He got his head in the wrong spot in a tackle.
It's how most concussions happen. It's not uncommon and clearly not something the players do intentionally.
The problem is, he did it intentionally. He was trying to grasscut him at the same time.
In very general terms, players who have had less concussions recover faster.
Moore seemed to confuse proper hardness with white line fever madness. I counted a number of times he crunched prostrate blokes with an elbow or forearm to the head or throat. On the positive side his engagement with Poite was as good as I've seen from a Wallaby captain.
The problem is, he did it intentionally. He was trying to grasscut him at the same time.
Back on topic, I'd be dropping Horne because he's not one of the top 2 wingers available, and his midfield defense isn't needed with K² there.
I'm not a fan of Horne either. I'd have either Tomane, Speight, Mitchell, JOC (James O'Connor) , AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper) and now DHP ahead of him.
But when you say not in the top 2 wingers available, who else is there avaliable? I doubt Naya or Nubili is a better option, Morahan the only one I would consider ready for test rugby.
Morahan. I'd rather we had an out and out winger and finisher with toe. Until Speight or Tomane are available anyway.