Who would you replace them with? Keeping in mind that no team has ever won a world cup without a wealth of experience. I see what he's trying to do. Yes, De Villiers is off form now, but how would he have known that if he didn't give him a chance after his injury recovery? Last year before he was injured, nobody even thought of replacing him.
I don't know what you have against Schalk either. Who would you rather have? If you say Carr I'll puke in my own mouth. Not because he's bad, but he's no better than Schalk and has no experience. If all our loosies were fit, then Schalk wouldn't be there, but now they're not, what do you want Meyer to do?
And the provincialism problem doesn't lie with me, but with you. Your hate for Meyer is so strong that you would even chastise WP players that Meyer picked because your intense hate for him overrides your favor towards WP players, that's how bad it is.
You don't need to confirm nor deny this, your comments speak for themselves.