Good comments,
I think the Reds have sat on their hands with the retention and have dropped the ball as I mentioned with Lawson, James and the rumoured Annan departure. In my opinion they are now extremely skinny in the 10 department with two young and small 10’s to call on with no apparent 3rd or 4th option if injury or form warrants replacement.
Jock would be called upon at this stage and then you wouldn’t have Annan as the back up utility like he was at the end of this season. Grealy on the move as well possibly so now fullback is quite thin with also Jordy rumoured to be leaving.
With the salary cap have they been smart where the money has gone for example, two wallaby locks that would command far more exaggerated wages than prior to this season when we have Smith, Uru, Blythe, Etc that are also now all in the Wallaby fold. Will any be happy missing out on selection moving forward and also get itchy feet like our backs move on because of the new signings?
Just my opinion and i would be interested in your thoughts?
I understand a lot of your concerns - although I won’t try and speak to whether the Reds dropped the ball as such. There are always difficulties in squad management and some of them include that you don’t always know how negotiations will pan out with individual players - especially when the Reds have no control over RA Top Ups. I agree though that l it will be disappointing to lose Grealy & Annan.
But - at the risk of pumping the Reds up as off season champions - I feel like the Reds had a clear opportunity to make a major play for title success next year and they would have been mad if they didn’t take it.
They basically got a free spin at recruiting Salakai-Loto & Canham into a position where we lacked depth and played a player out of position all year. Uru was great - but he isn’t a true lock. Our front row and back rows were already in good shape with quality and depth. Now our locks match. We should be expecting our pack to be up there with the very best.
With regards to the backs - it seems like we were losing Petaia anyway (doesn’t seem related to the Rebels signings in any way) and, if the rumours about Grealy & Creighton are true it sound like he moved on for greater opportunity to be starting players. I feel like this may well have been on the cards anyway.
In any case Daugunu is a test player and playing some of his best footy. And Lynagh should be progressing to a stage where he is expected to start most games, not be carefully managed. Both should be steps up from Grealy & Creighton.
If you look longer term - yes the losses of Annan and Grealy may be impactful but I see a squad where -
- Toomaga-Allen will be gone in 12 months. Du Lutiis hopefully ready to step up but it’s unrealistic to expect him to be at that level in 12 months
- We’ll almost certainly lose one or more of our locks but Smith & Blyth are both at a stage where if they aren’t Wallabies they are potentially looking OS
- If he does re-sign I can’t see us keeping both Wright & Uru beyond next year, and Bryant & Brial will both be at risk too
- Backline probably a bit more settled and a bit more upside with some of the players. Jock maybe the biggest risk of leaving and maybe HMP if he kicks on.
In any case, with titles so hard to win I think sometimes you have to take the opportunity in front of you and if just seems to me the Reds should be chasing 2025 pretty hard.