QLD GPS Rugby 2018

[Garry Owens]

Who knows Darkside ?

But a lot of things can , and will , change between now and next season and to be honest there was a lot of unpredictability / left field stuff going on at GT this year

There were probably a few boys in the 2nds that might have deserved their chance too - one of those a 10 too *shrugs*

All Schools can , and do , see things differently to external selectors - it goes both ways and happens everywhere . I don't think that means anything other than people have different opinions

 

[Les Patterson]

@ Getwithme re BSHS

I count 8 returning U16 players and probably another 2 to 3 from their current U16 team , so , they will need to rely on 14 to 15 U16 players next year and pray for no injuries as their Seconds and 16A's next year don't project to be that good ( if at least 8 to 9 of them are starting )

BSHS's U15 , U14 , U13 and even the U12 A teams seem to be wiping the floor with everybody ( U14 to U12 undefeated ) but they play IGS in the last round which will be interesting with IGS ( as always ) very strong in the under age groups - with they and BSHS always owning the early muscle

Interesting that all BGS A teams down to the U13's only had 1 win this year ( 13's had 2 ) and I don't think the 12's won a game

TGS seems a train wreck down the line with the majority of A Teams from U15 and down with 1 or no wins for the season and their Firsts looking like a wooden spoon recipient and their 16's going 50/50

Churchie seem to have 2 x strong back to back years emerging in U12 and U13 with both teams toward the top end of their competition

TGS won't get the wooden spoon with currently 2 wins. If they beat Terrace at home and finish with 3 wins, they will finish mid-table.

 

[Taipan168]

Round 9 tips

NC in a close game.
IGS
ACGS
TGS

 

[Pinetree]

You would think if they chose Elekana and Bell over Siolo, they wouldn't change that next year. Would be interesting to hear why they went with Elekana as a rookie 10 in the firsts, and then Bell, when Siolo played 10 every year he's been at GT, and also made several club rep sides in that position too.

It seems as though Siolo is seen as a fullback by the school selectors, where he has been lining up in the firsts, a position most pundits see PE playing ..agree with GO every school sees things differently and again next year could be something different b altogether

 

[The Nomad]

It seems as though Siolo is seen as a fullback by the school selectors, where he has been lining up in the firsts, a position most pundits see PE playing ..agree with GO every school sees things differently and again next year could be something different b altogether

Siolo was one of the three lads trialled at 10 by GT before PE was given a go quite late in the piece ( last of the GPS rep trials ).

Siolo was playing 10 for the 16a’s before being called up to replace Mone at 15 for the Firsts .

I can’t tell you why he has been overlooked as a possible 10 for the First XV now twice other than to agree with what Darkside mentioned a while ago in that the selectors would have their reasons .

Thought Bell made a good impression on his crack at 10 for GT , played square and defended well , which seems to fit with what the selectors are looking for .


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[DarkSide]

But a lot of things can , and will , change between now and next season and to be honest there was a lot of unpredictability / left field stuff going on at GT this year

There were probably a few boys in the 2nds that might have deserved their chance too - one of those a 10 too *shrugs*

My son is friends with current year 12 and 11 kids at Terrace, and they play club rugby together. Apart from the 10 position none of them have ever hinted there's much controversy in the selections, and most of the firsts are from grade 11 anyway. Given the results at GT, it would be hard to suggest the seconds are hiding players that should be in the firsts.

 

[Garry Owens]

^Of course . You are right

It was quite the banner season wasn't it ?

 

[Getwithme]

I can understand the switch IMO. Siolo's best characteristic has always been his ability to run with the ball while Elekana's has always been to set up others. Unfortunately Elekana hasn't really clicked with the role just because he's missing a few of the required items in the toolkit. I don't know if either of them would be my preferred 10 for 2019.

 

[TheRugbyGod]

Gideon Wrampling BSHS (2014-2017) has made the New Zealand Schoolboys after being poached by the Chiefs at the end of last season and moving to NZ to finish his schooling. Another loss to the Reds.

 

[The Nomad]

Gideon Wrampling BSHS (2014-2017) has made New Zealand Schoolboys after being poached by the Chiefs at the end of last season. Another loss to the Reds.

That’s great news for Gideon and a massive rise in where he was with his rugby a year ago. Well done to him and yes another miss for this side of the ditch.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[RugbyReg]

What’s his background? Is he just a kiwi returning home?

 

[The Nomad]

The family moved here a number of years ago , older brother made Qld Schoolboys from Kingston High , played some rugby in France after leaving school.

Gideon played First XV for BSHS last year as a 16 year old and a number of age rep teams earlier on . I didn't realise he had moved back to NZ.

 

[I play wing]

Test ref Angus Gardner will be in the middle for Nudgee vs Southport

 

[Rugrat]

A great ref, great venue and 2 outstanding schoolboy teams, how good will Saturday at Ross oval be. Go the Nudge.

 

[Set piece magic]

Is kick off at 2.15?

 

[Rugrat]

1st XV Kick off 2.15 the 2ndxv will also be a cracker of a game kick off 1 pm

 

[Garry Owens]

Yes Seconds will be a humdinger too

16A's as well - if Nudgee lose TSS win outright . If Nudgee do TSS - then TSS share the premiership with BBC ( assuming BBC account for Churchie which they should pretty easily )

 

[Tashara]

Rd8: Brisbane State High School vs Brisbane Boys' College

u16A: BSHS 0 - BBC 50 (0:17 min)
2ndXV: BSHS 5 - BBC 31 (3:58 min)
1stXV: BSHS 24 - BBC 19 (7:32 min)

 

[Oracle83]

Rd8: Brisbane State High School vs Brisbane Boys' College

u16A: BSHS 0 - BBC 50 (0:17 min)
2ndXV: BSHS 5 - BBC 31 (3:58 min)
1stXV: BSHS 24 - BBC 19 (7:32 min)

Great work Tashara - again many thanks - wish every school did the same.

BBC 16A play much more cohesively than the firsts, maybe the coaches could lend a hand this week or do we expect the same lame game plan again?

BBC 2nd XV 2&10 wouldn’t be out of place in firsts with s few of the 16A forwards.

 

[justamum]

My son is friends with current year 12 and 11 kids at Terrace, and they play club rugby together. Apart from the 10 position none of them have ever hinted there's much controversy in the selections, and most of the firsts are from grade 11 anyway. Given the results at GT, it would be hard to suggest the seconds are hiding players that should be in the firsts.

Not sure where you get your information from, I think if you asked most of the Yr 12 boys how they felt, your response would be very incorrect. And I think you will also find that their attitude towards the head coach of the Firsts squad is nothing short of contempt (along with most of the Firsts). There were a number of boys who were as good as the selected boys from the lower grades, but from what I understand it is all about Tom’s team of 2020, and at the cost of a passion to play for the Red and Black.