100% correct justamum. not a happy camp and a complete balls up!! randal mcmurphy cookhuu at the controls!!
QLD GPS Rugby 2018
- Thread starter Jets
- Start date
100% correct justamum. not a happy camp and a complete balls up!! randal mcmurphy cookhuu at the controls!!
Garry Owens
Alan Cameron (40)
Hmmm. Not so hard to suggest at all so it seems
DarkSide
Sydney Middleton (9)
Given this is your 6th post, and 5 of them have been about year 11 kids playing in the firsts, I think I'll let this one go through to the keeper.
I've said it previously here, with the results in the seconds you can hardly argue selections have been wrong in the firsts. Terrace folks might just have to accept they didn't have the cattle this year, they missed their boat in the previous two years.
BraveandGame
Bob Loudon (25)
Just look at the entire AB program at GT seems a complete and utter shambles by far the poorest season I can remember.
BraveandGame
Bob Loudon (25)
Plenty of reasons for that and it is not all about the cattle (although that is becoming a catch cry at Tennyson this season)
You can rest assured justamum is a lot closer to reality than your 'sons mates'!
BAG
Garry Owens
Alan Cameron (40)
Yeah
Not a Terrace bash but you can't slag the 2nds results as the reason why for some of these boys - when the Firsts will finish 2nd last
In fact , one may suggest , that some of the fire had already been lost which may explain some lack of engagement
But hey what would Terrace folk know right ?
I'm sure this is not a Terrace specific thing either as you look around some of the other programs that were expected to fare better and have limped through the season
The truth is , if you are a Rugby fan first and foremost , despite what School you are affiliated with - and despite all the banter - you just want to see all Schools do well as it increases the level of competition and experience for the boys
Not a Terrace bash but you can't slag the 2nds results as the reason why for some of these boys - when the Firsts will finish 2nd last
In fact , one may suggest , that some of the fire had already been lost which may explain some lack of engagement
But hey what would Terrace folk know right ?
I'm sure this is not a Terrace specific thing either as you look around some of the other programs that were expected to fare better and have limped through the season
The truth is , if you are a Rugby fan first and foremost , despite what School you are affiliated with - and despite all the banter - you just want to see all Schools do well as it increases the level of competition and experience for the boys
DarkSide
Sydney Middleton (9)
Fire already lost?
The TGS, BBC, and GT programs have all copped flack along the lines of selection issues and coaching problems. I don't think it's controversial to say that when you lose games you expect to win it's the stock standard approach to blame selections and the coaches. I always raise an eyebrow too when posters come here just to whinge, you have to ask what interest they have in the matter.
The one time I've seen both the firsts and seconds at GT, TGS, and the two occasions I've seen BBC I have not been struck by any great selection or game plan issues. Aside from the odd player, usually an outside back, it didn't seem like the firsts had the wrong kids running around.
Garry Owens
Alan Cameron (40)
Not sure what your ish is DS
You just don't seem to want to accept there is a much greater level of disquiet at GT that is the feeling of multiple persons instead preferring to rely on the inside chat of your son and a couple of his "mates"
That's fine
I too have friends and family at GT and the comment around the Seconds and the leadership in the Senior Program has been made to me by more than a couple of them , that are not directly effected , certainly reinforces the view that has been shared by persons on this thread that , y'know , are at the school . I am sure you are right once again and they are just salty crackers having a whinge with no right and entitlement to do so
Outside of GT - aside from Realist having a crack at what's wrong at TGS before the season started and Oracle83 having a crack at BBC recently , unless you can be bothered to find anything else ( which I don't think you will ) I don't really know what you and your raised eyebrows are talking about
You just don't seem to want to accept there is a much greater level of disquiet at GT that is the feeling of multiple persons instead preferring to rely on the inside chat of your son and a couple of his "mates"
That's fine
I too have friends and family at GT and the comment around the Seconds and the leadership in the Senior Program has been made to me by more than a couple of them , that are not directly effected , certainly reinforces the view that has been shared by persons on this thread that , y'know , are at the school . I am sure you are right once again and they are just salty crackers having a whinge with no right and entitlement to do so
Outside of GT - aside from Realist having a crack at what's wrong at TGS before the season started and Oracle83 having a crack at BBC recently , unless you can be bothered to find anything else ( which I don't think you will ) I don't really know what you and your raised eyebrows are talking about
DarkSide
Sydney Middleton (9)
My Ish GO is this isn’t the place to come and throw mud at individuals such as coaches.
I’m honest when I say no ones really complained around me about selections outside of the 10. Have they bagged the staff? Hell yes, but the GT team I watched lacked the talent to play better than they have, so I put those whinges away as sour grapes. Not to mention the folks who whinge on this forum clearly have an agenda, they rarely post and when they do they always raise a pet issue.
This is the second problem I’ve come across in Aus that I don’t see in NZ. Every coach in GPS has some solid history and skill
Behind them. The people whinging don’t. You guys are great at tearing down, but you don’t have a plan that would do any better.
Lute
Chris McKivat (8)
Yeah, the meds are wearing off Dilly, first post since 2011 !!!, he must have scratched something a bit close to your heartWow that post disappeared quick GO. i knew the salt would come eventually
Dark side, sorry that this was only my 6th post I haven’t had anything to say - until now. Yes I am a Terrace parent who has sat week after week and watched and listened to the talk around me and from my son and his mates. I am not slinging mud, I am stating what I have heard from the boys mouths. The coach in question has experience and knowledge, I have never disputed that. What he lacks however is respect from the Opens Rugby squads. The word toxic was used at a recent game by a parent who, like me, is watching it all implode. I’m lucky I get out this year, they have 2 other boys coming through the school. I only hope that the boys who have lost their way this year continue their Rugby journey back at Club level playing in Colts footy. Thank you BAG and GO for the support.
Garry Owens
Alan Cameron (40)
Fair enough .
I do concede the "new poster" with issue de jour can .......how shall we say ......raise an eyebrow ?
Only thing I would say is that .....it is a message board and people have their opinion ( clearly ) and not everyone will see eye to eye and nor should they .
Personally ....whilst I also agree its not right to rag on Coaches or Refs etc and its not something I would do ( at least publicly ) I also wouldn't go out of my way to wag a finger at them from upon the moral perch.
To be honest with you I felt it a little rich to be talking about some's agenda ( opinion shaping presumably ) on Coaches , on a message board , but , a page or two back you had no compunction in exerting your opinion shaping views about the fate / prospects of a high school player ( The U16 GT 10 ), that , seemed to marginalise him , and frankly seems like a double standard to me - which is why I replied to you re : it doesn't mean anything other than different people see different things
It's reasonable on a forum such as this , or any forum for that matter , there is an exchange of opinion . We can't , nor should we , rule thought or try and moralise it if you are partaking on the same basis. No one is being personally attacked or abused and so long as that is the case then play on
Peace, Trees and Waterfalls and all that
I do concede the "new poster" with issue de jour can .......how shall we say ......raise an eyebrow ?
Only thing I would say is that .....it is a message board and people have their opinion ( clearly ) and not everyone will see eye to eye and nor should they .
Personally ....whilst I also agree its not right to rag on Coaches or Refs etc and its not something I would do ( at least publicly ) I also wouldn't go out of my way to wag a finger at them from upon the moral perch.
To be honest with you I felt it a little rich to be talking about some's agenda ( opinion shaping presumably ) on Coaches , on a message board , but , a page or two back you had no compunction in exerting your opinion shaping views about the fate / prospects of a high school player ( The U16 GT 10 ), that , seemed to marginalise him , and frankly seems like a double standard to me - which is why I replied to you re : it doesn't mean anything other than different people see different things
It's reasonable on a forum such as this , or any forum for that matter , there is an exchange of opinion . We can't , nor should we , rule thought or try and moralise it if you are partaking on the same basis. No one is being personally attacked or abused and so long as that is the case then play on
Peace, Trees and Waterfalls and all that
DarkSide
Sydney Middleton (9)
No worries mate. The post of mine you responded to was about selections, and you shifted that to personalities. If you really have an issue with a coach or staff member, then raise it with the school.
The drop off rate from schoolboy opens to club is quite large normally anyway, and even bigger a year or two out of school. Rugby has some serious work to do to turn that around, it’s a lot more than just the coaches at the school.
Garry Owens
Alan Cameron (40)
^Quite right . Agree on this
Garry Owens
Alan Cameron (40)
Good on ya Mum
Tip Top's the one
Good on ya Mum
Tip Top's the one
Good on ya Mum
The Nomad
Bob Davidson (42)
Great idea, can’t see any problems at any school being solved on any forum. If the school is aware of concerns , it can only be dealt with there .
Good luck to all teams for the last round. Some great match ups and hopefully some great rugby to be played. If the last few weeks are anything to go off , most games could go either way . Would be nice to be discussing what’s happened on the field rather than off it .
Enjoy the last of 2018 !
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Garry Owens
Alan Cameron (40)
How do you see your prospects up the Range , Nomad ?
You guys at full strength ?
You guys at full strength ?
The Nomad
Bob Davidson (42)
Think it will be the same team as last week , so still down a few , but guess most teams would be in a similar situation.
Should be a good match up . Both teams capable of playing good rugby , but have been far from consistent. TGS are always hard to beat up there, as the GT team of 2016 discovered , so who knows , flip a coin maybe ?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk