Again, I am not doubting his ability but he played 4 games. Two of these they lost. Nudgee (19-15) & Southport (44-26). The two wins were against TGS (31-22) and BGS (37-20). I'm pretty sure Churchie still would have won the game vs BGS without Treyvon, no disrespect Grammar boys. I accept that this is your opinion and we are all entitled to one and I do respect it, but I don't believe your argument has legs. I would argue that most, if not all, teams are a better side with their preferred 15 in it, not just Churchie. I believe the comp this year had an exceptional bunch of 15s, Terblanche, Rosemond, Murgha, McGahan, and Johnson (just named in Australian Development squad) who played the whole season and were consistently amongst their team's better payers each week, to name few.