• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

LOCKED: Time to Sack Deans?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Langthorne

Phil Hardcastle (33)
I still don't see a coach that is clearly better than Deans. The sun currently shines out of Link's arse, but for the last few years he had plenty of critics.

Rod MacQueen

I am looking forward to having him back in the coaching ranks. I think he made a big contribution to the strength of the Wallabies through the 90s and early in the new century. He coached the Waratahs successfully in the early 90s, then set up the Brumbies, and following that he took on the Wallabies with great success. Even if he doesn't move back into coaching the Wallabies again, I am confident that whoever is coaching the Wallabies will benefit greatly from having him as one of the s15 coaches.
 

RedsHappy

Tony Shaw (54)
Rod MacQueen I am looking forward to having him back in the coaching ranks. I think he made a big contribution to the strength of the Wallabies through the 90s and early in the new century. He coached the Waratahs successfully in the early 90s, then set up the Brumbies, and following that he took on the Wallabies with great success. Even if he doesn't move back into coaching the Wallabies again, I am confident that whoever is coaching the Wallabies will benefit greatly from having him as one of the s15 coaches.

Big tick. I also think that he could well be approached to take over the Wallabies once more (he's certainly not too old) and he just might be interested if (a) the S15 reignites his passion for coaching and the latest versions of the game and (b) the Rebels don't fall into some awful heap (not suggesting here they will). I'd be quite sure JO'N was thrilled to have him in the S15. Also, if all goes well for him/Rebels, this may induce the right type of competitive pressure for a major coaching upheaval at the Waratahs, Brumbies and Force (although the Force has made the mad and short-sighted decision to go with Graham). (We talk of the Wallabies disappointing, but surely, surely, we have to do better than having only the Tahs scraping into the top 4 every now and then! Apart from the Tahs, our S14 teams really have done very poorly for way too long now, radical change is needed.)
 

Hawko

Tony Shaw (54)
Big tick. I also think that he could well be approached to take over the Wallabies once more (he's certainly not too old) and he just might be interested if (a) the S15 reignites his passion for coaching and the latest versions of the game and (b) the Rebels don't fall into some awful heap (not suggesting here they will). I'd be quite sure JO'N was thrilled to have him in the S15. Also, if all goes well for him/Rebels, this may induce the right type of competitive pressure for a major coaching upheaval at the Waratahs, Brumbies and Force (although the Force has made the mad and short-sighted decision to go with Graham). (We talk of the Wallabies disappointing, but surely, surely, we have to do better than having only the Tahs scraping into the top 4 every now and then! Apart from the Tahs, our S14 teams really have done very poorly for way too long now, radical change is needed.)

Further up the thread someone suggested Gaffney was too old to coach the WB's and now we have people commenting that McQueen is not too old. I might be an old bastard, but I fail to see that age has any importance whatsoever unless the person is too old to keep up round the field at training. McQueen has proven himself to be a master coach, with a record way better than Deans. He is far and away our best option. If he was available now I'd shoehorn him in immediately, but he's not. Our best candidates after McQueen in no particular order are Chieka, Gaffney, Link and Deans. You'll note that only one of those is a S14 coach. The other Aussie S14 coaches are nice people (mainly) but not up to the job.
 

Gagger

Nick Farr-Jones (63)
Staff member
An interview between Growden and Deans - someone get RedsHappy a defibrillator

Why Deans feared he'd get the axe
July 31, 2010
The SMH

Robbie Deans

Man with a plan ... Wallabies coach Robbie Deans. Photo: AFP

Robbie Deans says the Wallabies can turn the corner against New Zealand tonight, writes Greg Growden.

Q

How grating is it for you that Australia have lost the past seven Tests against the All Blacks?

A

You don't like losing any games. But it is the reality. As a coach, I tend to, out of necessity, chase the things that hopefully will address that in time, because that is all you can do. We also ask the players not to watch the scoreboard, but just do the things they need to do. If they focus their energy on that, it maximises their chances of changing that around. Obviously as a coach there is a lot of scrutiny, discussion, and that interests people. That's fine … it's part of the territory. But it doesn't change what is important in terms of dealing with it.

Q

Is it playing on the players' minds?

A

No, I don't think so. And I think you got an insight into that in a press conference here during the week when several of the players explained how they are working hard in order to get the returns they seek. So they are concentrating on the solutions.

Q

Does it make it any more frustrating that against the All Blacks, there has been quite a few occasions where you have done the hard work and taken a half-time lead, only to fall away in the second half?

A

That's happened for many and varied reasons. We haven't had a lot of continuity in terms of availability, which probably contributes to that. But we are bringing more consistency, most evidently in defence, where it has got to start. And I think we got an insight last week against the Springboks … [that] we are starting to make some headway in some of the critical areas. We are getting there. But getting the confirmation would be nice. And we know that confirmation is not going to be given up lightly. We know that the All Blacks are never going to give us a win we never deserve. But that's good.

Q

Does it irritate you that whenever the Bledisloe Cup comes around, the match is written about as a tussle between you and Graham Henry?

A

It doesn't irk me. It's part of the territory, and a piece of interest for people. Different people take different things out of it. That's fine as long as they are interested.

Q

Do you get on with Graham? What is your relationship with him?

A

I don't really have a relationship with him. I respect him as a coach. You've got to respect a man of his longevity. But we don't have a lot of history together. We've competed against each other, from 1997, and so we've opposed each other on numerous occasions. I don't know. I would actually be fascinated to hear what he thinks his relationship with me is like.

Q

For someone who has been attuned to success, is this the hardest period you have gone through?

A

It is tough, but I'm still coaching. The key for me is to stay focused on things which are important. And things which are important don't revolve around me, it revolves around the Wallabies player group. Sure, it gets challenging at times. You do feel it. You're aware of it, because your family and friends are aware of it. It's probably tougher for them, because at least I have the privilege of being able to do something about it. It is also important to monitor what you do day by day. I know externally we are monitored Test match to Test match, and that's fine. But what you see on the weekend is quite simply a reflection of what's happened through the week, and we are getting there, believe it or not. If you want to talk about statistics, the critical statistic is probably … we've moved from fifth to third on the IRB rankings.

Q

How encouraging for you was it that ARU chief John O'Neill came out recently and said that no matter what you will be the Wallabies coach until at least the end of next year's World Cup?

A

To be honest, I don't dwell on it. I understand my responsibility. I also understand that there are people in places who are appointed to make decisions. They are entitled to not only their opinions, but their decisions.

Q

But have there been times where you have been concerned you were about to get a tap on the shoulder?

A

Of course. It is not as if I am blind to that reality.

Q

You handle your emotions pretty well, but there was a moment during the Springboks Test last Saturday night when you started bashing the coach's box window. What was going on there?

A

There were two instances. It is not as if I am not without emotion. They are there, and I've always been worse when we are ahead. Nonetheless, what happened that night was two instances - one was out of frustration over a decision, and the other was at the end of the game I was high-fiving a member of the public who was on the other side of the glass, so it was actually a celebration.

Q

You've come from an environment where there is an abundance of good players, to one where there is a considerable shortage. Were you surprised by the lack of depth in Australian rugby?

A

There's nothing I've experienced here I haven't experienced before. It is very much same challenges, different faces. When I started with the Crusaders, we were stone cold last, and then we chipped away, and got to where we got to.

Q

But have you ever been in a situation where you've picked a squad, dropped someone [like Drew Mitchell], and virtually a week later, you've had to pick him in the team, because everyone has fallen over, and there's no one there?

A

Yeah, routinely.

Q

When?

A

I'd have to go through the books. It happens often, and with high-profile blokes. The Andrew Mehrtens situation with the Crusaders was a challenging period, and there was a time there when we had more international players than places available. Some incumbents were rested, which prompted on one occasion one well-known player refusing to get off the team bus. Again, it's part of the territory.

Q

Yes, but they were quality players. Here you are in a situation where sometimes you're looking for anyone to fill a spot. Just remember last year's end-of-season Wallabies tour when you had to bring in virtual unknowns. Then again, I suppose you can say that in such situations you've found diamonds like Will Genia.

A

Exactly. To me, picking Will wasn't a gamble. The moment I saw him I knew he was something. We have the benefit of insight, because we work day to day with these blokes. The general public will say 'gee, where did he come from?' but we see them, we observe them.

Q

Is it the biggest thrill as a coach, when you pick someone out of left field, and they really blossom?

A

Absolutely. I ambled into coaching. I had no idea I was going to do what I'm now doing. I simply was asked to help out one day with a country colts side. I helped out, and found it quite rewarding, and it went from there. The underlying motive of coaching is the sense of being part of a team that is working towards a purpose. Overcoming the challenges is what it is all about. It's really not about the easy times. I didn't want to go into coaching in the professional era because I was a bit apprehensive the impact professionalism would have on the playing group. Hence I took on managing to get an insight in terms of how the psyche had changed within the playing group. It involved going into unchartered territory, and I wasn't sure whether it was the right thing for me. In a weak moment I relented.

Q

What is the worst part about coaching?

A

You don't like seeing players suffering. Injuries are a bane of the game. To be honest, there are not too many downsides, and to be challenged is good. I am a great believer in no grey moments in life, and you learn from the passing of time that even the bad moments are good, as you recognise the value they offer you in moving on, and getting to where you need to be.

Q

On the eve of this year's Bledisloe Cup, what do you think are the core strengths of this Wallabies team and also the weaknesses?

A

The All Blacks would suggest that there are [weaknesses]. They will target individuals within our group for the hope of profiting because they lack background. But that all comes down to how we manage what we do. The strengths will hopefully be our collective sense of purpose. You saw seeds of that last week. There is a youthful enthusiasm in this group. And we're going to need that, because we don't have the wherewithal of experience. And it's not as if we have the wherewithal in terms of prowess, physical prowess, to be able to be one dimensional. So we're going to have to be smart, think smart, be fully united and committed to the first and the last minute. If you want to be first in the world, that's what you've got to do.
 

cyclopath

George Smith (75)
Staff member
Gee, unusual for Growden not to actually get into the nuts and bolts of the rugby, and focus on a lot of drivel about it being a pissing competition with G Henry. Does it annoy you to have lost 7 times to the ABs? Does it annoy you to have lost after leading 6 times? Does it annoy you to have to talk to a mediocre hack looking for his pay-cheque to go buy a box of party-pies?
 

DPK

Peter Sullivan (51)
what happened that night was two instances - one was out of frustration over a decision, and the other was at the end of the game I was high-fiving a member of the public who was on the other side of the glass, so it was actually a celebration.

That's awesome, will the Hi-Five reciever please stand up?
 

fatprop

George Gregan (70)
Staff member
Maybe we could set up some serious of questions to ask Deans - that rugby fans would like to know.

Like ..................

You don't use your all your bench for tactical changes very often (mostly just for injury replacement), why is that? and do you this could be affecting Aus's falling away in games?
What is the decision process you want players to use when deciding to committing players to rucks?
How are you trying to teach backs to be less selfish?
What attributes do you look for when watching a player's off the ball activity?
 

DPK

Peter Sullivan (51)
Maybe we could set up some serious of questions to ask Deans - that rugby fans would like to know.

Like ..................

You don't use your all your bench for tactical changes very often (mostly just for injury replacement), why is that?
What is the decision process you want players to use when deciding to committing players to rucks?
How are you trying to teach backs to be less selfish?
What attributes do you look for when watching a player's off the ball activity?

We had the opportunity when Reg was piping up at his birthday presser.
 
O

ozreyel

Guest
NO!!!!

Like every coach in history and judging from a few of the above posts, Deans is damned if he does, and damned if he doesn't. If he hadn't blooded the younger guys, we'd all be screaming for him to do so!! Now that he has, we're saying it was too early. And where would we be at the end of 3N 2010 with another series down the gurgler and no newer faces on the Wallaby scene. Deans has done a solid if not better than average job and with a very limited number of established Wallaby let alone world class players.

We are also STILL suffering the lasting 'hangover' of greatly OVER prescribed game plan from Eddie Jones, (who rode on the coat tails of McQueen as far as player stocks and winning culture with both Wallabies and Brumbies) and finally getting some form of 'play whats in front of us' game style back. All the while with less experience and quality as coaches since have the luxury since the mid 1990's.
 

Reddy!

Bob Davidson (42)
NO!!!!

Like every coach in history and judging from a few of the above posts, Deans is damned if he does, and damned if he doesn't. If he hadn't blooded the younger guys, we'd all be screaming for him to do so!! Now that he has, we're saying it was too early. And where would we be at the end of 3N 2010 with another series down the gurgler and no newer faces on the Wallaby scene. Deans has done a solid if not better than average job and with a very limited number of established Wallaby let alone world class players.

We are also STILL suffering the lasting 'hangover' of greatly OVER prescribed game plan from Eddie Jones, (who rode on the coat tails of McQueen as far as player stocks and winning culture with both Wallabies and Brumbies) and finally getting some form of 'play whats in front of us' game style back. All the while with less experience and quality as coaches since have the luxury since the mid 1990's.

I agree with what you have to say in your first paragraph, but disagree in your second. Eddie Jones has nothing to do with the Wallabies anymore and hasn't since the end of 2005. A generational change has occurred, therefore I doubt there is any remains of the Eddie Jones Wallabies left. That is just making excuses and pointing the figure at something, which quite frankly, isn't there. Welcome to the forum anyway :)

I think tonight is going to be a pretty defining moment for not only the Wallabies but Robbie Deans. If they win in whatever manner, there is going to be light at the end of the tunnel and faith will be restored somewhat. If we lose by a little bit it's back to the drawing board for another week, but perhaps glimpses of what we are capable of were exhibited. If, god forbid, we are thrashed by 30-40 points, the Wallabies and Robbie Deans face very very testing times in the future indeed.
 

RedsHappy

Tony Shaw (54)
An interview between Growden and Deans - someone get RedsHappy a defibrillator

Funnily enough I only have a year to live, so this (probably) won't be needed. Much of this GG-RD exchange is post-media-adviser Robbie-speak where he sounds (to me at least) more like a politician choosing nearly every word, than the person he is. The whole thing is generally so anodyne, it's hard to argue much with anything RD is saying. But, a little bit of my thinking and perception re RD today has shifted after the last week of my Deans-watching, and I copy it below with some comments I made (in the GAGR blog) re RD and the Wallabies following on from LF's ABs game preview here on GAGR:

Thanks LF. Many excellent points.

For me, you under-referenced two major factors. The Wallabies’ tendency for ‘soft mind’ under pressure, especially when they need to repeat a good game a second time, and Austin’s ‘underlying truths’ analysis relating how the Wallabies’ handling and related consistency-of-skill KPIs have been sub-world-class all of June, and into July as well (and in some cases materially worse than our S14 counterparts, even though it’s the same players in both groups). If these areas aren’t fixed on Saturday, there will be no chance of a win for Oz, and all the fan-love in the world will make not a jot of difference. (Btw, IMO, these two problems are related.)

Assuming the core skills KPIs get fixed (and it’s alarming there were not after 4+ June Tests), I am more optimistic for this Saturday than previously. Why? I saw on Saturday the glimmers of the ‘hard mind’ needed to win the biggest games. It was there at the breakdown and loose ball contest zone for almost all of 80, that’s where it was, right there, neon lights on. That ferocity and application was exceptional, and its consistency was most un-Wallaby-like. There is just some kind of dawn moment of new psychology emerging in this team – I think Genia, Elsom, Cooper and Pocock are its principal bearers – that I have not witnessed for a very long time. If we can sustain that without Cooper, we have a chance, because IMO what has been the X-factor whenever we have beaten the ABs is Australia’s capacity for magnificent flashes of intuitive, daring rugby brilliance just at the right moment when the ABs cannot respond, and when they least expect it. We never, ever win through brute force and ‘better players’ really, we win because we can be uniquely Australian rugby artists when the ABs are being just fine – and the best – rugby athletes.

The final thing for me was the transformation of Deans in the box and this week. At last, I sense this cool, Kiwi-internaliser, paid observer and analyst really turned local, his heart, his fear, his future, his core conjoined with the anxiety and fear and fraught passion of it all and he became one with these players. Huge positive. Combined with this team’s own knowledge that fate is awaiting them now, the excuses are gone for good, and Dean’s inner self really connecting with them, we could forge a moment of glory, and this is often how the best wins happen. The right human emotions connecting with a game-changing piece of brilliance.
 

Scott Allen

Trevor Allan (34)
I'm at the airport on my way to Melbourne for the game - I'll be at the press conference tonight so load me up with your questions and I'll see what I can get from Robbie.
 

DPK

Peter Sullivan (51)
I'm at the airport on my way to Melbourne for the game - I'll be at the press conference tonight so load me up with your questions and I'll see what I can get from Robbie.

The question of underuse of the bench is pretty high on the priority list IMO.
 

Gnostic

Mark Ella (57)
The question of underuse of the bench is pretty high on the priority list IMO.

Fat Prop's question about bench usage please. Most of us have been left dumbfounded by the lack of bench usage when some players are obviously off the pace.

My best example of recent times was Genia in the 2nd England test when he was obviously still carrying the leg injury and then broke his hand and his passing went downhill. Why did Burgess not get a run when the week before he played the best game he has ever played?
 

DPK

Peter Sullivan (51)
Fat Prop's question about bench usage please. Most of us have been left dumbfounded by the lack of bench usage when some players are obviously off the pace.

My best example of recent times was Genia in the 2nd England test when he was obviously still carrying the leg injury and then broke his hand and his passing went downhill. Why did Burgess not get a run when the week before he played the best game he has ever played?

Yep, but don't use a specific example like that one; Deans will just say something like:
Robbie Deans -
"Well, obviously, you know, I mean, we had to get Will some game time *Long pause with weird, akward nodding* so.... yeah, I mean, obviously we would like to give Luke a run, but, I mean, you see...."

Just use a stat attack, Austin. Something like "You've only used more than 2 benched player 6 times since taking over..." or something like that.
 

RedsHappy

Tony Shaw (54)
I'm at the airport on my way to Melbourne for the game - I'll be at the press conference tonight so load me up with your questions and I'll see what I can get from Robbie.

(Btw, I think RD made an attempt at answering 'the bench question' last week, didn't he?)

Tonight, I would favour a variant of DPK's 'stat attack' suggestion, namely: you Austin list a couple of those carefully checked % performance stats you have revealed recently re Wallaby handling errors, back line attack strategies, etc, and then ask: "Mr Deans, do you agree these KPIs are of significance in assessing the Wallabies' state of game-winning capability, and, if so, what exactly have your coaching team being doing week-to-week to address them?"

(Oh, PS, don't forget an autograph for Gagger and daz.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top