Arch Manning the halfback
Bob McCowan (2)
I would also agree, however, Harper is more crucial to BGS as they do not have as valuable cover
AMtH
QLD GPS 2024
- Thread starter Make_Rugby_Great_Again
- Start date
AMtH
50/23
Peter Burge (5)
nudgee?? sorry, im positive he goes to churchie is this correct?
GPS Lover
Herbert Moran (7)
I hate to break it to you but he goes to ACGS and also he hasn't missed as many games as Charlie Bird who only got to play one game before being injured.
GPS Lover
Herbert Moran (7)
That is fair enough I can see why it is worse for BGS as they have no depth.
The Blin6side
Darby Loudon (17)
Should the GPS place a ban on boys repeating to get ‘One More Year’ of first footy… It’s schoolboy for a reason. I just don’t get it, if you disagree, please reply…
footybaby
Larry Dwyer (12)
It's a tough topic it does show repeaters have plenty of passion for the sport and there school though.
rugby.jacko
Ward Prentice (10)
I have to disagree, I don't think its a great thing. But these boys have a right to repeat as it is still their age group.
GPS Lover
Herbert Moran (7)
Yeah I agree no matter what even if you are the younger part of the grade it is just unnecessary as you were placed in that grade for a reason. It also takes away opportunities for other players and there is also more than just schoolboy footy there is no need to extend your time just make do with what you do. I know as someone who was the younger part of the grade i would never Repeat as it is just unnecessary once you have had your time move on
Daniel Koalins
Herbert Moran (7)
yes they should it's unfair to boys who work hard to get into the first all for someone like Jacob Johnson to repeat and steal their spot because they want to go over 3 years
not so much as stealing their spot but not allowing them the oppourtunity
Get em onside
Sydney Middleton (9)
Even if Charlie Bird was in the team I still think BBC would have similar results. The impact Treyvon Pritchard has on the team is black and white. One week they go from losing to GT and the next they lose by the barest of margins to NC. Im playing the Ball and not the man here but Treyvon is much better than Charlie Bird.
GPS Lover
Herbert Moran (7)
Fair enough mate I can see where you are coming from
Breakdown bunny
Allen Oxlade (6)
Don't get me wrong, I love people with plenty of passion for their school, however taking someone's opportunity because you don't want to move on to the real world is unfair.
footybaby
Larry Dwyer (12)
We all know Trevon is a superstar but Charlie Bird is a great player as well who can play the number 15 and 10 role very solid.
Wayne Bennett 2ndMarriage
Ted Fahey (11)
"He scored three tries and was centimetres from a fourth.
One of BSHS’s best week-to-week players,"
Thoughts on Langi's contender spot at MVP after round 6.
One of BSHS’s best week-to-week players,"
Thoughts on Langi's contender spot at MVP after round 6.
Breakdown bunny
Allen Oxlade (6)
Don't think anyone else but Roman will take that MVP award. Just what I think in my opinion.
50/23
Peter Burge (5)
100 percent he has been state highs rock and stand out all season, i would not be suprised if he takes them to an undefeated premiership
backfencebandit
Chris McKivat (8)
Might be a surprise take but since BGS moving Zac Reader to Fullback I would have to say him with BGS gameplan centred around kicking and him being the pivotal part of them not losing by 50+ each week is his kicking getting them out of trouble. Although Jacob Johnson from NC and his extensive soccer background definitely assists him in this conversation.
50/23
Peter Burge (5)
I completely agree with you here BFB. After my son played his game for the 13E's i stayed to watch firsts (BBCvsBGS) Zac's kicking game saw many problems arise in BBC's gameplan and solving them was not easy as Zac kept picking out the corners with no problem at all.
Breakdown bunny
Allen Oxlade (6)
Gonna have to take Jacob Johnson, having that first football background.