Rebel man
John Thornett (49)
Even Noah or Jack Deb before Donaldson
Wallabies 2023
- Thread starter RugbyReg
- Start date
Tomthumb
Chilla Wilson (44)
Yeah I'm sure Eddie's master plan was to pick a team to lose
Bullrush
Geoff Shaw (53)
I actually don't care that much about who EJ (Eddie Jones) picks. As I said originally, it's his team, it's his right to select whoever he wants.
Just don't tell me how the new players have 'earned it' or any other BS. Wallaby fans here know that some of the guys selected weren't even good at Super Rugby level.
Bullrush
Geoff Shaw (53)
No. I said this is a team that is about the future. But it's not a serious RWC winning selection.
Dctarget
Tim Horan (67)
I like Skelton as captain. We have a great heritage of locks captaining us. Hooper looked whiney, McDermott is a scrum half, who the fuck is going to tell Skelton off. He’s a man giant who’ll always be composed. Hopefully it helps mitigate his red card for when he inevitably shoulder charges someone.
shame he’s playing overseas forever.
shame he’s playing overseas forever.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
Western Force have 2 Wallaby 9s and a 10. Only 1 has played a game for them and the 10 is likely to ride the bench for them.
What a time.
What a time.
Jimmy_Crouch
Peter Johnson (47)
15 of 33 have less than 5 caps and only 3 ofthe 33 have more than 50caps.
dusk
Vay Wilson (31)
I think the backup 10 is likely to be Kellaway. Played there at school and seems like someone who could cover that position well. Read an article few months ago which said that Jorgensen could make the switch to 10 later on - maybe he plays there but tbh that sounds like a horrible idea for someone so young.
Linerunner2023
Watty Friend (18)
This side shows a couple of things
Eddie does not have a fnn clue what his side and squad is
You need experience around to help youth,
he has had guys training all the time like longeran but then gets dropped? And Cooper and hooper playing in front of Gleeson and Donaldson but the later get picked?
Suli and Donaldson selections are a complete joke - even these players would have to know
The experience that’s left behind - when carter gorden gets found out at RWC like he did in bledislode and they have no one to turn to like Quade - and he becomes the next production like?
when hooper and ikatau are injured so injured players don’t go but injured players do like tupou ?
Eddie jones talks so much BS saying we will win RWC, despite a 4 and 0 record with 2 floggings
Seems like he is looking at 2025 and 2025 which he won’t be there to see
Eddie does not have a fnn clue what his side and squad is
You need experience around to help youth,
he has had guys training all the time like longeran but then gets dropped? And Cooper and hooper playing in front of Gleeson and Donaldson but the later get picked?
Suli and Donaldson selections are a complete joke - even these players would have to know
The experience that’s left behind - when carter gorden gets found out at RWC like he did in bledislode and they have no one to turn to like Quade - and he becomes the next production like?
when hooper and ikatau are injured so injured players don’t go but injured players do like tupou ?
Eddie jones talks so much BS saying we will win RWC, despite a 4 and 0 record with 2 floggings
Seems like he is looking at 2025 and 2025 which he won’t be there to see
Tomthumb
Chilla Wilson (44)
One Player, Donaldson, didn't have a great season. He also made his test debut under Dave Rennie so I thought you'd like him
Time will tell if Eddie has got it right or wrong, but to assert that a maniacal competitor like him would not be trying to win the World Cup is ludicrous
Tomthumb
Chilla Wilson (44)
They did turn to Quade, and he dropped the ball with a 2 man overlap in a 20 all game
Stop pretending he's Dan Carter or Bernie
molman
Jim Lenehan (48)
I've got to say I was reflecting a little on the Wales squad whilst seeing the confirmation of selections for the Wallabies RWC contingent. Whilst I'll be curious how they (Wales) go against England this weekend with more of their first choice players, it was still impressive to see how quickly Gatland has been able to fuse a relatively new squad into a coherent whole.
What was also rather obvious in that game was the passion and drive the new faces brought. Whilst experience can be a great thing, I do sometimes wonder at the hunger of youth over that of a been there, seen that veteran.
Anyway, at the end of the day I guess Eddie wasn't brought in to do more of the same. Can't say I understand all the permutations, but it's an interesting squad.
What was also rather obvious in that game was the passion and drive the new faces brought. Whilst experience can be a great thing, I do sometimes wonder at the hunger of youth over that of a been there, seen that veteran.
Anyway, at the end of the day I guess Eddie wasn't brought in to do more of the same. Can't say I understand all the permutations, but it's an interesting squad.
Linerunner2023
Watty Friend (18)
Yep so we turn to
Ben Donaldson?
TSR
Andrew Slack (58)
So far his captains have been Slipper, Hooper, Ala'alatoa & McDermott. Only one of those was ever going to play 80 minutes so I don’t think it’s a real factor. Interestingly thought with Skelton & McDermott C & VC it’s likely neither will be on at the end.
Lorenzo
Colin Windon (37)
I think the value of the "experience" and "mentoring" qualities associated with 30-somethings that have played >60 tests yet have barely participated in the winning of a meat tray is vastly overstated/overrated. What sort of mentoring or coaching is Cooper expected to provide Gordon exactly and when are people thinking he'll be providing it? Over dinner when they're all scrolling through instagram? When theyre in the gym and have the airpods in? Do people think Quade and Gordon will be sitting in a dark room after practice doing additional game film study and sharing 5/8 secrets? Is he expected to have some invaluable wisdom about how to get over the mental hump and perform with precision every time you step on the turf?
TSR
Andrew Slack (58)
Sure - but are any of those guys actually hard done by?