Wallabies 2012

[Forcefield]

I confess that I am no fan of Inman. There is something about him. Based on what I saw of the Rebels game this week he is no chance of ever playing for Australia: he threw an absolutely shocking pass and he gets himself out of position in attack - he's a backrower in a backs body: mind you I reckon he could play in the backrow at s 15 level.

Me neither. I wasn't a fan of him when he played for the Force. I haven't seen him much for the Rebels but there are some unchangeables about him: He's not fast enough and he doesn't have creativity or nous. If you were playing two playmakers at 10/12 then maybe he could fit in, but if Deans persists with McCabe at 12 then he has to be ruled out. That would be dreadful.

I'd sooner give the 13 role to AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper), who has excelled there in the past, and is faster and stronger in the tackle. Next best option is Horne- S15 form does not equal Wallabies form. I think Cummins should come into consideration. He has looked good the last two weeks he's spent at 13 for the Force. He would look even better with better backs surrounding him.

 

[MrMouse]

Me neither. I wasn't a fan of him when he played for the Force. I haven't seen him much for the Rebels but there are some unchangeables about him: He's not fast enough and he doesn't have creativity or nous. If you were playing two playmakers at 10/12 then maybe he could fit in, but if Deans persists with McCabe at 12 then he has to be ruled out. That would be dreadful.

I'd sooner give the 13 role to AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper), who has excelled there in the past, and is faster and stronger in the tackle. Next best option is Horne- S15 form does not equal Wallabies form. I think Cummins should come into consideration. He has looked good the last two weeks he's spent at 13 for the Force. He would look even better with better backs surrounding him.

This pains me to say, but the Honey Badger would be a better option than Horney at the moment...

 

[Scotty]

Happy to see McCabe as a 13 option. Please not at 12.