PaarlBok
Rod McCall (65)
Decided to open a SA Rugby thread where we can discuss all matters regarding SA Rugby and you welcome to throw in some questions regarding our game. Oom Paarl will be to keen to give you the info regarding anything player movement, CC stuff , refering, Bokke info, our schoolboy game, exct.
Have already started the Tamooau thread but we had two Aussie refs in action in our CC. Myself love the idea and hope this will happen much more in future.
SARugby.net
Have already started the Tamooau thread but we had two Aussie refs in action in our CC. Myself love the idea and hope this will happen much more in future.
SARugby.net
Aussie ref in the Currie Cup
Mon, 28 Sep 2009 17:41
Australian players have played in the Currie for several years, but this year, for the first time, Australians have refereed Currie Cup matches. They came to South Africa for two rounds of the Currie Cup - two matches each.
The referees are Paul Marks of Queensland and Ian Smith of New South Wales. The first weekend Marks referee the match between Boland Cavaliers and the Blues Bulls at Boland Stadium in Wellington and Smith refereed the match between the Leopards and Western Province at Olën Park in Potchefstroom.
For the second weekend the pair had the pick of the matches. Smith was a Loftus Versfeld when the Cheetahs came to play the Bulls and marks was at Newlands when Griquas came to play Western Province. The Newlands match has historical interest - the oldest unions in South Africa playing at the oldest ground. The Currie Cup has been played at Newlands since 1894 and for the first time there was an Australian to referee it.
A few weeks prior to this a Scot, Peter Allan, had two Currie Cup matches - the derby between Griquas and Free State and the match between Boland and the Sharks. Meanwhile Nathan Pearce of Australia has twice refereed Air New Zealand Cup matches, also an innovation.
Paul Marks was in Cape Town when the weather was Western Cape awful, but we asked him about this new trend in refereeing.
He explained that over the last two years SANZAR had been keen to introduce a merit-based panel of referees instead of being hidebound by the principle of appointing only unattached referees. Marks said: "There is a good relationship between the three referee managers - Anthony Eddy, André Watson and Lyndon Bray. Our man Anthony Eddy pushed hardest for it and so Australia has had the first opportunity for referees on the fringe of the merit-based system to go to the other countries to show their wares. They can then show if they are capable of taking the place of referees on the merit panel who may be injured or in poor form.
"It's a great privilege for us to referee in such competitions - certainly not a responsibility taken lightly."
Reciprocity? After all if local referees are to be asked to "give up" matches they would love to referee, then there must be a quid pro quo. Australia just does not have a provincial competition the equivalent of the Currie Cup or the Air New Zealand Cup. It had a provincial competition but that was abandoned after a year because of the expense involved.
"The idea is that next year New Zealand and South African referees will referee in the later stages of the Brisbane and Sydney club competitions. It may seem that there is some disparity in this but the club matches in Brisbane and Sydney are of good quality with the return of the Super 14 players to club rugby. They may not have the same profile as the Currie Cup and the Air New Zealand Cup but the quality is there. "
For the Australians coming to South Africa, Australia pays for the flights, South Africa for the accommodation. The referees are full-time professionals and in Australia they do not receive match fees, which means that they will not be paid to referee Currie Cup matches.
Enjoyed it?
"Oh yes. I always enjoy coming to South Africa - the people, the culture, the hospitality and the rugby. Three of my favourite SANZAR venues are here - Newlands, Loftus and Durban."
Boland vs Blue Bulls?
"It was one-sided in the end but for much of the match Boland gave as good as they got. There was nothing wrong with the physicality of the match but in the end the Blue Bulls' conditioning and speed were too much. But it was a great experience - stunning scenery and great hospitality. The ground is old-fashioned and it was a bit like going back to the amateur days - refereeing a professional match in an amateur ethos. Bit like refereeing at Ballymore."
Western Province vs Griquas?
"The rain let up in the second half and I thoroughly enjoyed the match. I thought Western Province played really well in the conditions - kept the ball well."
The next day he started the long trek home to Brisbane via Johannesburg and Sydney. Being placed in refereeing where he is now Marks is away a fair bit. One year it was 145 days. This year it will be 121 days. "The players travel in teams but we are lone most of the time. It takes some getting used to."
At home there is his supportive wife Linda and their children - Isabella (7) and Ben (5).
"The travelling is the best and worst of refereeing. I love the travel and going to new places but at the same time it takes me away from my family and the kids are getting to the age when they would like their father around a bit more."