chief said:Also touch judge on the Hardman (lineout) call was disgraceful, it couldn't have been straighter. correct. I replayed it a few times and couldn't see anything wrong with the throw. If it's in that metre channel between the shoulders it's OK. I did my research and Stephen Hill was the same AR who missed that forward pass in the Reds game when the Tahs scored even when Joubert asked him. wrong. The passer's hands were straight across the paddock; his forward momentum made the ball go forward but that's OK according to the Laws. Hill got this one right.