Fireworks
Jimmy Flynn (14)
That was directed at CFS wasn't it? After dropping the pass from Taps. Was a bit harsh in my opinion. Marto does seem to have random no filter moments where he just says whatever.
Reds v Waratahs, round 4, Saturday 7 March
- Thread starter Lindommer
- Start date
- Status
That was directed at CFS wasn't it? After dropping the pass from Taps. Was a bit harsh in my opinion. Marto does seem to have random no filter moments where he just says whatever.
You should probably have a crack at Beale for injuring Slipper's neck as well. That must have been foul play as well.
Fireworks
Jimmy Flynn (14)
I don't blame you. Was a nightmare to watch. Absolutely the polar opposite of the Reds plated up in the '10-'12 days.
leakytap
Sydney Middleton (9)
It was aimed at Tapuai.
Froggy
Nicholas Shehadie (39)
From a Tahs fan, there was a fair bit to like about that (and yes, I agree it was a rubbish game).
They are certainly trying to play that fast, expansive game with aggression at the breakdown and in defence that worked so well last year, and broadly it worked, let down of course by the awful handling. The defence was 100% better than the last two games, which conceded eight tries, and was getting back to where it was last year. The scrum seems to be improving, and clearly got the ascendency on the Reds. As many here have said, they could have put on 50 but for the woeful handing, but they created the opportunities to do so, which is positive.
Individually, both props had fine games, both in the scrum and around the paddock, and I thought Palu was good. Phipps is getting better, although still not back to last year's form, and both Foley and Beale were very good. Carraro mad the most of his opportunity, and Betham looked excellent with the ball so long as someone tells him never to kick again!
On the negative side, way, way too much ball dropped, both in contact and on the run. I think Potgeiter coughed it up at least four times, Folau three times, and TPN, Skelton, Phipps and others were also guilty. Another thing that Cheika needs to address is the dumb penalties, of which there were way too many (particularly among the bench players). The Reds were gifted the position for the try following stupidity, first by Nayarovaro (okay, I have no idea how to spell it) and then Ryan putting their brains in neutral and giving away two penalties in a row. Both these issues, the handing and the penalties, are about remaining mentally switched on for the eighty minutes, and that's what now needs addressing.
As to the Reds, they were just awful. I thought Thompson was the only person in a red jumper who looked the goods on the night. The front row got smashed, Gill tried hard but with little effect, Genia is still not back to form, Frisby has no idea of 10 and it is really unfair trying to have him learn it at this level, the centres were ineffectual and JOC (James O'Connor) just couldn't get into the game. The loss of key players is really hurting them, and particular Cooper, who they desparately need as they have no plan B at 10.
Finally, I really hope Lachey Turner is okay. Great guy and good player who has been belted by injury (the Ben Tune syndrome), lets hope all is well and he's back soon.
They are certainly trying to play that fast, expansive game with aggression at the breakdown and in defence that worked so well last year, and broadly it worked, let down of course by the awful handling. The defence was 100% better than the last two games, which conceded eight tries, and was getting back to where it was last year. The scrum seems to be improving, and clearly got the ascendency on the Reds. As many here have said, they could have put on 50 but for the woeful handing, but they created the opportunities to do so, which is positive.
Individually, both props had fine games, both in the scrum and around the paddock, and I thought Palu was good. Phipps is getting better, although still not back to last year's form, and both Foley and Beale were very good. Carraro mad the most of his opportunity, and Betham looked excellent with the ball so long as someone tells him never to kick again!
On the negative side, way, way too much ball dropped, both in contact and on the run. I think Potgeiter coughed it up at least four times, Folau three times, and TPN, Skelton, Phipps and others were also guilty. Another thing that Cheika needs to address is the dumb penalties, of which there were way too many (particularly among the bench players). The Reds were gifted the position for the try following stupidity, first by Nayarovaro (okay, I have no idea how to spell it) and then Ryan putting their brains in neutral and giving away two penalties in a row. Both these issues, the handing and the penalties, are about remaining mentally switched on for the eighty minutes, and that's what now needs addressing.
As to the Reds, they were just awful. I thought Thompson was the only person in a red jumper who looked the goods on the night. The front row got smashed, Gill tried hard but with little effect, Genia is still not back to form, Frisby has no idea of 10 and it is really unfair trying to have him learn it at this level, the centres were ineffectual and JOC (James O'Connor) just couldn't get into the game. The loss of key players is really hurting them, and particular Cooper, who they desparately need as they have no plan B at 10.
Finally, I really hope Lachey Turner is okay. Great guy and good player who has been belted by injury (the Ben Tune syndrome), lets hope all is well and he's back soon.
Inside Shoulder
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Well it wasn't the greatest pass so I thought it might have been at Taps.
i prefer to think Marto has random filtered moments when he doesn't say whatever first comes into his head - but they're getting randomer (sic).
Strewthcobber
Simon Poidevin (60)
Surprised nobody has mention the two biggest issues for the reds last night, both second rowers were awful.
They couldn't trust the scrum or lineout so couldn't even revert to the Force kicking+set piece game plan.
They couldn't trust the scrum or lineout so couldn't even revert to the Force kicking+set piece game plan.
Quick Hands
David Wilson (68)
I think that Marto's filtering process has been offline for some time.
Quick Hands
David Wilson (68)
Even in the dark days of Hickey/Foley our set piece held up. I think the Reds are now entering Matt Williams territory. (Which isn't that good for Australian rugby)
T
TOCC
Guest
They were 3rd and maybe 5th choice options so maybe a little harsh on them, but agreed that they struggled against Skelton and Dennis.
I watch more than I shoot. But both options would give me more insight than you.
T
TOCC
Guest
I wasn't talking about Beale, I would have to watch that play again to see what happened there... It was in reply to BH's comment who said in professional sport the referee decides when to stop play, I don't agree.. If someone is injured or at risk of injury you don't play on for the sake of playing the whistle if they are in the area of the play.
The referee doesn't see everything, players are the first to identify injuries as they hear a crack, a snap, or a scream of pain in the collision or contact.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
T
TOCC
Guest
Sully, plenty of people have mentioned Meehans name... But ultimately RG is the head coach and he is responsible for his assistant coaches.. If he identified deficiencies in assistant coach in 2014 or even during the NRC he should have taken steps to fix that or replace him...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
gel
Ken Catchpole (46)
That is not true.
Meehan has copped quite a lot of criticism as well.
Reds v Force 2015 Super Rugby Rd 2
I couldn't have made myself more clear, I would have thought.
- Status