• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

QLD Reds 2010

Status
Not open for further replies.

Godfrey

Phil Hardcastle (33)
I think that's a real shame and can't understand why he wouldn't be going with the squad. He has played pretty well this year and made some pretty good breaks, not to mention helping to turn 1/2 or 3/4 chances into tries. I noticed at the force game he didn't get a run on when nearly everyone else did. Probably a precaution to keep a back reserve incase of injury, but still...
 

louie

Desmond Connor (43)
given he's experience and no form i think this is a really stupid move. why being the main question.
 
T

tranquility

Guest
It doesn't bother me too much. For two reasons, the first being that it will give Will Chambers some vital game time at 13 and second is that it allows Ben Tapuai to go on tour.

The fact that Kingi is not going shows that he is already on the plane to Melbourne, therefore we need to show Tapuai he is getting opportunities so that he doesn't do the same thing.

Morgan has been playing okay - and I really like him in the squad because the younger blokes can learn alot from him tactically - but to be brutally honest we look a lot more threatening when he is on the pine. Sorry mate.
 
G

Geeves

Guest
Its not the first time Link has cut Turinui.

Last time he cut him from NSW.
 

en_force_er

Geoff Shaw (53)
If I remember correctly, and I may be wrong, he wasn't cut but forced onto the wing.

Surely Link couldn't cut Weekes even if he is moving?
 
T

tranquility

Guest
No, Link told Morgan when he was at the Tahs that he had no use for him.

As for Laurie well i'm not quite sure. Let's just wait for an official doctrine first before we go down that road.

But if he does abort ship, which it looks like he might - then I would have no problem discarding him in place of Kennedy, Slipper or Dayna. Even though I love Laurie - his name would become very dirty in Queensland.
 

Godfrey

Phil Hardcastle (33)
tranquility said:
It doesn't bother me too much. For two reasons, the first being that it will give Will Chambers some vital game time at 13 and second is that it allows Ben Tapuai to go on tour.

The fact that Kingi is not going shows that he is already on the plane to Melbourne, therefore we need to show Tapuai he is getting opportunities so that he doesn't do the same thing.

Morgan has been playing okay - and I really like him in the squad because the younger blokes can learn alot from him tactically - but to be brutally honest we look a lot more threatening when he is on the pine. Sorry mate.

I thought Kingi was injured?
 

red army

Bob McCowan (2)
i hear that out of the academy schatz and slipper are staying around for another 2 years and Tapuai's attracting some interest...i think they would have to secure him pretty quickly or melbourne could throw up something juicy for him.

I wonder if the "fringe" players they talk about maybe Quirk, Toua or Situati...maybe they hold off a bit to see if they show them something in club rugby. Quirk was good in the A game against casi. Tough and uncompromising be good to get him back from 7's and into the 15 a side game. Could possibly replace Braid if hes not cleared to stay. Toua's an interesting one. Looked good in the A games maybe starting to get some confidence back after he's knee recon. Although Morahan did play 15 against the chiefs, if he doesnt score that try he would've had a pretty ordinary game at the back, most definetely a winger IMO.

Surprising Morgs isnt on the plane to SA could be an indication he is on the outer..i guess they'll have to start moulding Chambers into a 13 incase something happens to Ioane...

i wonder who the 22 are that are already signed for 2011???
 
T

TOCC

Guest
Link doesnt sound happy

McKenzie was initially taken aback when informed of Melbourne's announcement, with the coach learning of the move through the media instead of being informed by his departing player.

Earlier in the day, as he named the touring squad for South Africa, McKenzie had said he was still keen on fighting for the signature of Weeks. But with news filtering out of Victoria just after lunch, months of speculation finally came to a grinding halt.

"We've been negotiating with him for three-and-a-half months now. I couldn't get to the bottom of why. I probably still won't understand why because the logic doesn't make sense to me," McKenzie said.

"With a World Cup year coming up, to push through to the Wallabies he was in good shape. I guess he could do it from down there but some might say he's taking a risk with that decision."

I've seen plenty of these things go on. I look at things fairly objectively. It's not a decision I'll probably ever understand but everyone has to make their own lot in life. I understand that. It's his decision," McKenzie said.

"He's going well. Of course it's disappointing. It's not necessarily logical but everyone has to make their own calls in life so we respect that. It's just the way it is. I'm not going to stress about it too much. I'll just look at our options."
 

Ruggo

Mark Ella (57)
That don't look to good for Mr Weeks. If the top sentence is true, I don't blame him for being pissed off.
 
T

TOCC

Guest
i understand a player willing to leave, but you would at least think you have the respect to tell your team mates and coach first
 
T

tranquility

Guest
It looks very average doesn't it? I wonder how the player's will take it?

With Regards to Tirinui - it is very interesting that Tapuai copped a direct mention from Link regarding the traveling party/ the omission.

This may suggest a bargaining tool as they try to get Ben's signature. He would have to be a target as he is match ready right now. He would be a priority signing if it were my side.

As for Quirk, I don't think he is 'fringe' I just think he is very young and they want to see him play some 15s he will be on a rookie contract no doubt about it next year.
 

spectator

Bob Davidson (42)
As an armchair commentator I think Turinui's omission from the SA touring squad is plain dumb. His positional sense is top shelf. However, Tapuai's selection more than suggests that he has been signed on and he is a 'clever' player who can fill the 13 spot if need be.

Kennedy's selection ahead of Slipper is a big indication that Link is looking to life after Weeks. If he goes well, then Weeks will be riding the pine behind Kennedy and Slipper for the remainder of the season.

Bad move by Weks, but good on Byrnes and Kingi.
 

Ruggo

Mark Ella (57)
In regards to Bynes deffection.

Can I throw this out there. Where is big Hugh M, are the Reds clearing the way for a return. The timing in relation to making himself available for world cup selection fits.

Is this just a pipe dream from a loyal Reds supporter?
 

Lindommer

Simon Poidevin (60)
Staff member
Ruggo said:
Where is big Hugh M, are the Reds clearing the way for a return. The timing in relation to making himself available for world cup selection fits.

Signed for Japanese rugbyclubsan for three years. Wishful thinking, R.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top