First time poster, but was at the GPS vs Brothers game and thought I would try quench the thirst of those interested. I wasn't watching for 'review' purposes so I guess it will be more of a general commentary.
As the scoreline suggests, it was a very tight, defensive game. A quality game none the less, with all those watching in my group commenting on it being one of the best club games they have watched for a while. My overall impression was that Brothers seemed to be the better team on the park, but just couldn't seem to capitalise on their dominance of possession and territory. However, GPS scrambled and defended their line very well, aided by some questionable decision making by Brothers as the pressure to score obviously mounted later in the game. The GPS back line looked very small and on first impression I thought they would be under gunned, but when they had some opportunities with some space and ball they looked sharp. I think unfortunately they were not afforded many opportunities with Brothers doing a good job of slowing down the breakdowns, it really was noticeable at times how many players GPS had to commit to secure their own ball.
Some standout players for me: Brothers tight head i think it was, he was everywhere, a real handful and stood out in a scrambling try saving effort deep into the second half; Brothers No. 8 looked damaging as a ball runner, probably not used enough? GPS 7 was outstanding defensively, effective tackles all day and especially deep into the second half; GPS 6 and 8 also damaging in defence, and I think it was the 8 that was also handy ball in hand.
Kuridrani looked to get involved and they tended to use him as a link in some sweeping moves, not sure if that is his go, certainly wasn't up to it in that game.
Really struggled with the ref's interpretations. Breakdown was a mess with so many obvious (both ways) deliberate hands in the ruck, not supporting body weight, and general lying around in the way. Two yellow cards, GPS prop for a tipping tackle I guess, not sure if he went for the tip or slightly late or combo of both, I thought it was a great tackle, not late, lifted yes but not into a dangerous spot and landed on the flat of his back? Brothers player yellow carded for taking out the legs of a GPS player in the air taking a midfield bomb, probably justified.
