• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

QLD GPS Rugby 2018

Garry Owens

Alan Cameron (40)
Ok the jig is up ........admittedly , it was a sly price - designed to give some value to a faithful few ( and astute ) true believers
 

The Nomad

Bob Davidson (42)
Think this year level at BBC were first anointed future First XV premiers back when they were towelling every other team up by plenty as U13s by the "faithful few" in 2014. Nice early call, very astute.....
 

Garry Owens

Alan Cameron (40)
^Well the excitement was palpable at that time given that BBC hadn't even won a chook raffle up until that point. Expectations have since been tempered

Afterall .......a couple of others Schools and their supporters swig the Kool Aid so much better
 

Keeper

Bob McCowan (2)
I wouldn't be breaking out the champers down on Miskin just yet. 2014 is a long time ago and BBC still haven't won the DIV 1 Lotto prize and 2018 will be another div 3 or 4 result!!

Backs are strong - with 10 and the back 3 the stand outs. Forwards are small from front row to back row, they will struggle in the set piece and at the breakdown and importantly there is no depth in any position (backs or forwards).

NC and TSS win comps with the majority of 17 turning 18 yo's (or turned 18) and a lot of size and depth. BBC has a lot of 15/16/17 yo's with no size and no depth.

I wish them well but 2018 will not be their year.
 

The Nomad

Bob Davidson (42)
I wouldn't be breaking out the champers down on Miskin just yet. 2014 is a long time ago and BBC still haven't won the DIV 1 Lotto prize and 2018 will be another div 3 or 4 result!!

Backs are strong - with 10 and the back 3 the stand outs. Forwards are small from front row to back row, they will struggle in the set piece and at the breakdown and importantly there is no depth in any position (backs or forwards).

NC and TSS win comps with the majority of 17 turning 18 yo's (or turned 18) and a lot of size and depth. BBC has a lot of 15/16/17 yo's with no size and no depth.

I wish them well but 2018 will not be their year.
Definitely correct in the mostly 18 year olds comment , think TSS had 9 of their First XV 18 ,or soon to turn 18 , last year.

Next year will be the first of the Prep intake to hit year 12. This basically means approximately half of the senior year of all schools will be turning 18. You would expect First XV squads from next year on to be predominantly 18 year olds across all schools , rather than just TSS and NC. Guess we will see if that causes a power shift in GPS First XV rugby ... but then of course there is still the coaching , depth , culture etc .....


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Oracle83

Bill McLean (32)
I wouldn't be breaking out the champers down on Miskin just yet. 2014 is a long time ago and BBC still haven't won the DIV 1 Lotto prize and 2018 will be another div 3 or 4 result!!

Backs are strong - with 10 and the back 3 the stand outs. Forwards are small from front row to back row, they will struggle in the set piece and at the breakdown and importantly there is no depth in any position (backs or forwards).

NC and TSS win comps with the majority of 17 turning 18 yo's (or turned 18) and a lot of size and depth. BBC has a lot of 15/16/17 yo's with no size and no depth.

I wish them well but 2018 will not be their year.

I wish them well too but as U16 last year BBC could not field below 16B who won 2games and 16A finish’s equal 3rd, hardly a platform for a successful 1st XV. Their U15 year group from last year were strong, interesting to see if they stopped growing which is what happens when you recruit in Y8 not Y11 line TSS.
 

TheKing

Colin Windon (37)
So let's see if we can piece together this BBC team with a few names.

1. Sebastian Martin
2. Isaac Talbot
3. Oscar Ruru
4. Tavita Roma
5. Jack Gallagher
6.
7. Connor Hayes
8. Jack Kelly
9. Will Deck
10. Carter Gordon
11. Shayden Stevens
12. Tetuai 'Waiwai' Raoren
13. Jack Howarth
14. Matt Stirling
15. Jack Bowyer-Bowen (younger brother of Josh, which should make him a nephew of Matty Bowen)

How did I do?
 

Black & White

Vay Wilson (31)
Definitely correct in the mostly 18 year olds comment , think TSS had 9 of their First XV 18 ,or soon to turn 18 , last year.

Next year will be the first of the Prep intake to hit year 12. This basically means approximately half of the senior year of all schools will be turning 18. You would expect First XV squads from next year on to be predominantly 18 year olds across all schools , rather than just TSS and NC. Guess we will see if that causes a power shift in GPS First XV rugby . but then of course there is still the coaching , depth , culture etc ...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Hello Nomad, does mean the inclusion of 18 year olds, now extends throughout entire year groups in the GPS and TAS system. Because if does, Queensland School Boy Rugby, moves closer in depth to NSW Schools. I noticed most schools rarely go beyond a 6XVth, even powerhouses such as Nudge are small in numbers within open division in comparison to NSW Schools.Who might produce teams between 12 (Joeys) and 8. Only Newington in NSW GPS has 6 in the Open Division.

If so I look forward to the expansion of Queensland Schools Rugby within each school, as numbers could double. Such an increase depth, will add a new dimension to your competitions.
 

BASSO

Bob McCowan (2)
I wish them well too but as U16 last year BBC could not field below 16B who won 2games and 16A finish’s equal 3rd, hardly a platform for a successful 1st XV. Their U15 year group from last year were strong, interesting to see if they stopped growing which is what happens when you recruit in Y8 not Y11 line TSS.

As I have said in a previous comment, BBC teams are predominatnly picked around parental involvement and emails, which again will happen this year, so they will have a good team but not the best team they could field.
 

The Nomad

Bob Davidson (42)
Hi Black &White, do you know if the NSW GPS comp runs an U16s as we do in the QLD GPS comp? The more traditional rugby schools up here will often have 5/6th division in Opens plus U16s down to the Es.
Obviously would make a difference if you grouped all of 16s and opens (17s/18s) into one .

And to answer your question , yes , from next year there will be a lot more 18 year olds in year 12 across all competitions in QLD. Would be great to think that this will increase our numbers playing rugby in final year of school , but you never know.
 

Jets

Paul McLean (56)
Staff member
So let's see if we can piece together this BBC team with a few names.

1. Sebastian Martin
2. Isaac Talbot
3. Oscar Ruru
4. Tavita Roma
5. Jack Gallagher
6.
7. Connor Hayes
8. Jack Kelly
9. Will Deck
10. Carter Gordon
11. Shayden Stevens
12. Tetuai 'Waiwai' Raoren
13. Jack Howarth
14. Matt Stirling
15. Jack Bowyer-Bowen (younger brother of Josh, which should make him a nephew of Matty Bowen)

How did I do?

I'd add Jake Tierney (2) and George Gibson (6). Both standouts at Qld U15 State Champs and in the Junior Gold Cup.
 

Vintage Red

Herbert Moran (7)
Hi Black &White, do you know if the NSW GPS comp runs an U16s as we do in the QLD GPS comp? The more traditional rugby schools up here will often have 5/6th division in Opens plus U16s down to the Es.
Obviously would make a difference if you grouped all of 16s and opens (17s/18s) into one .

And to answer your question , yes , from next year there will be a lot more 18 year olds in year 12 across all competitions in QLD. Would be great to think that this will increase our numbers playing rugby in final year of school , but you never know.


Yes - the AAGPS in NSW has U13-16s, and then Opens (traditionally Yr.11 & 12 students).
 

Black & White

Vay Wilson (31)
Hi Black &White, do you know if the NSW GPS comp runs an U16s as we do in the QLD GPS comp? The more traditional rugby schools up here will often have 5/6th division in Opens plus U16s down to the Es.
Obviously would make a difference if you grouped all of 16s and opens (17s/18s) into one .

And to answer your question , yes , from next year there will be a lot more 18 year olds in year 12 across all competitions in QLD. Would be great to think that this will increase our numbers playing rugby in final year of school , but you never know.
Thanks Nomad, I hope its the beginning of a new era in Queensland Schools Rugby. Yes, it might start slowly but here in NSW, many boys return to Rugby in their final year at school. In some cases, whole teams are composed of 18 year olds in Year 12 with some lower teams having something of a cult statues, amongst their peers.

I would expect based on observations that the boarding Schools will benefit more than the day schools. And Schools such as Nudgee are likely to display their enhanced depth early on. Equally, Toowoomba Grammar with a strong boarding population, could also emerge at least in terms of depth, as new force in GPS Rugby. With potentially two or three Rugby teams added to your open divisions per school, I see the Queenslands GPS with its 9 schools and the 8 of TAS surpassing NSW as the player base for Australian Rugby. In NSW we have 6 Top level rugby playing schools and 6 in the CAS. The ISA also have 6 schools. But in many cases some ISA and CAS schools would struggle beat a 3rd XV from Joeys.

I look forward to reading about this and it could change the face of Queensland Schoolboy Rugby, if not Australian Schoolboy Rugby.
 

Torpedo Punt

Herbert Moran (7)
Thanks Nomad, I hope its the beginning of a new era in Queensland Schools Rugby. Yes, it might start slowly but here in NSW, many boys return to Rugby in their final year at school. In some cases, whole teams are composed of 18 year olds in Year 12 with some lower teams having something of a cult statues, amongst their peers.

I would expect based on observations that the boarding Schools will benefit more than the day schools. And Schools such as Nudgee are likely to display their enhanced depth early on. Equally, Toowoomba Grammar with a strong boarding population, could also emerge at least in terms of depth, as new force in GPS Rugby. With potentially two or three Rugby teams added to your open divisions per school, I see the Queenslands GPS with its 9 schools and the 8 of TAS surpassing NSW as the player base for Australian Rugby. In NSW we have 6 Top level rugby playing schools and 6 in the CAS. The ISA also have 6 schools. But in many cases some ISA and CAS schools would struggle beat a 3rd XV from Joeys.

I look forward to reading about this and it could change the face of Queensland Schoolboy Rugby, if not Australian Schoolboy Rugby.


Yes B and W from 2018 Qld will be 18 ...at least by June 30.
Are you a former Qlder? Been away a while....20 years ago the better TAS schools split away to form AIC and TAS are now all co Ed and rugby not a big deal...no scholarships allowed at AIC and raided by GPS but interestingly ...even though soccer is played in the same term as rugby...numbers have held ok....ASH and SLC played last week and had opens down to 5ths and had at least 4 teams in each year...ASh and SLC fielded 7 year 7 teams.....GPS have no soccer at the sameness time so disappointed that some of the years are not fielding many teams.....someone told me Ippy Grammar had only 1 open team is that true?
We in the land of AIC worry that little Jonny gets turned off rugby knowing that he might nearly get to the top of the mountain and find you know who atanding at the top in his 1xv jersey...another thread I know but this is relevant.....will next years comp in all competitions be a bit b low standard because of the half year intake currently in year 11 ??
 

The Nomad

Bob Davidson (42)
Yes B and W from 2018 Qld will be 18 .at least by June 30.
Are you a former Qlder? Been away a while..20 years ago the better TAS schools split away to form AIC and TAS are now all co Ed and rugby not a big deal.no scholarships allowed at AIC and raided by GPS but interestingly .even though soccer is played in the same term as rugby.numbers have held ok..ASH and SLC played last week and had opens down to 5ths and had at least 4 teams in each year.ASh and SLC fielded 7 year 7 teams...GPS have no soccer at the sameness time so disappointed that some of the years are not fielding many teams...someone told me Ippy Grammar had only 1 open team is that true?
We in the land of AIC worry that little Jonny gets turned off rugby knowing that he might nearly get to the top of the mountain and find you know who atanding at the top in his 1xv jersey.another thread I know but this is relevant...will next years comp in all competitions be a bit b low standard because of the half year intake currently in year 11 ??
You would think the majority of next year’s players would be in year 11 this year?

Kids born in the first half of 2001 are in year 12 this year with very few born 2000. Next year will have a mixture of ‘01 and ‘02 born , that means half of the year group will turn 18 . Guess that makes this year the “below standard “ one ?

What are your thoughts on the AIC comp so far this year ? Are they below standard?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

The Nomad

Bob Davidson (42)
You will also find in the land of GPS that an U16 comp is still running , when you add the number of open teams ( often down to 5ths/6ths depending what school ) and the number of U16 teams you will end up with a number greater than five ....


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Black & White

Vay Wilson (31)
Yes B and W from 2018 Qld will be 18 .at least by June 30.
Are you a former Qlder? Been away a while..20 years ago the better TAS schools split away to form AIC and TAS are now all co Ed and rugby not a big deal.no scholarships allowed at AIC and raided by GPS but interestingly .even though soccer is played in the same term as rugby.numbers have held ok..ASH and SLC played last week and had opens down to 5ths and had at least 4 teams in each year.ASh and SLC fielded 7 year 7 teams...GPS have no soccer at the sameness time so disappointed that some of the years are not fielding many teams...someone told me Ippy Grammar had only 1 open team is that true?
We in the land of AIC worry that little Jonny gets turned off rugby knowing that he might nearly get to the top of the mountain and find you know who atanding at the top in his 1xv jersey.another thread I know but this is relevant...will next years comp in all competitions be a bit b low standard because of the half year intake currently in year 11 ??


No, a NSW person although I have Holidayed on the Gold Coast and Noosa Heads.and great holidays they were. I believe the enhanced depth your GPS and AIC competitions are likely to experience, has the potential to change your respective competitions.

Joseph Stalin once said why his more numerous but less professional Soviet Army defeated the highly professional German Army that success was due to the circumstances that "Quantity has its own Quality. The same applies in club and school Rugby depth.

Thus large schools whose Rugby programs can generate large numbers of rugby teams in the open division will be at a distinct advantage. Quite simply 1st and 2nd XV coaches will have more players to choose from in selecting their teams. Particularly, in the forwards where an extra year in the open division, will promote expertise born out of experience.Equally, boys will grow and their improved techniques from added strength will be demonstrated, more so in their second year in the open division.

It is not usual for a boy in a Sydney GPS or CAS school to play in a lower grade such as the 4ths,5ths or 6th XVs only to be propelled into the higher grades such as 1sts,2nds and 3rds the next year. Even 7th, 8th,9th and 10 XVs have had players emerge into the higher grades. So I believe QLD Schoolboy Rugby could be in for something of upheaval, if Schools start experiencing an increase with two or more teams added to their open division.

So, Queensland Schoolboy Rugby supporters, I believe you are about to experience some exciting times ahead. With more teams to watch and teams build around greater depth leading to higher quality teams.
 

fairplay

Johnnie Wallace (23)
No, a NSW person although I have Holidayed on the Gold Coast and Noosa Heads.and great holidays they were. I believe the enhanced depth your GPS and AIC competitions are likely to experience, has the potential to change your respective competitions.



Joseph Stalin once said why his more numerous but less professional Soviet Army defeated the highly professional German Army that success was due to the circumstances that "Quantity has its own Quality. The same applies in club and school Rugby depth.



Thus large schools whose Rugby programs can generate large numbers of rugby teams in the open division will be at a distinct advantage. Quite simply 1st and 2nd XV coaches will have more players to choose from in selecting their teams. Particularly, in the forwards where an extra year in the open division, will promote expertise born out of experience.Equally, boys will grow and their improved techniques from added strength will be demonstrated, more so in their second year in the open division.



It is not usual for a boy in a Sydney GPS or CAS school to play in a lower grade such as the 4ths,5ths or 6th XVs only to be propelled into the higher grades such as 1sts,2nds and 3rds the next year. Even 7th, 8th,9th and 10 XVs have had players emerge into the higher grades. So I believe QLD Schoolboy Rugby could be in for something of upheaval, if Schools start experiencing an increase with two or more teams added to their open division.



So, Queensland Schoolboy Rugby supporters, I believe you are about to experience some exciting times ahead. With more teams to watch and teams build around greater depth leading to higher quality teams.



Hopefully it doesn't become anything like the confusing mess that is the NSW Schoolboys comp.
 
Top