NSW AAGPS 2025 (banter and commentary)

[Professor62]

How many GPS captains have been put into this Aus 20s team?

From what i know;
Finn Baxter (E)
Will Guilfoyle (S)
Toby Brial (S)
Liam Grover (R)
Hwi Sharples (J)

Are there any more? seems to be lots of leaders filling the side.

 

[The 6 Seat]

How many GPS captains have been put into this Aus 20s team?

From what i know;
Finn Baxter (E)
Will Guilfoyle (S)
Toby Brial (S)
Liam Grover (R)
Hwi Sharples (J)

Are there any more? seems to be lots of leaders filling the side.

Lipina Ata (N)
Mangelsdorf & Doyle (c) (J)
Fowler (J)

 

[Footy head]

How many GPS captains have been put into this Aus 20s team?

From what i know;
Finn Baxter (E)
Will Guilfoyle (S)
Toby Brial (S)
Liam Grover (R)
Hwi Sharples (J)

Are there any more? seems to be lots of leaders filling the side.

Luca Clev (N) was in until he got injured in the Rugby Championship

 

[fortheloveofthegame]

His impressive confidence and magic in rucks is needed though, he was easily the best 7 and perhaps forward in the GPS last season.

I would almost say his small size benefits the way he plays, with his style proving very valuable to teams he has played for. His size hasn't stopped him playing well before, hence why I don't think he should (and hopefully won't) be shunned from team positions due to his size.

school boy footy, Shute Shield footy are not test match footy. A 7 must be a lineout option and the reality is that physics takes over at the gain line eventually.

 

[The Ghost of Raelene]

That's not true.

You have four legitimate options before you get to potentially throwing a 7 up in the lineout. If you can't get it done with them you have bigger problems. How many takes did McReight, Tizzano, Gamble and Reimer take this year in Super Rugby? Australia have never used our 7 as an extra 6. We use them for a skill specific set in the pack.

He is on the smaller side but at his age he's fine. Every chance he ends up high 90s low 100s in weight which is fine if he maintains speed in the middle. Hooper, McReight, Tizzano all 101kg. Even Van de Flier is only 103kg

 

[Ballscollector]

He is on the smaller side but at his age he's fine. Every chance he ends up high 90s low 100s in weight which is fine if he maintains speed in the middle. Hooper, McReight, Tizzano all 101kg. Even Van de Flier is only 103kg

How tall was Hooper actually? I know he is listed at 5'11ish but that has to be wrong, I wonder if MLM can get close to him, but does anyone have an accurate guess to Hooper's height?

 

[twister29]

school boy footy, Shute Shield footy are not test match footy. A 7 must be a lineout option and the reality is that physics takes over at the gain line eventually.

Say this to Michael Hooper and he may beg to differ...

 

[The Ghost of Raelene]

How tall was Hooper actually? I know he is listed at 5'11ish but that has to be wrong, I wonder if MLM can get close to him, but does anyone have an accurate guess to Hooper's height?

5'11 if he has the 18mm studs screwed in.

 

[RuckReaper78]

Michael Lippman's only 6.1ft
Joeys 1st / 100 games for Bath and a caps for England.

 

[keenas]

around the 55 minute game time mark

This was full on intentional something needs to be done about it !

 

[Professor62]

Marshall Le Matire certainly should be making these Aus 20 rep teams after his recent form in shute shield. He is starting in first grade and dominating! Already winning 2+ man of the match performances, he is on a tear at the moment. I believe he might take the same route as Jorgo, skip the Aus 20s and go straight to the Tahs and beyond. I reckon he will be able to debut next season, interested to hear others thoughts. Cheers Professor

 

[TonyTackle01]

Marshall has been unstoppable for norths this year, 100% got a bright future ahead of him.

 

[fortheloveofthegame]

That's not true.

You have four legitimate options before you get to potentially throwing a 7 up in the lineout. If you can't get it done with them you have bigger problems. How many takes did McReight, Tizzano, Gamble and Reimer take this year in Super Rugby? Australia have never used our 7 as an extra 6. We use them for a skill specific set in the pack.

He is on the smaller side but at his age he's fine. Every chance he ends up high 90s low 100s in weight which is fine if he maintains speed in the middle. Hooper, McReight, Tizzano all 101kg. Even Van de Flier is only 103kg

Marshall Le Matire certainly should be making these Aus 20 rep teams after his recent form in shute shield. He is starting in first grade and dominating! Already winning 2+ man of the match performances, he is on a tear at the moment. I believe he might take the same route as Jorgo, skip the Aus 20s and go straight to the Tahs and beyond. I reckon he will be able to debut next season, interested to hear others

Michael Lippman's only 6.1ft
Joeys 1st / 100 games for Bath and a caps for England.

Marshall is a lot shorter than Hooper and Lipman for that matter. If he hits 100kg he’ll loose a tonne of pace which is an important attribute of his. no denying he is a great competitor, i reckon he could continue and be a good 7 at Shute Shield but he could be a genuine world class 9.

 

[fortheloveofthegame]

Marshall Le Matire certainly should be making these Aus 20 rep teams after his recent form in shute shield. He is starting in first grade and dominating! Already winning 2+ man of the match performances, he is on a tear at the moment. I believe he might take the same route as Jorgo, skip the Aus 20s and go straight to the Tahs and beyond. I reckon he will be able to debut next season, interested to hear others thoughts. Cheers Professor

Jorgo skipped 20’s by going straight to Super footy, he didn’t sit out 20’s via the vagaries of selection politics.

 

[Backintheolddays]

Marshall is a lot shorter than Hooper and Lipman for that matter. If he hits 100kg he’ll loose a tonne of pace which is an important attribute of his. no denying he is a great competitor, i reckon he could continue and be a good 7 at Shute Shield but he could be a genuine world class 9.

I fear he'll end up as a 9 in the wrong code

 

[fortheloveofthegame]

I fear he'll end up as a 9 in the wrong code

agree but don’t you think that would have happened if there was an offer ?

 

[Rugbynbeers]

Marshall Le Matire certainly should be making these Aus 20 rep teams after his recent form in shute shield. He is starting in first grade and dominating! Already winning 2+ man of the match performances, he is on a tear at the moment. I believe he might take the same route as Jorgo, skip the Aus 20s and go straight to the Tahs and beyond. I reckon he will be able to debut next season, interested to hear others thoughts. Cheers Professor

have to disagree, he will definitely not be playing super rugby in the next two years.

He is unlucky to miss out but looking at the 7s above him in that 20s side they are just better.

 

[TonyTackle01]

Hearing word there’s been some huge changes made in SHORE’s 1sts team from last week. Through a combination of subpar form and injury. This could seriously be the nail in the coffin for their 2025 campaign.

 

[2013-2017]

Definitely a late shot, too late for it to be accidental in my eyes...

Let's just hold up for a sec, this is rugby, the goal is to dominate and hurt the other player, correct? This is a contact sport, correct?

He obviously didn't mean to knock him out, but an attempted big hit gone wrong when the ball-runner slips at the last second, causing the chest high tackle to turn into a head high tackle. He also passes as Heinz goes in for his tackle, and this happens, it's rugby.

Unfortunate, obviously, but if he didn't get knocked out it wouldn't even be looked at.

So let's just relax for a sec,

Can he even get suspended if he did not receive a red card?

 

[tight5]

Fon

I agree, Lemoto is the #8. Fonua and Justice can play #6 & #7

Fonua into 2nd row, Justice #6, Lemoto #8