Steve_Grey
Alfred Walker (16)
Hit the nail on the proverbial head.I’m talking French system but yes, our bigger issue is the gap between school and elite. That’s why I have an issue with the PONI nonsense. The lads get identified then don’t play, resulting in a) others not getting the chance to demonstrate how they perform against the up until now “best” U20’s players and validate their development, and b) the PONI’s not developing the toughness required that can only come through playing under pressure.
"The lads get identified then don’t play" spot on - many of them relocate to the Waratahs Daceyville gym, play a few Colts or 2nd Grade games per season to tick the boxes - they become 'blockers' for others who don't get their chance to demonstrate their ability (as you say above) - some players are late developers, some are simply ignored.
Very few checks and balances - performances aren't validated against the wider NSW Shute Shield Club U20s talent pool (as they play so few Club games) - some of the PONI in the system are not currently even the best U20s in their own Clubs, let alone NSW.