Way to early to call for a winner. The trials start this weekend for all schools and these games are usually used to test and consolidate combinations. Joeys will be looking for a solid 1st XV. Only a few years ago they tried 36 players for the team (due to injuries and knee jerk reactions) and these changes continued during the season. While many people are not a fan of "pick and stick", the benefits though do allow a team to gel and for combinations to find their feet. Only if a player in lower grades does something "consistently" amazing then bring them up. In the meantime allow players to develop. Nothing builds confidence more than certainty. If you live in fear of being dropped then your play will suffer.
BTW.....WB and B&W, what are your thoughts on the Newington "Silverback" XV. In 2021 the Newington silver back team supposedly had players good enough for the 3rd XV. How is this possible? They played a Joeys 7th's and narrowly lost in their only comp match. It was a game full of niggle and cheap shots.
Hello Joker
Regret to say, since I am somewhat touch with some aspects of Newington Rugby at present. But I do know that in 2020, most of the then 16As, were taken out of their age division and finished playing in the open division. Yet, their replacements from within that division comprising players from the previous years 15Bs and 15Cs "stepped up" when in the 16s age group. the New 16As of 2020, only lost one game and that was to Shore. I think the score was about 33-28 to Shore.
I don't know how many of those players were year 10 boys in 2020, but if we are optimistic say 7-10 boys 2nds and 3rds could at Newington could have some talent. Although both these teams were beaten by Scots, it is still early days. with the likelyhood that that both New teams are coming together. Certainly in the season, when New plays Scots, Scots in preseason tend to be more successful. Usually, with better Match fitness. So it might be some seeks before we haw these teams may fare. This was why I was enquiring about players lost. As one commentator believed New had lost about 30 players from our opens. Additionally, I believe it was WB, who said that a number of Pacific Islander Boys, have arrived at the College. Depending on Numbers and their skill levels, fitness, pace and size. They could indeed make an impact as well.
So sorry Joker, if I have not been as a precise as you like. But I do expect that these Newington Teams will take some time to come together.
Another matter, that is worth mentioning, don't expect Newington to go and beat St.Augustines this Saturday, by 82-0. Firstly, I believe the S.Augustine Boys will adapt quickly to playing, GPS standard Rugby and such a loss will serve as a benchmark, for them to lift to higher standards of Rugby.
Expect a much closer game this Saturday.
Regards B&W
.