In 2011 I wrote an evocative (shit stirring if you prefer) post about the Tahs and the years of dysfunction and the fact that no matter who coached them the results were the same with some minor changes to the mode of play. Think back and you remember Matt Williams, Ian Kennedy, Bob Dwyer, McKenzie, Hickey and Foley. The results were largely the same. The playing group contained throughout the time some of the most gifted players ever to wear the sky blue.In that article I proposed that the problem ultimately was coaching based, though it had a part to play. Basically I was saying shit rolls downhill and there was a hell of a lot of it at Tahs HQ (which everyone knew and did nothing about).
I see some massive parallels to Wallaby land from 2003 onwards. It may well have been present long before but with professionalism the impacts became more pronounced. We have had a succession of seriously poor management at ARU level. Starting with Flowers squandering a once in a generation (or even multiple generations) capital investment opportunity that could have funded the game for a very long time. No lets piss it up the wall with a pie in the sky idea that any rational assessment could have said would not work as it never involved the grass roots and they had no real investment in it. Then we have JON mark II (reign of Nero) with inflated salary and rubber stamp board. Rome burned and JON ran around being important and then as the flames licked the walls of his summer house and he couldn't tell everyone it was just a foggy day, and with the Goths and Vandals raping and pillaging our once great Legion, he raided the vault and ran for the hills.
In steps Billy P. No changes to the rubber stamp brigade and his school buddy Chairman but we expect different outcomes. WTF.
Just like the Tahs. Until we have reform at the administration level any gains made at coaching level will be short term and ephemeral IMO. As with the Tahs the great tragedy is the collateral damage along the way, in coaches, support staff and players. Notice how the managers and administrators never get any blame for the shite systems that lead to these situations.
Hopefully Chieka keeps his driver (as in golf club) close at hand, not to motivate players, but to beat administrators around the head to try and get some sense into their skulls.