The thing about Rattue is that many forget that Henry called him out when he called Wales the village idiots of world rugby. Wales were rightly pissed off about it, and Henry said it appears we have village idiots of our own, and then I think complained to the editor of the herald. Since then, Rattue has spat nothing but bile at Henry and co. In his latest column on Deans, he had a massive turn and called him out of his depth - once again, proving himself to be a turncoat.
However, in the age of news on the internets, these columnists need to be controversial in order to survive - any thoughtful, meaningful analysis just gets swept under the rug.
I'd prefer to read Walrus over Rattue anyday - you can feel his real rugby passion which is always good. I mean, he hates us (well, he tries to comes across that way although I'm not entirely convinced he believes what he writes) and LOVES a jibe at NZ - but in reality, some of his observations aren't too far of the mark. Rattue just writes crap without any passion to wind people up - quite a difference.