• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

Chiefs v Brumbies Super Rugby R4 2012

Status
Not open for further replies.

spectator

Bob Davidson (42)
Well done Brumbies! Disappointing to lose, obviously, but after having been written off by all and sundry all week, it was good to see them guttsing it out like they did. Plenty to like about this young team and Mowen does strike me as a good leader.

Agree with others who have mentioned Mogg. He looked very composed for a bloke as inexperienced as he is, and did some pretty good things. I also thought Prior went ok as well.
 

wamberal

Phil Kearns (64)
I thought the Ref did a great job in this game.


The only major blemish, although maybe my wife and I are wrong, watching at home of course, was that everybody appeared to miss a possible penalty against the Chiefs after a knock-on. on the last 15 minutes or so, I think it was Kerr-Barlow appeared to touch the ball attempting to catch a kick, it appeared to go forward, and a retreating Chiefs player picked it up.

Did anybody else see this incident in similar terms? Or are we being too harsh? A penalty just out from the Chiefs 22 would have been pretty handy at the time.
 

Slim 293

Stirling Mortlock (74)
The only major blemish, although maybe my wife and I are wrong, watching at home of course, was that everybody appeared to miss a possible penalty against the Chiefs after a knock-on. on the last 15 minutes or so, I think it was Kerr-Barlow appeared to touch the ball attempting to catch a kick, it appeared to go forward, and a retreating Chiefs player picked it up.

Did anybody else see this incident in similar terms? Or are we being too harsh? A penalty just out from the Chiefs 22 would have been pretty handy at the time.

I do know what you're referring to only because Mowen tried to point it out to the ref afterwards but I'm assuming (pub with no sound) that he ruled it as maybe not being intentional?

Anyways, my only criticism was that in the first half the Chiefs had a lot of lazy forwards loitering offside at the rucks ala the All Blacks which let them get some extra metres around the ruck... however, in the second half they seemed to curb it?

They were also hanging onto Brumby defenders around the ruck and there wasn't a scrum where Hooper wasn't being held back so he could swoop onto SBW... but thankfully McCabe had him covered...

Anyways, I don't think any of that really had any effect on the match, and the Brumbies can only blame themselves for such silly errors in that last few minutes...

There was that MASSIVE forward pass which led to that Chiefs counter attack back down the field, but the ref was in no position to rule on that... the assistant however (I've noticed that in a number of games lately that these guys tend to make many more worse decisions than the actual ref)...

But in hindsight I agree with Sully that the match was generally reffed pretty well...
 

Slim 293

Stirling Mortlock (74)
Well done Brumbies! Disappointing to lose, obviously, but after having been written off by all and sundry all week, it was good to see them guttsing it out like they did. Plenty to like about this young team and Mowen does strike me as a good leader.

Agree with others who have mentioned Mogg. He looked very composed for a bloke as inexperienced as he is, and did some pretty good things. I also thought Prior went ok as well.

This would be harsh on Prior, particularly as White didn't play so well at the end there... but...

I think I would prefer to start with White and finish the game with Prior...

White has that x factor that can allow him to do some magic, but Prior is solid and while not as flashy will be safer option in the dying stages of the match...

I was really impressed with the way that Prior was marshalling the forwards in his debut starting match... when the Brumbies put on that beatiful 34 metre rolling maul he was screaming at players and telling them where to go...
 

Slim 293

Stirling Mortlock (74)
And someone correct me if I'm wrong... but did Tomane actually contribute anything to the game?

I forgot that he was playing until he got subbed off...

Kuridrani or Crawford for the wing next week?

And what did everyone think when Murphy came on for Alexander?

It looked like the left side of the scrum stopped moving towards the earth...
 
N

Newter

Guest
And someone correct me if I'm wrong... but did Tomane actually contribute anything to the game?

I forgot that he was playing until he got subbed off...

Kuridrani or Crawford for the wing next week?

He belted Sonny Bill in at least one hit.
 
N

Newter

Guest
It was not a bad execution of a limited game plan but the limitation was itself a negative in the wash up.

Jesse Mogg has been the biggest surprise for me at the Brumbies this year and not least for his booming left foot. He has Wallaby squad written all over him. There is a bit of Dagg and Jane about him; so they have to design plays, or at least procedures, to get the ball to him. Ditto for Tomane. Can anybody work out if he is any good from that game? Why didn't they try to find out?

That game plan is pure Jake White and in truth it plays to the Brumbies strengths; but there has to be a bit of dessert to go with the meat and potatoes.

PS - A magnificent game from Leali'ifano don't you think? Worthy of the old Brumbies teams.
.

Was Lealifaano that good, Lee? I thought he struggled to manage the play when it really mattered. There were a lot of knock ons by the Brumbies in good attacking position.

If To'omua had been playing it might have served them better to attack more.
 

Slim 293

Stirling Mortlock (74)
I felt Lilo had a mixed game...

He nearly gives me a heart attack every time he kicks the ball... he's so prone to charge downs...

His handling at times wasn't up to scratch...

Hopefully he'll improve for the next game because he's such a good ball runner and he does have a great pass...

His goal kicking is a revelation though...

It's disappointing losing To'omua after the many nice touches he had against the Cheetahs... and there's so many big linebreaking runners in that backline and they were a bit under utilised last night.
 

Slim 293

Stirling Mortlock (74)
As Fardy is only EPS...

Is he allowed to remain in the team while any member of the forward pack is off injured? Or does it specifically have to be a lock/backrower?

If he continues to play like he has the past couple of weeks he has Wallaby potential...

Both him and Mogg... both coming from the EPS...
 

aussie1st

Alfred Walker (16)
Defense looked pretty good and the attack was good. You can definitely see Jake's influence on the team, now to sort out the handling.
 
P

Paradox

Guest
Bloody proud of that effort. Well done Brumbies. We really missed the kicking game of To'omua. A fit and firing Scott Fardy will make Rocky Elsom nervous. Could be that hard nosed 6 we've been lacking for a while.
 

Ruggo

Mark Ella (57)
As Fardy is only EPS...

Is he allowed to remain in the team while any member of the forward pack is off injured? Or does it specifically have to be a lock/backrower?

If he continues to play like he has the past couple of weeks he has Wallaby potential...

Both him and Mogg... both coming from the EPS...

I think the best way to deal with losing Fardy is to move Mowen to six and then Vaea to his rightful 8 position. The pack will still have the punch White is looking for and it will be well balanced.

If you can keep Fardy, he will make a great impact bench player.
 

Brumbies Guy

John Solomon (38)
As Fardy is only EPS...

Is he allowed to remain in the team while any member of the forward pack is off injured? Or does it specifically have to be a lock/backrower?

Colby is still awhile off, as is Fotu; there's still plenty of time for Fardy.
 

Brumby Jack

Steve Williams (59)
Apparently Fotu played for Easts today, which puts him ahead of Colby I think, although I haven't been over there for a week or so
 

Slim 293

Stirling Mortlock (74)
To be fair, the geographical positioning of both clubs to their respective names is slightly screwed... ;)
 

brumsfan

Sydney Middleton (9)
Not one Brumby good enough to make the smh team of the week, friday must be too long ago to remember!! They probably played the toughest opposition of all Aussie teams and were level with 90 seconds to go.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top