Both these programmes are ARU
Surely a competition that asks to increase intensity and skill isnt going to do that by excluding what some have described as the best players (from the NGS) or is there conflict within as well
engagement in this should be compulsory for the NGS participants in this age group
JGC is targeting 14 (turning 15) and 16 (turning 17) year olds. NGS doesn't target Under 15's.
Occasionally they will have the odd 15 year old but the majority of kids in NGS are 16-18 year olds.
The 17 and 18 year old NGS boys would obviously be too old for JGC U17's.
In the olden days (ie last year) when there was NGS and JGS, NGS was 3 days a week commitment and JGS was one day a week commitment over spring/summer. NGS continued all year long, reverting to one day per week during rugby season, whereas JGS stopped in Autumn.
The drills and routines practiced are essentially identical, as is the knowledge and game tactics passed on. The NGS boys just do more of it, more often, so execution and improvements can be better monitored.
There is probably no reason why the one of the three weekly training days that the 10-20 U17 NGS boys do can not be done in conjunction with a U17 JGC training day, and therefore those U17 NGS boys could play in the National JGC games.
I was under the impression that the JGC was to encourage more kids into the Village Clubs at Under 17 and Under 15 level. It appears that this will not achieve that objective, because most of the (Sydney and Brissie) kids in the programme will be locked up in the Schools system over the Winter. Some Schools are reasonably ambivalent about their 15A's playing Village Club footy on Sundays, but it is a different story at Open age (Under 17's).
The vast majority of the 120 "best" Under 17 year olds in Sydney will be playing 1st XV rugby for their school, or will already be playing Colts (Non-Rugby Schools) on Saturday, and will not be able to physically back up and play Junior Village Club footy on Sunday.
Under 17 Junior Village Club footy in Sydney looks to be going down the gurgler, rather than being strengthened by this initiative. I hope I am proved wrong.
Conversely this will probably be a good shot in the arm for Country Under 17 footy.