Search results

Disagree. One good game against Uni does not make them the best prop combo in the comp. They are the third, even fourth best propping combination at best. Paraka and Sanday from Easts are the best prop combination in the comp, then Smith and Kite from Jeeps, and its a photo finish between...

Before suffering from his compound fracture I would have said Kuridrani was a shoe in to replace one of the places left by Ioane, Morahan or Lance's departures. I'd say from what I have seen from Chris this year he is still very much trying to find his rhythm again. He has'nt set the world on...

I would've given the Musashi award to someone from Wests first and foremost and then Tabu or Ma'afu who worked himself to a standstill up front in defence. A Jeeps player should not have rated a mention. Would be interesting if they actually watch all the games to pick the most deserving or if...

The game against Norths shows just how important guys like Jono Ellis, JP Smith and P Kite are up front as well as Kerevi, Frisby, and Malolua out back to the GPS squad. GPS had a number of opportunities in the Norths red zone, where repeated attempts in close were constantly repelled by a brave...

Jets, thats not what Im arguing at all. What I'm arguing is that if you have not earnt the right to do something (like play in a semi final or a grand final) then you should not be allowed to take part and enjoy the privilege of taking part in one. The basic premise of my argument is a "Fair...

The benefits for whom exactly? So you have no problem with guys who have also put in the hard yards since November during pre season while also holding down full time jobs and in most cases supporting families sacrificing their spots in a semi or grand final that they have contributed to...

Australia can cherry pick from Tasmania because it is part of Australia Rassie :-)

Still not a big fan of Reds (or any Super Rugby players for that matter) coming back to club rugby just to play in finals. Its not really fair on the blokes who actually got the team to the finals in the first place and then be moved down a grade when the club's Reds come back. Yes, it probably...

B.Tuqiri is usually first option but he is injured at the moment. I think Tuqiri and McWhirter are solid contributors and wont let anyone down when asked to do the job, I just think in terms of a pure number 10 skill set, Jake Milne is the best option Jeeps have. The difficulty is, with Milne so...

Just saw the game from the weekend between and Wests and Jeeps and although it is hard to admit, I thought Jeeps were pretty shocking in terms of cohesion and especially accuracy around the park. Too many pushed passes, inaccurate at the breakdown, and guilty of trying to do far too much with...

Premier players should get videos of their games or links to their games recorded by the QRU. The footage is password protected, but I have a few mates from each club who kindly send me the links, so I can enjoy the games at home.

I'm looking forward to watching the video of the game, wasn't able to get down to Yoku today. Can't say I was expecting any other result though, just too much firepower for GPS all over the park. Good to see Waita continues with his good form for the Bulldogs. Looking forward to seeing how young...

FilthRugby, I think we're definitely top 4 material this year, whether we're legitimately ready to contend for the title I'm not sure. I will reserve my judgement until we've played Brothers and Sunnybank who we've traditionally struggled with. What I do know is that this year's squad is...

Just quietly FilthRugby, how good of a pick up was Michael Bond for you guys? I'd say Norths would be fairly dirty he returned to play at Crosby instead of Shaw Sports...quality player, with Murphy inside going great guns and Gendle still a force, Brothers arguably have one of the better if not...

He had a shocker, just way too nitpicky when it comes to scrum time for me. Imagine having a player red carded for something he didn't do in the first place and wasn't illegal play. I would probably say he was a contributing factor to Wests not being able to take advantage of the extra...

Lets hope your right about which Wests outfit rocks up this weekend, I always prefer a hard fought game anyway. Also, not having as many minutes on the park is actually another reason Wests in my opinion will probably struggle on the weekend on top of the ones I mentioned previously, because...

Coady is a good player, no doubt and probably deserved an opportunity during the stretch when the Filth were at the top of the food chain but I think his best days are behind him. Best hooker in premier rugby is Maile Ngauamo, then Mitch Wade, then followed by Andrew Ready.

In all honesty, I think if everything goes to script Wests could be in for a really long day at the office this Saturday. Saw the game against Souths from last week, and from that performance I just don't think Wests have the personnel to go with GPS this week. Have heard a few whispers that...

I think you hit it on the head, a Butler-less squad robs Easts of one its most potent ball running options in the forwards. Paraka and Sanday seem to be set piece specialists while young Ready and Lafaitele are probably a year or 2 off realising their real ball running potential to earn hard...

Lol, sorry mate.... In my defence I was posting it on the sly on the old iPhone while my wife was trying to make me watch Packed to the Rafters re-runs. The English isn't too good while trying to look interested in my wife's certain obsession with this damn show.