Search results

Yeah thanks Reasoning have a look. The ref was very definite in his signalling. Just something I haven’t seen before. Could be a new addition to the rugby rule book. Like we need more rules in our game.

Question? Griffith v Albury game. Right near the end of the game Albury knock on, near the sideline. Griffith player lightly punts ball over sideline. Ball travels a couple of metres. Instead of scrum Griffith decision is Albury penalty. Is that the correct decision? From ensuing play Albury...

The point is Athol, Mauler & Nick know a lot more about players across Siru than I do. Hence my position on the tipping comp. % wise the Rep side is comprised of City 36%, Tahs 24%, Aggies 16%, Steamers 8%, Bulls 8%, Blacks 4%, Phantoms 4%. I’ll leave it at that. I’m not going to post about this...

Really Bubba. 15/25 from 2 clubs. 4 from another club that has only been able to beat the hapless Reddies this year. You blokes are cracking jokes aren’t you. It shouldn’t be the SIRU Rep side because the SIRU Rep side would be representative of SIRU wouldn’t it.

This is not a SIRU rep squad. This side that has been selected should be renamed the Wagga Invitational. 19 out of the 25 available places have gone to Wagga based clubs. Albury & Tumut only have 2. Siru hates criticism. Why do this?

Griffith decent side, high standard game, genuine contender. Rep Squad. Wagga City 9. Griffith 1.

Of course people are going to continue to talk about the draw Mauler. It’s a difficult situation. My opinion is that I don’t believe Leeton should be in 3rds. Also don’t think we should be having all these byes in 1st grade so we can include Hay & Deni in 2nds. Will miss Whistle’s posts in 2021.

Griffith looked pretty average on livestream yesterday. Looks like Bulls, Blacks & Waratahs about equal at this stage. Maybe Steamers will be capable of challenging City.

Blacks have big no.s training & involved in the club. They will have 4 solid teams throughout the year. I’m not sure Griffith has a lot of exciting players. But those clubs like Griffith that have a solid base generally perform consistently over the season. I think the Blacks will finish in the...

I’d be interested in the tipping comp Mauler. With the 3rds situation I reckon they should have a seperate draw. Maybe like the pub comps they have in League where games are held fortnightly and all games are held at a common venue. At least that way the teams would have consistent footy. As far...

That might be the case Whistle but I just had a look at the 3rd grade draw. In the 1st 4 weeks Griffith has 3 byes. The whole draw process has been based on being inclusive of Hay & Deni in Siru. Unfortunately this inclusion of Hay & Deni is fine for 2nd & womens grade where these clubs have...

I don’t know what to think of the draw, Reasoning. What do you say. It’s what you get when you work from the bottom up instead of the top down. Here at Griffith in the 1st round we have the Sports Club ground booked & 2 out of our 4 teams (who have been training for quite a while now) will be...

The draw we have is questionable in the present circumstances. If Phantoms can’t field 1sts almost half of the teams in the 1st grade draw won’t be actually playing on any given weekend.

Blacks club in a good place Sam. I haven’t heard of any new star players or anything like that but very good no.s at training. Can’t see any issues with having 4 strong grades this year. Well run club with a good ground to play on.

I can’t see we’ve resolved anything with the draw that has been decided on this year. Hay & Deni are never going to have a 1st grade. I can understand everyone’s point of view that it’s been agreed on & accepted. Fine, let’s get on with it, but are we going to have 4 byes in 1st grade next year...

Given the draw scenarios posted by Reasoning we probably need to do another draw. Is this situation going to be different in the future? Leeton have been struggling for 2nds for a while now, Hay and Deni are never going to have 1sts.

It’s great to have footy back. Re the draw - it looks like a case of the tail wagging the dog. Shouldn’t we be setting the 1st grade draw & the 2nds & women’s draw fitting in with that 1st grade draw. If the clubs don’t want split travel shouldn’t the byes be appearing in the 2nd grade & womens...

It’s probably obvious to everyone else but am I reading the draw wrong. Is there a 2 team bye?

Lurker - someone who reads but doesn’t contribute to a forum. Arrogant - someone who has an exaggerated sense of their own importance or abilities. Can’t believe how clever you 2 guys are. BTW are you 2 insinuating that the team in blue ( you know the one that plays in the vastly inferior...

Don’t get it. The guy recently played for Leeton & City. Wearing blue next season on a SIRU forum? Why would anyone click to Royals? Doesn’t make sense.