Search results

Wrong

Just to be absolutely clear - I did not bring this 22 call into the discussion and it was not something I am using as a reference to my original point. I am responding to it, but it's separate to my original post.

No - his legs are over the line (and touching the ground) the whole time. Your own words earlier: His feet were over the line at all times throughout the tackle process. Just so I am very clear on the definition I am using for "throughout": that means - When he lands after the jump and...

He was tackled outside the 22. His feet were outside the 22 when he collapsed onto the ground (I.e tackled). He was outside the 22, It was carried back.

But it was extremely nice of Jaco to start coaching the French from that point onwards to ensure that they didn't repeat the error.

I'd end up hating myself.

Carried back

It was carried back

Removing any in game TMO process completely depowers the host broadcaster. On field, game time decision sticks and the host broadcaster can replay it however many times they want and it won't matter. Referees have a tough job because they have to make the decision real time, and people...

Incoming: 1. A post by @Braveheart81 critiquing Campbell's one misstep as if it encompasses his whole match. Then suggesting we need to work in more experience in the fullback position ("oh, I dunno........... Maybe Kurtley Beale, with Marky Mark (Nawaqanitawase) on the wing and Campbell to suck some eggs in...

TMOs need to be completely removed. They add nothing other than frustration.

I'm not.

The real issue is that these wallabies cannot and refuse to learn lessons. The same fallibilities that are so absolutely correctable just continue to manifest in every fucking game win or lose !

on the plus side - one of the better coast to coast tries i've seen in a long while.

What an absolute crock. We were 5 mins away from one of our best wins for decade. Terrible fandom from you.

He normally gets that kind of shit right tho

So many opportunities to win. At the death, Australians could so easily advanced down field with an off side penalty by passing the ball straifhtht into the french loiterer... But no, better to hold the ball run backwards, pass around the back of the offside player and lose 10m. A magnificent...

It was almost as if he had to take a bit longer to read the game than other players (who have been constantly actively playing matches) for some unknown reason. I have never seen his delivery slower than what it was in that match.

For the good of his career, I really hope McDermott gets a gig overseas. The 2023 contract end is probably Ill timed as so many other test and world cup players will be off contract. Like Liam Gill, recognise where the wallabies actually see you, and that you'll make waaaaay more money touring...

France 18 Wallabies 25