• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

First Nations & Pasifika XV vs the Lions - Tue, Jul 22 @ 8:00 PM, Melbourne

molman

John Thornett (49)
Thomas was extremely disappointing. Some poor decisions and his wind up to pass right to left allows the defence and extra metre or more to advance at our ball receiver. Jack Deb went ok, not great, for the third best No 10 at the Brumbies.

The real star for the FNP side was Charlie Gamble. Won't get him into the Wallabies over McReight and Tizzano, but he can be very satisfied with his performance tonight. WTF is going on with LSL (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto) (Lukhan Salakaia-Loto)? He should be atg least on the bench for the tests, but doesn't even make the squad. Joe has a bit to answer for there.
It was Thomas' option taking with a quick tap that setup one of the tries and I actually throught Goddard looked a step down with some of his passing. There were a number of passes hitting either high or low at times. Thomas hasn't impressed me much in the past, but I thought he showed a lot of willing tonight.

I also thought in the context of a thrown together team Debreczeni played his role reasonably well. There was a lot of play off 9, and you could see he didn't have connections with some of the other players, but his clearances really took some of the pressure off the team and he had some moments where he was able to insert himself.
 
Last edited:

molman

John Thornett (49)
Getting an invitational side up to play the Lions is very different to managing a Super side week to week, but Kefu has done plenty to advance his case for the Reds job.
Stood in stark contrast to the AUNZ game. I don't know what that says.
 

Wilson

Tim Horan (67)
Stood in stark contrast to the AUNZ game. I don't know what that says.
It says plenty about the opposition (this was much more of a scratch Lions side with a lot less prep), and definitely lends credence to the talk the Kiwi players were treating that game as a Baa Baas style week on the piss. Beyond that I'm not so sure you can draw too many direct conclusions though.
 

Brumby Runner

Jason Little (69)
I'm not disagreeing that Jarrah McLeod had a fine game, but to be calling for him to be added to the Wallabies squad, as some are doing here tonight, is premature. He hasn't even played a agme of Super Rugby yet iirc. His partner in crime from the U20s, Kadin Pritchard, on the other hand played against Fiji and appears to be ahead in the Brumbies pecking order.
 

Major Tom

Nev Cottrell (35)
I'm not disagreeing that Jarrah McLeod had a fine game, but to be calling for him to be added to the Wallabies squad, as some are doing here tonight, is premature. He hasn't even played a agme of Super Rugby yet iirc. His partner in crime from the U20s, Kadin Pritchard, on the other hand played against Fiji and appears to be ahead in the Brumbies pecking order.
He’s not joining any wallabies squad yet. He’ll be fun to watch in super rugby au though. Leli might be close to going on the end of year tour. He’s looked comfortable in every scrum he’s been in this year.
 

Rebel man

John Thornett (49)
I'm not disagreeing that Jarrah McLeod had a fine game, but to be calling for him to be added to the Wallabies squad, as some are doing here tonight, is premature. He hasn't even played a agme of Super Rugby yet iirc. His partner in crime from the U20s, Kadin Pritchard, on the other hand played against Fiji and appears to be ahead in the Brumbies pecking order.
Bent the line on every carry. Doesn’t have to play this year for the Wallabies or next for that matter but with the potential he showed tonight I feel it is when and not if he earns a wallabies jersey
 

lpd

Bill Watson (15)
I'm not disagreeing that Jarrah McLeod had a fine game, but to be calling for him to be added to the Wallabies squad, as some are doing here tonight, is premature. He hasn't even played a agme of Super Rugby yet iirc. His partner in crime from the U20s, Kadin Pritchard, on the other hand played against Fiji and appears to be ahead in the Brumbies pecking order.
For sure - hopefully he keeps developing and is in the mix for the Brumbies next season
 

Sir Arthur Higgins

Bob Davidson (42)
Does anyone know if David Feliuai got injured right on the half time bell from that late tackle? Strange he did not come out for second half after playing so well. Mcleod did well though.
Get him some minutes. Send him on an Australian A tour and build him into a star in 2-3 years. We need a couple big ass backs in aus who can bust the gain line
 

Dan54

David Wilson (68)
That was fun watching (I did it this morning). Only comments are loved the concept of the In/PI team, great to see more.
Was pissed at first YC to Riley(didn't even think it was a penalty), but full disclosure, I thought the decisions in first test as no cards were right . I not into refs finding some reason to make these things cards. I didn't think Riley even made contact with head, or if he did after coming off shoulder ir was minimal. But all in all the In/PI team will be happyish (I know they prefer a W) they played with real pride and did themselves proud.


One other comment can Morgan Turunui give it a rest, his whining makes Justin Marshall sound fun!
 

KiwiM

Colin Windon (37)
One other comment can Morgan Turunui give it a rest, his whining makes Justin Marshall sound fun!

Agreed with this. There's understandably an eagerness by the Stan commentary for the Aus teams to do well on this tour but he's gone over the top - non stop whinging is grating

What an excellent game that was. It shows that with purpose and attitude a team brought together in one week can actually compete (looking at you AUNZ team....). I think it helped that a number of these players had experienced playing the Lions already on this tour. Plenty of lessons for the Wallabies to take away for Saturday and a few of those FNP players should be in the 23 on Saturday if there was a genuine chance for players to play their way in.
 

Homer

Charlie Fox (21)
Only chink in the armour is an apparent lack of interest in tackling. does have an impact otherwise.
Think you were watching the wrong guy. He missed one tackle out wide when covering but shot out of the line and put on some good shots, forcing the Lions to rush a few passes. Made a couple of double plays in defence as well and drove some attackers backwards. Not saying it was perfect but he threw himself at anything wearing red.
 
Top