Waratahs 2023
- Thread starter RugbyReg
- Start date
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
I can see how this isn't a bad signing but it fails to get me excited because I expect him to be suspended at some stage. I want the Tahs to go after a guy like Billy Pollard at the Brumbies. I could see him as the Tahs hooker for a decade.
I know they have Thomas Maka signed as well but after seeing the Aus U20s and that he has mostly been playing Colts for Gordon I think he has a lot more development to be done before he's up for senior team consideration.
Rae Rae
John S
Chilla Wilson (44)
Yeah, I've got similar reservations, maybe he has changed, but there's always going to be that niggle at the back of the mind.
I thought it would have been better as Rae Rae has said to look at some up and coming local hookers.
topgun
Billy Sheehan (19)
Ugh, I hope he was cheap. By any means he shouldnt be stepping ahead of Vailanu, he was great this year.
Eyes and Ears
Bob Davidson (42)
So has Horton been let go?
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
Well he's coming off a 11 week suspension in France and had another for Ref abuse before that. His team owner wanted him gone more than others wanted his signature.
Rae Rae
John S
Chilla Wilson (44)
Yeah, it's a real head scratcher why he got signed with his history (and even with his history at the Tahs)
I can't imagine he was expensive
I have two concerns
1/ the obvious is his attitude, what the f*ck has he done to demonstrate being given a chance?
2/ has he learnt to throw well at lineout?
The upside? At his best, he is one the best around the field unit playing 2 in the world but can't throw straight to save his life
Lets see how he goes, but I am quite dubious
I have two concerns
1/ the obvious is his attitude, what the f*ck has he done to demonstrate being given a chance?
2/ has he learnt to throw well at lineout?
The upside? At his best, he is one the best around the field unit playing 2 in the world but can't throw straight to save his life
Lets see how he goes, but I am quite dubious
Last edited:
Jimmyjam
Watty Friend (18)
Agree completely. Excellent player when on song, low cost, if it doesn't work out, then move him on. Could be a great redemption story ala Perese...
Coleman seems to be creating a fantastic playing culture that's bringing out the best in the players currently at the Tahs. Look at Holloway as a great example of a bloke suddenly fulfilling his potential. This could be another great story..... or not!
Froggy
Nicholas Shehadie (39)
Sorry, but I think this is a bad signing. I am all for giving a guy a second chance, look how well that's gone for the likes of Slipper and Perese. However this isn't a second chance, it's a 40th! This is a guy who is unable to control his actions, both on and off the field. He needs to get out of the high profile/high money world of international sport, get a real job and seek some psychological support.
Purely from a rugby point of view, I am very happy for the Tahs to continue to develop Vailanu as a second hooker option, and we then also have Horton.
Purely from a rugby point of view, I am very happy for the Tahs to continue to develop Vailanu as a second hooker option, and we then also have Horton.
Drew
Bob Davidson (42)
Thoroughly agree with Froggy! Why? We have the current Wallaby hooker, 2 very good back ups. We all love a redemption story, but Perese made a few mistakes (off field) at the beginning of his career. He cleaned up his act and has shown remorse. Whereas Latu has been consistently playing up on and off the field since Perese was in high school.
Edit: 2 decent back ups….
Edit: 2 decent back ups….
Last edited:
Jimmyjam
Watty Friend (18)
One Super Rugby standard back up in Vailanu, Horton currently not up to standard as a scrummager or thrower. Yes, solid around the park, but weakens the team at set piece unfortunately.
Latu has been foolish a number of times, but where is the downside for the Tahs? He screws up again then he is let go, but if he performs to his ability, then it's a massive improvement to the current back up hookers.... At his best he is the No. 1 hooker in Aust. He was close to the Wallabies best player in RWC 2019.
redblack
Larry Dwyer (12)
Thoroughly agree Froggy. Why wouldn't we target Billy Pollard (who is a sydney local) , he will be competing with one of Canberras favourite sons Noss Lonergan who will not be going anywhere. At least with the tahs he will get the opportunity for a starting jumper sooner rather than later. Vailanu is certainly worthwhile putting more time into.
redblack
Larry Dwyer (12)
Because we all know Lonergan will be No 1 there
Drew
Bob Davidson (42)
If he swears off the booze I might change my opinion.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
They also have Connal McInerney on the books. Lonergan and McInerney are both locals which would come into consideration at the Brumbies more than some other teams IMO.
I'd love to see a 20yr old Hooker come to the Tahs squad and get some more game time and sit behind Porecki who will be 31 by the end of the RWC. Vailanu still has quite a high ceiling and plenty of improvement still in him from what I've seen and Coleman is obviously a fan with him winning the Ken Catchpole Medal with Gordon in 2020 then taking him to the LA Giltinis.
Rae Rae