I don't quite know what to think after that game. It certainly was a high quality game, with Kaplan not taking any crap (but I thought both Moore and McCaw deserved cards at various points). However, a few bad decisions at crucial times let us down. The three that annoyed me the most;
1. Smith's grubber kick hot on attack in the first 10 minutes. I knew he was going to do this as soon as he got the ball, and of course it failed miserably- both in execution and the fact that it was never on to begin with. And then he did it again in the second half, in heavy traffic, and guess what? It failed. Someone needs to give him a kick up the arse and tell him to hold the fucking ball. He did not have his best game tonight.
2. Cordingley's pick and go. He may have seen something, but it was a bad call with no forwards in support. I thought his service was good all night, but his direction and decision making around the ruck let him down in a big way- the forwards had no idea what to do, and we often ended up passing to Benn Robinson standing flat footed 5 metres behind the advantage line with no-one in support. We missed Burgo.
3. Giteau's behind the head pass to Tuqiri, which went to ground and we lost the ball. At a crucial time it was a silly thing to attempt. He was 50/50 tonight- made some shocking errors (kicking dead off a penalty springs to mind) but set up two good tries. Pass mark, but Carter was a class above.
Other than that, a few defensive lapses (from Sharpe and Cross) largely cost us the game. Horwill and Brown (how good was he?) were our best, and naza I think you may have to eat some humble pie about Moore and Palu, as they were both ordinary. Our lineout was sensational, but Moore gave away at least 5 stupid free-kicks and was lucky to stay on. Cross was great with ball in hand, but made a couple of bad errors and let himself down.
Close but no cigar. OK under the circumstances (we badly missed Barnes) but I am still gutted. Well played NZ.