• Welcome to the forums of Green & Gold Rugby.
    We have recently made some changes to the amount of discussions boards on the forum.
    Over the coming months we will continue to make more changes to make the forum more user friendly for all to use.
    Thanks, Admin.

Wallabies Middle age meltdown?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Stu Wilsons Gloves

Stan Wickham (3)
Is there too much player power in Aus rugby? The snr players got rid of David Nuci in a putsch at the Brumbies (who have failed to impress since he left), maybe they are trying it on again? In a WC year that is pretty unimpressive if true. I doubt Deans will be Wallabies coach next year anyway you have to wonder sometimes how stupid the players actually are.

As for Gits, being an All Black supporter I would like to see hime start every game with Wycliff Palu.
 

Rob42

Nicholas Shehadie (39)
the players are the custodians of the game

Yes, but that's all players, from schoolboys to Wallabies. "Player power " set-ups like the former Brumbies, or the more recent Aust cricket team for that matter, are great for keeping the current stars happy and terrible for succession.

I don't agree with all of Robbie's selections, or use of substitutes, but overall, I'll take the medicine he's giving.
 
C

CanadianRugby

Guest
The thing that confused me about this article is where this belief that there is a "young player" policy instead of a "best player" policy. So Gits was benched? He was playing like crap and one benching doesn't make an entire policy. I don't really think there is one instance when you can say that one player was definately picked over another because of age. Considering the injuries before the tour, there wasn't a lot of choice anyway. I guess you could point to someone like Baxter who wasn't picked, but there are plenty of other reasons NOT to put Al Baxter on a Wallaby team. If you are claiming a youth policy then you have to do better than "Gits was benched against Italy"
 
O

OLDDOG

Guest
Yes, but that's all players, from schoolboys to Wallabies. "Player power " set-ups like the former Brumbies, or the more recent Aust cricket team for that matter, are great for keeping the current stars happy and terrible for succession.

I don't agree with all of Robbie's selections, or use of substitutes, but overall, I'll take the medicine he's giving.


Ive said it before, and I'll say it again. there were some great players in the wallabies, who thought they could stay forever, regardless of form and results. the player power group of mortlock, smith, giteau et al just lost the arm wrestle with robbie. he is the sort of guy who looks at the big, longer picture, younger guys are rewarded for effort and form is a requirement. the lads have been great players in their time, but there are now clearly more options available. I use again Berrick as an example.... did he spit the dummy about being dropped? no. he just dug deep, trained harder, got his chance, and took it with both hands to form an awesome pairing with quade in the last 2 tour games, if i recall correctly. giteau could do the same, but clearly dingo won't be dictated to, and I reckon if he wants a place in the team, HE HAS TO EARN IT ALL OVER AGAIN. The current batch that are brewing may be youngish, but boy, are they HUNGRY! there's a bit of experience too, with statesmen like sharpey lifting HIS game to new standards, AAC (Adam Ashley-Cooper) too. they only got better cos they had to, otherwise it would have been sayonara! that reporter has to be pally with gits I reckon......
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top