I did not say that White was not OK and in fact he has in part been excellent. He just is not a 9.5 as claimed.
White’s game deteriorated as he tried to take more responsibility to make things happen. His sniping can be better than good, he has easily the best box in Australia, I actually love his lip and constant reminder to the ref and opposition pigs, he tackles well.
White’s delivery can be great, but often fell apart as the forwards were controlled to provide slow ball. “OK, that was slow, let’s just take some time to re-set” is logical in context. Just not when it becomes repetitive. He also ended up taking way too many steps before the pass - which if combined with sniping might have been interesting, but that then didnt happen either.
Passing accuracy is another matter, can be good, but consistently when the going gets s tough.
JOC (James O'Connor) had nothing to do with White’s performance. Without reviewing the games, my gut reaction is similar with Hodge though the strategy around delivery was different then - Hodge made few passes for a 10 but the backline worked mostly.
White is an interesting figure. On one hand I could see the logic of making him Captain. On the other I can only nod my head with Reg.
@Reg, right or wrong Rennie has a stated target for kicking in his game plan with the half being a major contributor. Tate should well and truly have gotten the mail. Let’s see what he does with it. I understand the logic of a good coach needing to adapt his strategy and plan around the talent available. But an excellent player with world class potential may also need to adapt to fit a coaches intentions.