Just out of curiosity has anyone on the forum personally or had any friends play any Rugby in the US ? And if yes what clubs? Curious to hear about the club competition over there and the standard, and how far they may be off from having a fully professional competition? Seems like there are plenty of Aussies over there or that have been over there
I was born and raised here but was in the US for a long time. Happy days.
Played for, among others, San Francisco Golden Gate for nearly 10 years (2000-2009) during the early halcyon days of the Rugby Super League. The quality was very good to be honest.
As a marker in terms of quality - i'd say it was a handy / mid range 1st Grade D1 level here in NSW Subbies.
As a further indicator, I'm back now, i'm 38 years old and still playing in D1 Subbies.
NorCal Rugby is where its at - a lot of imports initially but that has changed dramatically over the last few years.
USA Rugby truly is the "Sleeping Giant". It just depends on when - or if at all - it wakes up.
Its home to a huge population base and could have access to some really amazing athletes, the key is as always, getting Rugby balls in the hands of kids rather than the norm - which is usually not until college.
It also has 2 other HUGE elephant in the rooms barriers.
1/ America is a litigious society - there will always be an over riding fear for Americans in allowing their young kids (and I'm talking 7/8/9 years olds) play Rugby as its perceived as a violent game. They will however let those same kids play Pop Warner Football - which is much more dangerous. Rugby is thought of as dangerous and as such if those kids get hurt i'm suing your ass. Go figure.
2/ Rugby is a flowing game - for the most part - scrum resets aside. But my thoughts on how to fix that should be on another thread. (Let's just say I'm a flyhalf - and the believe the forwards should just go and stand over the corner at set piece time, lean on each other and stay out of the way)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Stick Out Tongue :p :p"
Because it flows there is very little time during a telecast - aside from half time - to put in your 30 second Doritos or Budweiser commercial. Less advertising $ makes it harder to sell to TV networks which in tunr carry the game to a wider audience.
Get around these barriers (and get younger kids to play the game more frequently) and they have a shot.
Everything changed for US Soccer during the late 80's - early 90's.
So called "Soccer Mom's" were the catalyst for Bill Clinton and the Democrats victory in 92'.
These Soccer Mom's started having their young Children - (7/8/9 year olds) play Soccer as their first sport of choice - and consequently - 20 years later - the US Soccer team has until recently been in the top 10 in the world. (now 13th - still 2 places ahead of England - of which Soccer is their national pastime)
Don't poke the Giant.