U16/U19 Competition 2023
- Thread starter D-Box
- Start date
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
QLD always produce tall timber.
There is a clear skill difference man to man in this one.
Anyone who knows more about the QLD side. Are many of these boys playing 1st XV footy or 16s?
A lot of the NSW guys do and I’m wondering if it’s making a difference having played against/with boys turning 18.
There is a clear skill difference man to man in this one.
Anyone who knows more about the QLD side. Are many of these boys playing 1st XV footy or 16s?
A lot of the NSW guys do and I’m wondering if it’s making a difference having played against/with boys turning 18.
Majority of the side play 1st XV at their schools
RebelYell
Arch Winning (36)
Don't reckon this is overly fair. How many Vics at the RWC? Valetini, Leota, Uelese, Pone, Tuipulotu, even the Romanian 10.
Non-traditional states won't ever be consistent with huge stocks YOY but there's enough evidence of talent coming out of Vic in recent years to be extremely encouraged. If anything, this year is a slight outlier in terms of the Brumbies & Force levels.
HooperPocockSmith
Bill Watson (15)
I spy another aussie hooker that's great around the park but can't hit a barn door.....
Rudderless
Trevor Allan (34)
U16’s
NSW 38
QLD 10
U15’s
NSW 40
QLD 7
NSW 38
QLD 10
U15’s
NSW 40
QLD 7
Prodigy
Ron Walden (29)
100% they should.
HooperPocockSmith
Bill Watson (15)
Poor bloke. Looks like a bad one
Rugby follower
Billy Sheehan (19)
Geez the basic skills of some of our best u19 players are poor, bad passes, dropped balls, kicks charged down, crooked line out throws. You wonder what sort of coaching these players have received through junior levels. Maybe centralisation is needed to provide better coaching from a young age. Interesting that the ball runners are strong, maybe it was pass it to the big kids in juniors and forget about everything else.
yeah agree. This is scary. I was happy to excuse it in the 16s but this is pretty dire. Terrible attack structures by Qld in particular
Wilson
Phil Kearns (64)
I'd hoped they were just rusty last week coming off the bye and integrating the schoolboy reps but it's not looking much better this week. I guess they don't play too many games together which explains some of it, but not so much the quality of catch and pass and other basics.
The Ghost of Raelene
Simon Poidevin (60)
Don’t know how the forums go with Covid talk but I was talking to a coach of some girl’s basketball at a rep level around 16/17 years old and they have noticed a drop off in skills they think is a result of missing up to 2 years of coaching and meaningful play.
The 19s comp overall is very underwhelming. It’s a level that seems not far above the 16s with the obvious exception of size.
The 19s comp overall is very underwhelming. It’s a level that seems not far above the 16s with the obvious exception of size.
Wilson
Phil Kearns (64)
I hadn't thought of that but it makes a hell of a lot of sense. That and missing the interstate competition which really holds back the top guys and set piece development in particular.
Rudderless
Trevor Allan (34)
Under 19’s
NSW 31
QLD 19
NSW 31
QLD 19
Wilson
Phil Kearns (64)
I don't think anyone is contesting that, more observing that this generation looks a step down from recent ones even
Rudderless
Trevor Allan (34)
Next weekend
Round 4 of 5
Saturday
Force v Brumbies at Revo Fitness Stadium, WA
Sunday
Rebels v Reds at Box Hill Rugby Club, VIC
NSW bye
Round 4 of 5
Saturday
Force v Brumbies at Revo Fitness Stadium, WA
Sunday
Rebels v Reds at Box Hill Rugby Club, VIC
NSW bye
Brumby Runner
Jason Little (69)
Someone in particular? The Rebels' hookers had trouble with their lineouts on Saturday but mainly due to the dominance of the Brumbies' jumpers and the almost gale force wind blowing throughout the game.
On the subject of Hookers in that game, I thought Cameron Johns, the Brumbies reserve, was excellent. Looks to be the big bodied, aggressive style of player we have been lamenting as missing at higher levels lately. And the rolling maul from the 22m line that presented him with a try was a beauty to behold.