RedsHappy
Tony Shaw (54)
No not seduced RH, I stick by the primary issue - coaching. In among things I earlier called "trifles" are player performances. I think it's germane to point out the same players we praise on one hand can legitimately be criticised on another. Fans perspective on judging players then falls to either what is considered more important by the fan, or just as likely to cognitive biasses. Of which there are plenty when we start discussions over say, NSW bias, or Quade/Moore/Mumm/Hooper/Phipps hell even Fardy/Higgers etc.
Coaching is our thorn, but you cant really talk about the Wallabies without some discussion on the plyers.
Mate, I am absolutely fine with pages and pages of discussion re our elite players as individuals, who should be selected where and when, etc.
I just believe that 'selections' are not in any way the solution to our core Wallabies problems as at 2017 that are, for example, the difference between team stagnation and genuine team progression (a progression we have not truly seen since Deans departed despite a few performance 'spikes' that were not in any way subsequently consolidated into a new superior platform from which we notched up to the next level and held there).