Here To Do
Sydney Middleton (9)
I was thinking 1v4 and 2v3 and then a GF. But I’m all for this as Mosman and Convicts have also played a lot of games but haven’t had the success of the other 4.
Also presents opportunity for a great match up. LCOI beat Hills 22-21 last weekend so should be a cracker.
The main thing for me was not adding unnecessary games and rewarding teams who have already performedWhy not the following. Friday nights under lights.
Week 1.
Mjr Semi- 1 v 2
Mnr Semi- 3 v 4
Week 2
PF- Looser of Mjr v Winner of Mnr
Bowl GF- Mosman v Convicts
Week 3
Plate GF- Looser of PF vs Looser of Mnr
Halligans cup GF- Winner Mjr vs Winner PF
Probably don’t need the extra games in week 2 and 3 but nice to have a couple of games each week in the lead up to the other Finals
Colleagues VI are the clear "top" team in the comp: most wins 7-2 and equal-most 9 games (tied with Convicts II), on 35 points.
The next best team, Kings II, have the second most wins 6-1, second-most 7 games and 29 points.
Then there's a bit of a gulf, with LCOI only having 1 BP in their 5-1 record over 6 games for 21 points, but Hills III are right behind them thanks to a draw, with a 4-2-1 record from their 7 games and 20 pts.
You could also throw a Maccabi II v UNSW V game in there (both 4 GP with 1-3 records) but I've thrown Mosman VI and Convicts II a bone for their 8 and 9 GP respectively, despite Mosman's 1-7 record and Convicts' 0-9.
I'm not a fan of going "well, we want a 4 team finals so we're going to make clear leaders in Colleagues play a team 15 points down with a much worse record" - to me, those matchups above make the most sense to find the true "champions".
Also important is that teams have played fairly recently - Colleagues VI have played all but 2 rounds, INCLUDING the bye against Manly Savers, Kings, LCOI and Hills have also been very active and Hills have already booked a full bill of games for the coming weeks.
Having a look at the draw, Maccabi haven't played since the end of May so maybe UNSW V need a new opponent, but unfortunately there are no other clubs that have at least 4 games for them to meet ATM.
Over the next few weeks, I reckon we'll see a few changes to the above, but that's how things stand IMO ATM.