You're still not getting it.
Subbies rugby is about playing for the fun of it with you're mates. Premierships are great but good clubs keep on going comfortably without them.
Seriously, how sad must you're life be that you need to be paid to play park footy against a bunch washed up never were's (and proud of it) and guys well past their prime just looking to play slightly competitive matches in the sport they love.
Subbies has no place in the development pathway. Subbies is not for people with any kind of higher representative aspirations. Subbies is for FUN!!!
I'd love the sledging if payments were out in the open. "Hey Champ, couldn't hack in Shute Shield so you thought bashing a couple of over-the-hill old blokes makes you look cool?!?!?!"
There is Shute Shield (NSW), Premier Rugby (QLD) and John I Dent (ACT) for the blokes who think their good enough to be paid to play. For country guys unable to make their city move the Cockatoos are their pathway option.
At no point does Subbies factor into the equation. And the moment it does, Subbies will die. Because it's NOT why Subbies players play.
I apologise for the repetitiveness of this post but you really seem to be struggling with what Subbies Rugby is about
Seriously I understand your point that people play for the love of the game but I disagree that it is just to have a run with friends.
Subbies is for everyone. People who want to compete, people who want to talk dumb stuff, people who are lonely. People who are athletes.
Whoever you are, there's a place for you in Subbies.
Otherwise,
Why do people train twice a week a second opposed to just showing up like I n park cricket?
Why is the hallogans cup a joke as opposed to a 40 strong comp?
It's because some people want to compete, they are born that way.
Other people just want to tell their mates in a pub they coathangered Matt Giteu or some wallaby and put him in hospital.
Others, just want a weekend run and there's nothing wrong with either.
But don't tell me it's just and only just for fun
Back in the day Balmain would pay their players between 5 and 6 figure amounts to play in division one and put their body on the line.
These are people who needed to play to feed their families or pay rent in the Balmain area which is among the highest in Sydney.
But all that was taken away from a dumb decision by the powers that be because smaller, badly ran clubs had a whinge because they can't or weren't willing to cough up hard cash.
It's like the two brothers where one slammed clam and drunk vodka throughout their twenties whereas the other brother did a law degree over five years and worked up to 9 hours a day to get ahead, then the first brother whining that his finances aren't like his brother in his 40s and life's unfair!
In that metaphor, Balmain is the brother with the law degree.
Five years ago Balmain had star power, crowds in the thousands would come watch. Merchandise was sold, they would regularly make the paper and put subbies on the back pages of the mainstream media. The game had never been so healthy.
Nevilles from other clubs could boast to their children that they sidestepped Sebastian Chabal or knocked Ryan across out.
But that was all taken away to appease clubs who had no clue!
ANd you wantvto to talk about fun?
It's no fun getting belted every week for no cash, so players who just want to play for fun will race to the bottom and they will trigger to fill the A grades.
It's simple. Why can't we have paid first graders (If clubs wish) and fill the lower grades with the speds who just want to have fun and everyone in between?
Imagine, in my vision for the game, walking your dog at the local park and seeing half the wallabies squad line up for Balmain take on Epping with Japanese representatives.
Or Petersham with Ex state of origin players go up against say, Beecroft, who have nabbed an ex NFL star!
You trying to tell me this will reduce interest? No, numbers will be up and the game will never be so healthy.