It was one game, he will do betterAnd yet you think Staniforth is a better option?
Sent from my Nexus 9 using Tapatalk
It was one game, he will do betterAnd yet you think Staniforth is a better option?
Whatever the question, it is unlikely Holloway is the answerWasn't Holloway a lock before moving to 8?
Brumby runner rates him!
KOB, take a good look at my comments. I have never rated Tom in attack. He runs the ball a lot in a game but makes no territory gain. His strength lies in his ability to hold up a runner to create a maul. He is also a better than average lineout operator especially on the opposition throw. Sounds a lot like Rob Simmons, doesn't it? Except he is stronger than Rob.
Tom had run his time at the Brumbies and will not be missed. On balance, just an average Super player, but sarcastically will be a good chance of making the Wallabies now that he wears a blue jumper.
Yeah but Holloway looks good at NRC level and plays pretty wide and loose. He's a big unit and would serve the Tahs better if he was playing tighter and "heavier" I think. Plus, he has been used more as an impact player which flatters to deceive at times. I think he could be very good for them, but he hasn't really laid down a big marker to prove it yet. Not to mention all his injury / rehab time. Hopefully this year is a breakout year for him. Wells looked a bit "meh" tonight.
Good points but let's enjoy the win, I don't know what the crowd number was but at least from where I was sitting (and standing!) it was a very vocal crowd which was nice to see. I think the Tahs put themselves in the position to win and luck has very little to do with it, 2017 Tahs loose that game any day!Back home in the beautiful Blue Mountains after attending tonight's match. A few thoughts:
- The ground surface looked very good after all the crappy ones we've seen at Allianz over the years. It resembled a newly-sown lawn with a pale green shine on it, a bit too long for soccer and evenly-grassed over the whole pitch. A coupla scrums lifted up a few footmarks but there weren't any patches with wholesale damage. And no sand coming up in those footmarks.
- My pre-match fears about the front row were realised, unfortunately. Added to the front three the tight five were significantly lighter than the Stormers and it showed at the breakdown where the Tahs were out-muscled too many times. That Kitshoff's a beast, big (120kg), strong AND mobile. And he can catch a ball thrown at him.. My advice to the Tahs' coaches is this: choose a side for the props (I'd suggest 1 for Ryan and 3 for Robbo) AND LEAVE THEM THERE! And find some big bastards who like playing lock.
- How come with a multitude of players from the Force looking for a gig over east all we got was a winger and a young prop?, two slots where we really aren't short of local talent. What about a big lug for the second row? There were three good locks at the Force and we couldn't snag one of them, they went to the Rebels and Brumbies where their 2017 second row cupboards weren't exactly bare. The lack of physical grunt in our tight five will cost us this year. Latu, Kepu and Dempsey will go some way to addressing this concern but none of them play in the second row.
- Addressing the pigs first, Fitzpatrick and Han igan played well in the open, Robertson toiled away at the breakdown with some success, the second row and Wells were ineffective and Hooper was his usual energetic self. The replacement front row weren't much better in the scrums (OK, no better) although Roach was very active and physical in the open. Palmer and Holloway played quite effectively in the little time they had, in my opinion showing up the starters.
- Is Simmons required to do one stupid thing every match? He didn't let us, or himself, down there.
- Gordon, Beale and Folau were very good tonight, any one of these three would've been my MotM. Nice to see Kurtley underplaying his hand quite a few times. I was up the end where he went over under the posts, I thought his first touch of the ground when he slid over might've been a try yet Gardner and the TMO looked for a grounding when Kurtley tried to place the ball immediately afterwards.
- All the other backs, including Foley, had quiet games, Hegarty did a coupla good things when he came on but that was about it for all the other backs.
- Lineouts were good. Not surprising as Han igan is a very good lineout technician.
- Foley kicked well, nice to see.
- Far too much time was spent looking at contentious matters on the big screen. TMOs' involvements in matches needs to be addressed.
- That was a very arsey win, but I'll take it.
Thanks for that Cyclo, but KOB was actually referring to my opinion of Staniforth. I do agree with your comments about Holloway, but despite not yet having laid down a big marker, I believe he is the best option the Tahs have at No 8.
I have separately addressed KOB re Staniforth.
Really enjoyed that despite the typical early season mistake-fest from both sides. Biggest positive for me was the Tahs defence for 80 minutes, 100% up from last year (although that doesn't set the bar very high). I thought the backs generally were very good, with Beale the best, although I guess all that was to be expected. Ball security across the park was disappointing, although the same could be said for the Stormers.
The big worry is the tight five. 2nd row offered nothing, front row, particularly Robertson, were monstered. We will lose more than we win if the scrum doesn't massively improve. Kepu will help, but he's only one guy. And I'm inclined to think it doesn't matter who is in the front row if they are getting no weight from the locks.
Just a comment on Hanigan, who was copping a bit of a bagging during the game. It's become a bit of a right of passage here to criticise him (and at test level I tend to agree) but I didn't think he was too bad last night. Not MOTM, but was excellent in the lineout, took a wonderful take off our kick-off to retain the ball, scored that last try with real determination, and generally worked hard all night. Certainly not our biggest problem, unlike the five guys in front of him.
Congratulations to the 'Tahs. Didn't watch the game unfortunately.
Hoping the manner of loss irks the Stormers into something special next weekend. Eternal optimist I guess.
It was one game, he will do better
Sent from my Nexus 9 using Tapatalk
Fixed. It's more than just the FR (which struggled for sure).Can the Tahs scrum be that woeful after a week. They managed to get a penalty try awarded last week on a dominant scrum (albeit Rebels) and last night was just pure garbage from the front35 very frustrating!
Fixed. It's more than just the FR (which struggled for sure).