The torpedo
Peter Fenwicke (45)
Well AUS teams vs Chiefs games are just gonna go swimmingly........oh god pls help
Super Rugby 2017: matches not involving Australian teams
- Thread starter waiopehu oldboy
- Start date
- Status
Simon.
Bob Loudon (25)
It looked to me like Luatua's hit did start at shoulder height but then slipped up to neck height. Probably borderline yellow/red last season but definitely red this season.
A hell of a lot of games this season are going to be decided by the new laws. Worth a punt on the rank outsiders just on the off chance the favourites get a red in the first 10 minutes.
A hell of a lot of games this season are going to be decided by the new laws. Worth a punt on the rank outsiders just on the off chance the favourites get a red in the first 10 minutes.
But Kiwis never do anything with intent!
Good thing these guys know what a player is thinking, or not.
The torpedo
Peter Fenwicke (45)
But Kiwis never do anything with intent!
Good thing these guys know what a player is thinking, or not.
I mean, how DARE he imply that New Zealand rugby teams break the rules?
Inside Shoulder
Nathan Sharpe (72)
Very strange defence of him. I reckon it looked pretty intentional. The bloke never got the ball.
Hard to see any redeeming aspect except he didn't protest the punishment.
waiopehu oldboy
George Smith (75)
^^^^^^^^^^^ Didn't see the game & have only seen the FoxSports clip of Luatua's brain explosion (clear Red IMO, with or without the latest WR (World Rugby) directive), curious to know who the comms defending him were? According to the stuff.co.nz live update I saw even Kirwan was calling it Red while Skeen was reviewing it.
Interesting also that Bloos only trailed 9-15 prior to the Red & reportedly dominated the final quarter when they brought their AB benchies on so maybe it wasn't quite the reaming it appears at first glance (can't believe I'm somewhat defending the Queen City mofos, I must be getting soft in my middle age).
Interesting also that Bloos only trailed 9-15 prior to the Red & reportedly dominated the final quarter when they brought their AB benchies on so maybe it wasn't quite the reaming it appears at first glance (can't believe I'm somewhat defending the Queen City mofos, I must be getting soft in my middle age
).
Dismal Pillock
Michael Lynagh (62)
weirdly I thought the Blues solid D from Round 1 didn’t actually regress too much. The Chiefs jailbreak action was just goddamn dizzying. Sirens, dogs, flashing halogens, just sheer bloody terror. I don’t know the Chiefs schedule but they might ANNIHILATE some sides this season
Dan54
David Wilson (68)
Commentators were TJ, Goldie and JK, and they all said it Red as soon as it happened, JK just said it not normally his game, but didn't in anyway defend his action!
That was the way I heard it too. Not really even much debate that it would have been yellow in the past.
Clear red for me. No one should be complaining if that is consistently a red card this season.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
Hawko
Tony Shaw (54)
The Chiefs were very good, I wouldn't throw in the towel yet. I still think you'll get one of the wildcard spots (at the expense of the Highlanders).
My issue with the comms was the insistence by a couple that there was no intent (which they cannot know) followed by the "he's a good bloke" routine, as if that does or should make a difference. They should just be objective and say it was bad, it's red, that's it. And I am aware that lots of other commentators going round are just as bad on this or worse, which is also irrelevant.
waiopehu oldboy
George Smith (75)
Liam Squire looks to have done some damage to his previously-less-damaged knee. Lentjes having already gone off & the reserve hooker limping out if the warmups, they can't really afford to lose him as well as probably only Wheeler can cover flank/ 8.
waiopehu oldboy
George Smith (75)
WTF. 80% possession & Clan have barely been in our half, first time they get into the 22 they score under the dot. Clan 10-3 after 30ish.
waiopehu oldboy
George Smith (75)
Clan score again on the back of a grand total of 58sec in the CruSadist's 22. This just doesn't make sense, Clan should be looking up & contemplating how they're gunna come back from 15ish behind, instead they're probably wondering how they got to be 11 in front.
It is in this thread! I'm not sure about the other 13 teams in Super Rugby.
waiopehu oldboy
George Smith (75)
It's far too late but Dagg needs to go to 15, Clan are quite happy to kick it into Havili's zone 'cos they know he'll just truck it up & they can counter that easily. Or Sopoaga will kick-pass it to Fekitoa who doesn't drop it & feeds Naholo for the PI-trifecta try. Fuck me, 6-27 with 30 to go.
- Status